Who would you rather keep?

Ok, chances are we'll lose both.

But if we got to keep one, between Caulker and Medel, who would you choose?

Not included Marshall, because he'll stay IMO.

Caulker would still give his all, no matter our division. Not sure Medel would do the same.

Medel. Very good player but made the scapegoat by a lot on here. If we were to go back up straight away he would have a great season surrounded by some better players.

I think we'd get more for Caulker as he's one of the best young British centre halfs. Plus we've got enough quality at CB for the Championship

Were we really that much a better team with Medel & Caulker ? Would the team of last Christmas beat the team of the previous Christmas.......

Were we really that much a better team with Medel & Caulker ? Would the team of last Christmas beat the team of the previous Christmas.......

yes

Caulker.

Medel's price will go up every match Chile win so we should use that to our advantage.

Get the money for them them and let them go.