Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Who would you keep?

Fri Apr 17, 2015 12:07 am

Out of the current squad, who would you keep for next season? Here's mine. May be a few controversial choices but it's all about opinions :thumbright:

Keep

David Marshall
Simon Moore
Lee Peltier
Fabio
Ben Turner
Bruno Manga
Sean Morrison
Peter Whittingham
Anthony Pilkington
Kagisho Dikgacoi
Matthew Kennedy
Joe Ralls
Kadeem Harris
Eoin Doyle
Joe Mason
Kiko Macheda
Adam Le Fondre

Also Conor McAleny if we can get him on loan again.

Sell/Release

Declan John
Scott Malone
Danny Gabbidon
Matt Connolly
Aron Gunnarsson
Tom Adeyemi
Craig Noone
Stuart O'Keefe
Alex Revell
Nicky Maynard

Undecided on Kenwyne Jones, but think he'll leave anyway.

I'd expect Marshall and Manga to go though, and can't see Le Fondre coming back. That would leave us, without new signings, with a possible first team of this:

Moore
Peltier Turner Morrison Fabio
Kennedy Whittingham Ralls Pilkington
Doyle Mason

Re: Who would you keep?

Fri Apr 17, 2015 4:48 am

I would keep...

Marshall
Moore
Peltier
McNaughton
Manga
Turner
Malone (maybe)
Whittingham
Ralls
Adeyemi
Kennedy
Noone
Mason
Doyle


Get rid of...

Fabio, Morrison, Gunnarsson, O'Keefe, Macheda, Jones, Revell amongst others!

Re: Who would you keep?

Fri Apr 17, 2015 10:51 am

Keep

Marshall
Moore
Peltier
McNaughton
Manga
Morrison
Turner
Malone
John
Gunnarsson
Adayemi
O'Keefe
Ralls
Kennedy
Harris
Pilkington
Mason
Doyle
Revell

Get rid of

Connolly
Gabbidon
Fabio
Whittingham
Noone
Jones
Le fondre
Macheda

Re: Who would you keep?

Fri Apr 17, 2015 12:05 pm

Keep


Simon Moore
Lee Peltier
Fabio
Ben Turner
Matt Connolly
Matthew Kennedy
Aron Gunnarsson
Craig Noone
Joe Ralls
Tom Adeyemi
Kadeem Harris
Eoin Doyle
Alex Revell


Sell/Release
David Marshall
Bruno Manga
Sean Morrison
Peter Whittingham
Anthony Pilkington
Kagisho Dikgacoi
Declan John
Scott Malone
Danny Gabbidon
Stuart O'Keefe
Nicky Maynard
Joe Mason
Kiko Macheda
Adam Le Fondre
Jones

Re: Who would you keep?

Fri Apr 17, 2015 12:31 pm

I'd sell Fabio and Jones for starters. Fabio cannot defend and is totally unconvincing as a 'winger'. Jones forces us to play a certain way, which we need to change and use the likes of Doyle and Mason properly. Signing McAleny permanently is a priority.

Re: Who would you keep?

Fri Apr 17, 2015 2:44 pm

worcester_ccfc wrote:Out of the current squad, who would you keep for next season? Here's mine. May be a few controversial choices but it's all about opinions :thumbright:

Keep

David Marshall
Simon Moore
Lee Peltier
Fabio
Ben Turner
Bruno Manga
Sean Morrison
Peter Whittingham
Anthony Pilkington
Kagisho Dikgacoi
Matthew Kennedy
Joe Ralls
Kadeem Harris
Eoin Doyle
Joe Mason
Kiko Macheda
Adam Le Fondre

Also Conor McAleny if we can get him on loan again.

Sell/Release

Declan John
Scott Malone
Danny Gabbidon
Matt Connolly
Aron Gunnarsson
Tom Adeyemi
Craig Noone
Stuart O'Keefe
Alex Revell
Nicky Maynard

Undecided on Kenwyne Jones, but think he'll leave anyway.

I'd expect Marshall and Manga to go though, and can't see Le Fondre coming back. That would leave us, without new signings, with a possible first team of this:

Moore
Peltier Turner Morrison Fabio
Kennedy Whittingham Ralls Pilkington
Doyle Mason





Pretty much agree and the basis of a good squad, but can't agree with letting Gunnarsson or Adeyemi go

One of our players of the season and another I feel can make a big impact if given a run in the side :thumbup:

Re: Who would you keep?

Fri Apr 17, 2015 2:52 pm

I don't think it's a matter of who we keep, it's a case of who we bring in. There's 6 spaces in the team that need sorting this summer imo