Poll: Do you want Paul Hartley as our next manager?

With Paul Hartley now Favourite, what are your views on this. Do you want him to take over from Ole?

No thank you. Nothing against him personally but I hope the club do not gamble with someone not proven at Championship/ Premiership level and instead they appoint a manager who has a PROVEN record with experience. There are many out there that fit the bill who are out of work!

No thank you. Nothing against him personally but I hope the club do not gamble with someone not proven at Championship/ Premiership level and instead they appoint a manager who has a PROVEN record with experience. There are many out there that fit the bill who are out of work!

Spot on, nothing against him but we need someone with experience to stop the slide firstly then push on.

Probably a nice guy, but this would be out of the frying pan and into the fire... Another unproven unknown... People didnt want Lennon yesterday because he had only managed celtic to league titles and last 16 in champ league, so why a league 1 play off winner?

Why would anyone vote for this guy?
We've just had a 'bright exciting young manager' why would we want to try another one?
Get Pullis in to get some pride, fight & organisation back.

Perhaps the jacks are voting.

With Paul Hartley now Favourite, what are your views on this. Do you want him to take over from Ole?

May as well appoint my mother and 95 year old granny. Anyway, he's scottish and they want independance - so he should remain up there!

What had Malky achieved when he took over, nothing! He just managed Watford!

Paul Hartley has achieved a lot in Scotland with promotions managing both Alloa and Dundee and he's done this with No money!!! Don't dismiss this guy, there are not many who have managed this successfully with 2 different clubs at such a young age - there must be something about him!

What had Malky achieved when he took over, nothing! He just managed Watford!

Paul Hartley has achieved a lot in Scotland with promotions managing both Alloa and Dundee and he's done this with No money!!! Don't dismiss this guy, there are not many who have managed this successfully with 2 different clubs at such a young age - there must be something about him!

Ole had won the Norwegian league twice too... As well as manged utd reserves prob worth as much ad the whole Scottish league.... Still unproven at prem & champ level and where did it get us? Hartley may well be a decent manager in time to come, but that's not what we need now.. We don't have time to mentor an unproven guy. We need an already established person....

What had Malky achieved when he took over, nothing! He just managed Watford!

Paul Hartley has achieved a lot in Scotland with promotions managing both Alloa and Dundee and he's done this with No money!!! Don't dismiss this guy, there are not many who have managed this successfully with 2 different clubs at such a young age - there must be something about him!

I suppose that is one crumb of comfort. I still want Pulis though.

What had Malky achieved when he took over, nothing! He just managed Watford!

Paul Hartley has achieved a lot in Scotland with promotions managing both Alloa and Dundee and he's done this with No money!!! Don't dismiss this guy, there are not many who have managed this successfully with 2 different clubs at such a young age - there must be something about him!

Based on that we may as well appoint a Welsh League manager!

SCOTTISH FOOTBALL!!!

Parks at best!

I am going to fly against everything I believe now but my Celtic supporting mate suggests Hartley is an inspired choice.

He wanted Hartley as the Celtic manager after Lennon. He has not put a foot wrong.

Still should be Pulis though.

i would rather have JR Hartley ( One for the older guys )

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nv1VQ7uSC-s

Do any of us know enough about the man to make a reasoned judgement on his possible recruitment as City manager.
It's a big call and could go tits up or it could be an inspirational choice.
I didn't vote as above because of lack of knowledge about the man.

i would rather have JR Hartley ( One for the older guys )

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nv1VQ7uSC-s

I believe he finally found some old book and went Fly Fishing, mate!

i would rather have JR Hartley ( One for the older guys )

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nv1VQ7uSC-s

I believe he finally found some old book and went Fly Fishing, mate! [/quote]

Gutted

Played for the Worzels, didn't he?

Neil Eardly

Neil Eardly

If pullis does want the.job and weve gone for him then thats an.absolute joke

I am going to fly against everything I believe now but my Celtic supporting mate suggests Hartley is an inspired choice.

He wanted Hartley as the Celtic manager after Lennon. He has not put a foot wrong.

Still should be Pulis though.

Wete talking league.1 standard football tops it doesnt matter what he thinks celtic are shit anyway. we need someone whos been there

@BBCBMcLauchlin: Dundee boss Paul Hartley has turned down the chance to become manager of Cardiff City. More soon #bbcsportscot

Does Tan read this forum? The poll is pretty conclusive with all due respect to 'yes' voters (and the odd closet Jakk).

Please appoint a credible grafter who has a CV including at least success in the English league.

Just saying.

@BBCBMcLauchlin: Dundee boss Paul Hartley has turned down the chance to become manager of Cardiff City. More soon #bbcsportscot

So that's that then. The bookies do get it wrong!

Now let's get back to planet Earth where Pulis is still available. Go get him Vinnie!

No. There is only one man for the job and that man is TP. Get it done now City.