Thu Jul 09, 2015 6:24 am
Thu Jul 09, 2015 7:14 am
Thu Jul 09, 2015 7:38 am
KWest wrote:I thought he finished the season okay, but my god was he a liability at the start. At one point, I genuinely didn't think he belonged anywhere near the first team.
I don't agree with the school of thought here that he deserves to be a regular starter for us now, because I personally feel we have better quality at the club already, and could attract better quality too. That said, if ever he's going to prove me wrong, now is the time to do it.
Make no mistake, I'd love him to become a star for us, but right now I think people are really exaggerating his importance to us currently.
Thu Jul 09, 2015 7:47 am
Thu Jul 09, 2015 8:19 am
Thu Jul 09, 2015 8:40 am
Thu Jul 09, 2015 8:40 am
scooby1973 wrote:I can see Joe being a future captain ..
Thu Jul 09, 2015 8:48 am
Reza wrote:U two must be watching a different player,ralls has been one of our most consistent players last yr and made it impossible to drop come the end of the season,he's our only midfielder who looks like he's working his socks off,personally I think he'll play a much bigger part this season,and looking at the training videos it looks like he's been given the number 8 shirt this season
Thu Jul 09, 2015 9:11 am
Reza wrote:U two must be watching a different player,ralls has been one of our most consistent players last yr and made it impossible to drop come the end of the season,he's our only midfielder who looks like he's working his socks off,personally I think he'll play a much bigger part this season,and looking at the training videos it looks like he's been given the number 8 shirt this season
Thu Jul 09, 2015 9:19 am
Reza wrote:U two must be watching a different player,ralls has been one of our most consistent players last yr and made it impossible to drop come the end of the season,he's our only midfielder who looks like he's working his socks off,personally I think he'll play a much bigger part this season,and looking at the training videos it looks like he's been given the number 8 shirt this season
Thu Jul 09, 2015 9:39 am
Thu Jul 09, 2015 9:44 am
City Slicker wrote:I think he's class and can only get better and better. What a midfield we'd have if we built the midfield around him eith Gunnarsson and Adeyemi assisting, Dikgakoi DM and now Ameobi or Kennedy on the wing. Mouthwatering!
Thu Jul 09, 2015 9:47 am
OriginalGrangeEndBlue wrote:City Slicker wrote:I think he's class and can only get better and better. What a midfield we'd have if we built the midfield around him eith Gunnarsson and Adeyemi assisting, Dikgakoi DM and now Ameobi or Kennedy on the wing. Mouthwatering!
What no Whittingham?? I'm astonished!!!!
![]()
Thu Jul 09, 2015 11:31 am
Thu Jul 09, 2015 12:07 pm
Thu Jul 09, 2015 1:12 pm
llan bluebird wrote:Lot of time for Joe... One of the only genuine 442 central midfielders we have, so we play him on the left or as a full back obviously.![]()
Doesn't have the same touch or vision as Whitts, but his physicality and energy more than make up for it. This needs to be his break through season.
How the hell Slade will play Dikachoi is beyond me, even Whitts has more mobility, so to say he is ahead of Ralls in Slades rigid 442 is a mystery.
Huge Whitts fan (we need footballers at a football club) but this is his replacement. For me Whitts is over played and his performance drops hugely during the second half of the season because of this. A rotation based on opposition between Whitts Gunnar and Ralls would be my choice, although I wouldn't entertain 442, its 2015 !!!!
Thu Jul 09, 2015 1:29 pm
piledriver64 wrote:llan bluebird wrote:Lot of time for Joe... One of the only genuine 442 central midfielders we have, so we play him on the left or as a full back obviously.![]()
Doesn't have the same touch or vision as Whitts, but his physicality and energy more than make up for it. This needs to be his break through season.
How the hell Slade will play Dikachoi is beyond me, even Whitts has more mobility, so to say he is ahead of Ralls in Slades rigid 442 is a mystery.
Huge Whitts fan (we need footballers at a football club) but this is his replacement. For me Whitts is over played and his performance drops hugely during the second half of the season because of this. A rotation based on opposition between Whitts Gunnar and Ralls would be my choice, although I wouldn't entertain 442, its 2015 !!!!
I think the key to all of this is whether Slade continue to persist with 4-4-2 in every game. If he does then I think we will struggle whoever the personnel are from our current squad as I simply don't think we've got the type of players to do that successfully in either midfield or upfront.
I can't even remember the last team that got promoted from the Championship playing a permanent 4-4-2. Jones managed to finish 3rd with that system but he had a front 2 of Chops and Bothroyd who were playing well above Championship level at the time and way better than any pairing we could put up there at the moment.
If we play 5 in midfield then there is a better chance of Ralls getting, and succeeding in, one of the 3 central roles in my opinion.
Thu Jul 09, 2015 1:33 pm
Rydogsccfc wrote:piledriver64 wrote:llan bluebird wrote:Lot of time for Joe... One of the only genuine 442 central midfielders we have, so we play him on the left or as a full back obviously.![]()
Doesn't have the same touch or vision as Whitts, but his physicality and energy more than make up for it. This needs to be his break through season.
How the hell Slade will play Dikachoi is beyond me, even Whitts has more mobility, so to say he is ahead of Ralls in Slades rigid 442 is a mystery.
Huge Whitts fan (we need footballers at a football club) but this is his replacement. For me Whitts is over played and his performance drops hugely during the second half of the season because of this. A rotation based on opposition between Whitts Gunnar and Ralls would be my choice, although I wouldn't entertain 442, its 2015 !!!!
I think the key to all of this is whether Slade continue to persist with 4-4-2 in every game. If he does then I think we will struggle whoever the personnel are from our current squad as I simply don't think we've got the type of players to do that successfully in either midfield or upfront.
I can't even remember the last team that got promoted from the Championship playing a permanent 4-4-2. Jones managed to finish 3rd with that system but he had a front 2 of Chops and Bothroyd who were playing well above Championship level at the time and way better than any pairing we could put up there at the moment.
If we play 5 in midfield then there is a better chance of Ralls getting, and succeeding in, one of the 3 central roles in my opinion.
Bournemouth played 442.
Thu Jul 09, 2015 1:38 pm
2blue2handle wrote:He is certainly not a left back, id like to see him given more of a chance in the middle.
Thu Jul 09, 2015 1:57 pm
piledriver64 wrote:Rydogsccfc wrote:piledriver64 wrote:llan bluebird wrote:Lot of time for Joe... One of the only genuine 442 central midfielders we have, so we play him on the left or as a full back obviously.![]()
Doesn't have the same touch or vision as Whitts, but his physicality and energy more than make up for it. This needs to be his break through season.
How the hell Slade will play Dikachoi is beyond me, even Whitts has more mobility, so to say he is ahead of Ralls in Slades rigid 442 is a mystery.
Huge Whitts fan (we need footballers at a football club) but this is his replacement. For me Whitts is over played and his performance drops hugely during the second half of the season because of this. A rotation based on opposition between Whitts Gunnar and Ralls would be my choice, although I wouldn't entertain 442, its 2015 !!!!
I think the key to all of this is whether Slade continue to persist with 4-4-2 in every game. If he does then I think we will struggle whoever the personnel are from our current squad as I simply don't think we've got the type of players to do that successfully in either midfield or upfront.
I can't even remember the last team that got promoted from the Championship playing a permanent 4-4-2. Jones managed to finish 3rd with that system but he had a front 2 of Chops and Bothroyd who were playing well above Championship level at the time and way better than any pairing we could put up there at the moment.
If we play 5 in midfield then there is a better chance of Ralls getting, and succeeding in, one of the 3 central roles in my opinion.
Bournemouth played 442.
Not in every game they didn't. It was often 4-3-3, particularly at home.
I'm not saying 4-4-2 shouldn't be played, just not in every game no matter what the circumstances of the game or personnel available.
Thu Jul 09, 2015 5:14 pm