Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Player Ratings

Sat Jan 10, 2015 6:41 pm

Moore - 7 very solid performance and a clean sheet, if Marshall is off then we aren't short in that position.

Brayford - 6 really good considering he didn't have much in front of him
Morrison - 6 didn't really see the goal, dealt with most things well
Turner - 6 lead well, solid captain
Malone - 7 very confident debut

Adeyemi - 5 didn't offer much, didn't help Brayford
Gunnar - 6 a little lost at times but did the hard work when required
Whitts - 6 typical Whitts performance really, good ball for the gol, calm on the ball when required. A bit too poor in the final third.
Noone - 6 quite flat, needs Pilkington to balance the midfield. Worked well with Malone

Jones - 5 Did well, not sure why he was subbed, maybe injured?
ALF - 3 really becoming more and more like Eddie Johnson, Maynard, Mason or someone new please

Revell - 6 did really well, battled for everything won more than you'd expect.
John - 5 didn't have much to do
Harris - N/A

Re: Player Ratings

Sat Jan 10, 2015 6:43 pm

ho was the keeper on the bench?

Re: Player Ratings

Sat Jan 10, 2015 6:49 pm

Moore - 7 very solid performance and a clean sheet
Brayford - 8 Classy at this level
Morrison - 6 Still scares me defensively
Turner - 8 Should be captain
Malone - 7 Poor start, improved as the game went on

Adeyemi - 6 adds physical presence, not a wide midfielder though
Gunnar - 6 Fought well, but going through a rough patch
Whitts - 7 Classy touches, needs to dominate the game more
Noone - 5 Fans favourite, but crosses are just guesses,looked positionally lost

Jones - 6 Bit of effort must have bottomed him, plus it was cold
ALF - 5 Worked hard, but his job is to score goals,it just isn't happening


Revell - 7 liked the look of him

Re: Player Ratings

Sun Jan 11, 2015 12:45 pm

llan bluebird wrote:Moore - 7 very solid performance and a clean sheet
Brayford - 8 Classy at this level
Morrison - 6 Still scares me defensively
Turner - 8 Should be captain
Malone - 7 Poor start, improved as the game went on

Adeyemi - 6 adds physical presence, not a wide midfielder though
Gunnar - 6 Fought well, but going through a rough patch
Whitts - 7 Classy touches, needs to dominate the game more
Noone - 5 Fans favourite, but crosses are just guesses,looked positionally lost

Jones - 6 Bit of effort must have bottomed him, plus it was cold
ALF - 5 Worked hard, but his job is to score goals,it just isn't happening


Revell - 7 liked the look of him


This is pretty much how I saw it

Re: Player Ratings

Sun Jan 11, 2015 3:56 pm

Wilson from the under21s was replacement goalie on the bench

Re: Player Ratings

Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:16 pm

RFMH wrote:Moore - 7 very solid performance and a clean sheet, if Marshall is off then we aren't short in that position.

Brayford - 6 really good considering he didn't have much in front of him
Morrison - 6 didn't really see the goal, dealt with most things well
Turner - 6 lead well, solid captain
Malone - 7 very confident debut

Adeyemi - 5 didn't offer much, didn't help Brayford
Gunnar - 6 a little lost at times but did the hard work when required
Whitts - 6 typical Whitts performance really, good ball for the gol, calm on the ball when required. A bit too poor in the final third.
Noone - 6 quite flat, needs Pilkington to balance the midfield. Worked well with Malone

Jones - 5 Did well, not sure why he was subbed, maybe injured?
ALF - 3 really becoming more and more like Eddie Johnson, Maynard, Mason or someone new please

Revell - 6 did really well, battled for everything won more than you'd expect.
John - 5 didn't have much to do
Harris - N/A


Alf 3? Come on his work rate and tracking back deserves a 6. Finishing 3 yes. But overall 6.
Adeyemi 8 possible mom for me

Re: Player Ratings

Mon Jan 12, 2015 4:51 pm

Moore - 8 For me he did well and I would have no problems with Moore as our #1

Brayford - 7 A decent and solid performance. Dealt with most things that came down his wing. A couple of slip ups
Morrison - 7 Another decent defensive showing. Got a goal and did well to get in position and mostly unmarked
Turner - 7 Yet another 7 in defence for me. They didn't do much wrong and I think Turner as Captain helped a solid back 4
Malone - 8 Great vision, solid in defence and not lacking in effort. calmly cleared the ball upfield when required and had a few good runs

Adeyemi - 5 Pretty standard showing from what I saw
Gunnar - 6 Non descript for most of the game and didn't see too much from normal play. BUT his long throws troubled and led to our goal
Whitts - 4 I didn't see anything I liked from Whitts on Saturday. Out of position, constantly on his wrong foot and the main reason for our loss of posession from what I could see
Noone - 7 Some great work fron Noone. Some lovely runs up the left and not afraid to take people on. Certainly game them trouble int he second half

Jones - 5 Didn't see much of Jones. Looked like he'd taken a knock and though he did well with ball retention, didn't really stand out for me.
ALF - 6 Unlucky not to score. Had one wonderful chance and has been marked down for a laughable attempt instead of laying off to the side for Kenwyne to blast it in. Never stopped running, never stopped working.

Revell -8 Second new signing and a second great performance from them. Great work rate, good vision and great link up play.
John - 5 Didn't see too much of the ball. had a shaky few minutes before becoming just standard
Harris - had about.............that long on the pitch...


I'd like to see what Revell and Le Fondre can do with a full 90. the links between them worked well and they caused some worries for Fulham