Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

'Disgusted with Marshall'

Sat Sep 19, 2015 7:29 pm

Absolutely shocking result today, I honestly believed we would win comfortably today. One man is to blame, and it's not the first time he has cost us. David Marshall should most definitely be ashamed and I hope Slade strips him of the captaincy.

He cost us at Chelsea in the prem, Forest last season, and he has cost us a possible point or three today. It's not good enough from a captain. I am fuming. We will now be without him for four vital games.

Rant over.

Re: 'Disgusted with Marshall'

Sat Sep 19, 2015 7:30 pm

I know how u feel.

Re: 'Disgusted with Marshall'

Sat Sep 19, 2015 8:10 pm

How did he cost us the Forest game? We won ffs. We were always going to lose against Chelsea, the best of keepers make mistakes. Neuer's made more mistakes than him over the past three seasons. What he did earlier was inexcusable but I've forgiven him, holding it against him will only make him perform worse, he probably feels like shit already.

Re: 'Disgusted with Marshall'

Sat Sep 19, 2015 8:37 pm

VincentTanOut wrote:How did he cost us the Forest game? We won ffs. We were always going to lose against Chelsea, the best of keepers make mistakes. Neuer's made more mistakes than him over the past three seasons. What he did earlier was inexcusable but I've forgiven him, holding it against him will only make him perform worse, he probably feels like shit already.


He cost us at Chelsea because if my memory serves me right we were 1-0 up at the time, or certainly 1-1. Poor English by me in reference to Forest. I was just saying that if the score had not been in our favour it could have cost us.

Re: 'Disgusted with Marshall'

Sun Sep 20, 2015 3:59 am

try watching the replay in slow motion you will see at no point does marshall kick out at Derbyshire marshall was swung around by him and his arm brushed his back . Derbyshire should have been booked for impeding marshall or rugby tackling him would be more accurate and we should have had free kick.
first seen it in sky sports news where all the panellists were amazed he was sent off

Re: 'Disgusted with Marshall'

Sun Sep 20, 2015 6:28 am

Absolute rubbish never a red card, derbyshire should jve been booked

Re: 'Disgusted with Marshall'

Sun Sep 20, 2015 7:40 am

For me Def not a penalty :o
But they were all over us by the end of the game it was one way traffic

Re: 'Disgusted with Marshall'

Sun Sep 20, 2015 8:05 am

Problem is Marshall is showing himself up as someone who is easily riled. Other teams might start niggling him knowing they'll get a reaction.

Re: 'Disgusted with Marshall'

Sun Sep 20, 2015 8:33 am

DM has made a huge mistake and will get a severe dressing down and probably a fine over his conduct. Yes it was costly in the context of the game vs. Rotherham but I have witnessed countless points he has earned us over the years with his outstanding goalkeeping.

Therefore putting the label of "Disgusting" against him is a little OTT. I'm as angry as the next fan over the result and if we are to challenge we can't throw away points against teams like Rotherham, but lets get a little perspective and remember Marshall is one of the best players we have.

Re: 'Disgusted with Marshall'

Sun Sep 20, 2015 1:41 pm

Tony Blue Williams wrote:DM has made a huge mistake and will get a severe dressing down and probably a fine over his conduct. Yes it was costly in the context of the game vs. Rotherham but I have witnessed countless points he has earned us over the years with his outstanding goalkeeping.

Therefore putting the label of "Disgusting" against him is a little OTT. I'm as angry as the next fan over the result and if we are to challenge we can't throw away points against teams like Rotherham, but lets get a little perspective and remember Marshall is one of the best players we have.


Yeah but he's only 11 years of age mate!

Re: 'Disgusted with Marshall'

Sun Sep 20, 2015 9:39 pm

James the bluebird fan wrote:Absolutely shocking result today, I honestly believed we would win comfortably today. One man is to blame, and it's not the first time he has cost us. David Marshall should most definitely be ashamed and I hope Slade strips him of the captaincy.

He cost us at Chelsea in the prem, Forest last season, and he has cost us a possible point or three today. It's not good enough from a captain. I am fuming. We will now be without him for four vital games.

Rant over.

Imagine where we would be without David Marshall. He was a big factor in our promotion, won us play off semi finals and saved us from having about 8 points in the Premier League. But no, a defeat against Rotherham is way more important than that.

Re: 'Disgusted with Marshall'

Tue Sep 22, 2015 12:03 pm

We beat forrest for a start and it was an honest mistake against chelsea