Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

' Formation and players I would play '

Sun Jan 18, 2015 12:12 pm

Marshall

----- manga Turner Connolly

Brayford ------------------------ Fabio

-------- Adeyemi Gunnarson

---------------- Whitts

------------- ALF Revell

Use Morrison while Manga is away.

Have always been a fan of 4-2-3-1 and I think it would also suit us but I think our full backs would all be better as wing backs, meaning 3-5-2 suits them more.

Gunnarson played as an anchor man, Adeyemi using his energy to get around the field and press, Whitts playing further forward to dictate the play and create things but knowing he had Gunnarson and Adeyemi around to protect him.

Think ALF needs a bit of time on the bench but I wouldn't put any of our strikers ahead of him at the moment. Don't think Jones and Revell will work because neither are likely to run in behind.

Re: Formation and players I would play

Sun Jan 18, 2015 12:45 pm

Marshall

Brayford Turner Morrison Malone



Noone Adeyemi Gunnarsson Harris


Whitingham

Jones

Re: Formation and players I would play

Sun Jan 18, 2015 12:55 pm

All good thoughts. But after loosing Ravel and Daehli the only formation I see with our squad is a 4-5-1 and 4-3-3. Almost identical formations, but slightly more attack minded with the latter. Two biggest concerns Imo is the lack of movement in the team and the tempo moving the ball, and that needs addressing. No doubt Jones being striker in these formations, and wingers need to put a shift on the brake downs. Leaves players like Whittingham and Gunnarsson less exposed. But for all our suggestions we still will go with four, four f*cking two :cry:

Re: Formation and players I would play

Sun Jan 18, 2015 12:56 pm

Enola Gay wrote:Marshall

Brayford Turner Morrison Malone



Noone Adeyemi Gunnarsson Harris


Whitingham

Jones


This is the only real option, if this Hyland guy signs him to replace probably Gunnar.

Re: Formation and players I would play

Sun Jan 18, 2015 1:04 pm

RFMH wrote:
Enola Gay wrote:Marshall

Brayford Turner Morrison Malone



Noone Adeyemi Gunnarsson Harris


Whitingham

Jones


This is the only real option, if this Hyland guy signs him to replace probably Gunnar.

Big concern with the lack of mobility on top there isn't it? Hard to see how those two can create space and openings together.That Hyland guy is crap, just saying.

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Sun Jan 18, 2015 1:12 pm

Le Fondre!!!!! No thanks.

Re: Formation and players I would play

Sun Jan 18, 2015 1:18 pm

RFMH wrote:
Enola Gay wrote:Marshall

Brayford Turner Morrison Malone



Noone Adeyemi Gunnarsson Harris


Whitingham

Jones


This is the only real option, if this Hyland guy signs him to replace probably Gunnar.



I don't think Adeyemi or Gunnarson keep the ball well enough to play as a 2 in a 4-4-2 or 4-4-1-1

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Sun Jan 18, 2015 1:21 pm

It doesn't matter what formation we play. There is a dry rot throughout the club that will only be sorted by changes from top to bottom. We need a football philosophy, directors who understand the game, a manager who knows what he's doing and players who have the hunger and desire to succeed and who will run through brick walls for a manager they respect.

Right know we have none of the above.

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Sun Jan 18, 2015 1:57 pm

................Marshall..................
Brayford..Manga..Morrison..Malone
.......Adeyemi........Gunnarson......
..Noone........Harris......Pilkington..
..................Jones (c)................

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Sun Jan 18, 2015 2:25 pm

Marshall

Bradford manga turner Malone

Harris Gunnar adeyemi whites

Jones noone

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Sun Jan 18, 2015 3:23 pm

I'd bin the current 4-3-1-2 system we're going with, our midfield looks unbalanced and out of sorts, Noone is not a central attacking midfielder.

With players we've got I'd got with 4-5-1

Marshall

Brayford
Morrison
Turner
Malone

Harris
Adeyemi
Gunnars
Whitts
Noone

Revell

Keep us nice and compact in the middle, good work rate up top and two direct wingers out wide as our outlets. Sounds very simple but I think if players are well drilled and know their individual and collective roles then it gives you a platform to work from. At the moment I think we look a bit awkward.

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Sun Jan 18, 2015 3:49 pm

for me its got to be 5 - 3 - 1 - 1
moore
brayford Connelly Morrison (manga when back) turner john
adeymi gunnarsson ralls
harris
ravel
our full backs are wing backs so three central defenders are a must
adeymi and ralls either side of gunnarsson holding
harris down the middle feeding off ravel as he did at Norwich on Saturday
this team would give us more energy and pace
and ive not used any players I said I would sell in another thread
ie marshall Fabio whitts noone maynard macheda kimbo le fondre but the five I would bring in would be on the bench :bluescarf:

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Sun Jan 18, 2015 4:08 pm

................Marshall..................

Brayford..Turner .... Connelly ...Malone

.......Adeyemi........Gunnarson......

..Noone........Whitts.........Harris
..................Revell ....... ...........

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Sun Jan 18, 2015 5:41 pm

There is nothing really wrong with the formation we have now .

The problem is the way the players implement it during games and that infortunatly is slades fault and is
where we are going wrong .

his way of playing a 4-4-2 is lower league stuff and is too easy to counter when you have higher quality players in this league .

If he can find the right mix and work ethic needed we could be great with a 4-4-2

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Sun Jan 18, 2015 6:20 pm

................Marshall..................

Brayford..Turner .... Connelly ...Malone
................ Whitts
.......Adeyemi........Gunnarson......

..Noone.................Harris
...............Revell ....... ...........



Malky knew Whitts in a free role took the mick 2 seasons ago, until teams put a player on him. We heed another winger as Noone is shot, but we haven't got one

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Sun Jan 18, 2015 6:40 pm

Unfortunately we havent got sny quality to play with. The best of a bad job woukd be:

Marshall
Brayford
Turner
Morrison
Fabio
Adeyemi
Ralls
Gunnarsson
Harris
Noone
Revell

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Sun Jan 18, 2015 6:43 pm

Get some pace instead of noone who is a one trick pony and that would be the side i would go with

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Sun Jan 18, 2015 9:43 pm

KBK-13 wrote:Marshall

----- manga Turner Connolly

Brayford ------------------------ Fabio

-------- Adeyemi Gunnarson

---------------- Whitts

------------- ALF Revell

Use Morrison while Manga is away.

Have always been a fan of 4-2-3-1 and I think it would also suit us but I think our full backs would all be better as wing backs, meaning 3-5-2 suits them more.

Gunnarson played as an anchor man, Adeyemi using his energy to get around the field and press, Whitts playing further forward to dictate the play and create things but knowing he had Gunnarson and Adeyemi around to protect him.

Think ALF needs a bit of time on the bench but I wouldn't put any of our strikers ahead of him at the moment. Don't think Jones and Revell will work because neither are likely to run in behind.


It was going well then........ ALF are you fecking mental, he is SHIT. Statistically the worst player in the league :lol:

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Mon Jan 19, 2015 11:37 am

---------------Marshall---------------
Brayford -- Manga -- Morrison -- Malone

Adeyemi ---- Gunners

Harris ---------- Whitts/Pilks ---------- Noone

Revell

This or a simple 451. The way slade sets up we need to pack the midfield.

Re: ' Formation and players I would play '

Mon Jan 19, 2015 1:29 pm

KBK-13 wrote:Marshall

----- manga Turner Connolly

Brayford ------------------------ Fabio

-------- Adeyemi Gunnarson

---------------- Whitts

------------- ALF Revell

Use Morrison while Manga is away.

Have always been a fan of 4-2-3-1 and I think it would also suit us but I think our full backs would all be better as wing backs, meaning 3-5-2 suits them more.

Gunnarson played as an anchor man, Adeyemi using his energy to get around the field and press, Whitts playing further forward to dictate the play and create things but knowing he had Gunnarson and Adeyemi around to protect him.

Think ALF needs a bit of time on the bench but I wouldn't put any of our strikers ahead of him at the moment. Don't think Jones and Revell will work because neither are likely to run in behind.


Perfect line up. That's exactly the line up and formation I would pick. Fully agree with your reasons and everything you've said there too. :thumbup: