Keepers: John Hallworth, Neal Alexander or David Marshall

Who do you rate the best of City's Goalkeepers?? Got to be Marshall, though the other 2 were special at their levels!

What about ,Gavin Ward ?

David Marshall. Best keeper I've seen in a City shirt since my first game in 88.

Hallworth for me spent many games chanting this when we was shit

Hallworth sort em out, Hallworth Hallworth sort them out.

hallworth for me was a hero when i was a kid, used to love him

but for me super neil alexander, him and kav are my all time favourate players

Hallworth and Neil were decent keepers - (although Neil couldnt save penalties lol) - but Marshall, in my opinion, is a mile above these two.

The only two keepers who come close, again in my opinion, are Ron Healey/Bill Irwin.

Marshall for me with Alexander a close second but Roger hansbury doing cartwheels at Cardiff arms park had a great rapport with the fans and a good keeper to boot

Yea i agree. Mark Grew for his save in '94against Man City. And George Wood, he's got no hair but we dont care...all stood out as given their all for the shirt.

...actually lets not forget Andy Dibble and also Champions League Medal Winner Ross Turnbull

Bill irwin Ron Healey andy dibble

Bill Irwin

What about ,Gavin Ward ?

I agree

David Marshall for me, but I have liked all of them

Okay, Okay.

Someone's going to say it so it might as well be me.

Peter Zois.

What about Tony Elliott 'The axe man'

Ron Healey.

Who remembers Roger Hansbury

Local boy Mel Rees a brilliant young keeper with a great future ahead of him tragically died of cancer at the young age of 26 just over twenty years ago.

Bill irwin Ron Healey andy dibble

You forgot Fred Davies!

Roooon Heeealy

Always seem to have done well for keepers in recent years, however when we've had a bad one we've a terrible one

Not forgetting Heaton to the list too, he was a good keeper but sadly for him Marshall just smashed it in the end

your all mad , anybody forgetting Tony Warner & arran lee-barrett

no mention of Roger Handsbury or Mark Grew haha

What about Konstantopoulos always remember his blunder at Wolves

Marshall best ive see

Stephen Bywater. End of thread.

Stephen Bywater. End of thread.

Used to love Neil Alexander, but Marshall has to be the best of the three.

:o no mention of Roger Handsbury or Mark Grew haha

Look above a few posts up

Who remembers Roger Hansbury

I do

Definitely my top 3 favourite keepers these 3. My most enjoyable days were with Alexander in goals but I'd have to say Marhsall is by far the best Keeper out of the 3.