Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Who would you sell?

Thu May 29, 2014 11:39 pm

For me,

Connolly
Medel
Kim maybe
Cowie
Jones
Gunnarson
Lewis
Campbell obviously wants to go
Caulker
Marshall (for the money we are rumoured to get)

Re: Who would you sell?

Fri May 30, 2014 1:02 pm

Id only sell Campbell, Loaning a lot out could be a good option. The current squad we have is good enough 8-)

Re: Who would you sell?

Fri May 30, 2014 3:26 pm

Medel
Jones
Campbell
Caulker
Mason
Mutch

I'd also bring in a midfield enforcer, or 2. We also need a speedy centre back.

Re: Who would you sell?

Fri May 30, 2014 5:07 pm

DrBlue wrote:Medel
Jones
Campbell
Caulker
Mason
Mutch

I'd also bring in a midfield enforcer, or 2. We also need a speedy centre back.


Connolly - sell for a reasonable price
Taylor - keep as cover
Medel - sell for a good price after a good world cup
Kim - sell for a reasonable fee after a good world cup
Cowie - only sell if we get a reasonable offer
Ktc - sell for reasonable price
Jones - I will pay to get shot of big wage bill- sorry not rated
Gunnarson - keep as cover (hope he gets his throw in's back)
Wittingham -sell if we get a good offer
Campbell -sell if we get a good price, obviously he wants away?
Caulker - sell if we get a good price
Marshall - sell only if he gets a good premier team as First choice keeper and wants to leave and we get a good price

Defo Keep :-

Moore
Cala
Hudson
Turner
Fabio
John
Oshilaja
Brayford
Noone
Mutch
Mason
Rall's
Harris
+ the 4 new signings + Top quality premiership centre half.

Hopefully we can keep Marshall as a top asset. Otherwise we need to spend on a top keeper.

Blooobirds Forever !!! :old: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :thumbup:

Re: Who would you sell?

Fri May 30, 2014 6:06 pm

Try to create two teams really

Moore
Brayford New CB Cala Fabio
Noone new CM Whitts Dæhli
Le Fondre Guerra

Lewis
McNaughton Hudson Turner John
Kim Gunnar Eikrem Burgstaller
Mason Macheda

Are two ok squads. Selling or loaning out Marshall, Caulker, Medel, Mutch, Campbell, KTC, Connolly, Berget, Nugent, Ralls, Maynard, Jones and Velikonja.

22 players is a touch too thin though so utility players like Conolly. Ralls and Berget would probably stay taking it to 25.

Personally I'd prefer a new CB, two new midfielders and a new goalkeeper so another four players getting out squad to about 27 which is what the championship needs.

Re: Who would you sell?

Fri May 30, 2014 7:17 pm

powysblue wrote:
DrBlue wrote:Medel
Jones
Campbell
Caulker
Mason
Mutch

I'd also bring in a midfield enforcer, or 2. We also need a speedy centre back.


Connolly - sell for a reasonable price
Taylor - keep as cover
Medel - sell for a good price after a good world cup
Kim - sell for a reasonable fee after a good world cup
Cowie - only sell if we get a reasonable offer
Ktc - sell for reasonable price
Jones - I will pay to get shot of big wage bill- sorry not rated
Gunnarson - keep as cover (hope he gets his throw in's back)
Wittingham -sell if we get a good offer
Campbell -sell if we get a good price, obviously he wants away?
Caulker - sell if we get a good price
Marshall - sell only if he gets a good premier team as First choice keeper and wants to leave and we get a good price

Defo Keep :-

Moore
Cala
Hudson
Turner
Fabio
John
Oshilaja
Brayford
Noone
Mutch
Mason
Rall's
Harris
+ the 4 new signings + Top quality premiership centre half.

Hopefully we can keep Marshall as a top asset. Otherwise we need to spend on a top keeper.

Blooobirds Forever !!! :old: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :thumbup:

Glad you're not the manager. You've just put most of our midfield up for sale. :lol:

Re: Who would you sell?

Fri May 30, 2014 7:53 pm

Campbell - 2.5 million unless the rumours about the release clause is true
Jones - free
Mutch - 6 million
Caulker - 10 million
KTC - 1.5 million
Medel - 6 million
Taylor - 500k

Hope Marshall stays and will be disappointed if he goes for less than 10 million

Re: Who would you sell?

Fri May 30, 2014 8:04 pm

Glad you're not the manager. You've just put most of our midfield up for sale. :lol:


I think we have to remember that we are now in the championship and we have to save some money, so selling some assets, deadwood or large wage takers would make sense if the price was right - we need a team for the championship.

How can you say we would not have enough Midfielders?

Cowie
Gunnerson
Dahali
Berghet
Mutch,
Noone
Burgenstaller
Eikram
Harris
Zaha

That's 10 midfielders without any extras Ole may bring in the summer. How many more do we need FFS ?

Blooobirds Forever !!! :old: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :thumbup:

Re: Who would you sell?

Sat May 31, 2014 7:40 am

powysblue wrote:Glad you're not the manager. You've just put most of our midfield up for sale. :lol:


I think we have to remember that we are now in the championship and we have to save some money, so selling some assets, deadwood or large wage takers would make sense if the price was right - we need a team for the championship.

How can you say we would not have enough Midfielders?

Cowie
Gunnerson
Dahali
Berghet
Mutch,
Noone
Burgenstaller
Eikram
Harris
Zaha

That's 10 midfielders without any extras Ole may bring in the summer. How many more do we need FFS ?

Blooobirds Forever !!! :old: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :thumbup:


Zaha?

Re: Who would you sell?

Sat May 31, 2014 7:46 am

Powys I think you left them midfielders out of your original keep / sell post ??????????? :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :bluescarf: :ole:

Re: Who would you sell?

Sat May 31, 2014 9:27 am

Most notably Mutch. Because I identify him as the most likely to steeply become worse in a short amount of time, his slump at the season's end in Premier the warning sign. He can command a considerable fee right now; but the next time the chance arrives he most probably won't.

Thus, not selling Mutch could be a major loss.

Other than that, among the large amount of squad players, I only see Gunnarsson, Campbell, Kim and Berget as worth keeping.

The 'must keep' list:
-Noone
-Dæhli
-Fabio
-Whittcream (Whittingham and Eikrem)

Pretty short.

Re: Who would you sell?

Sat May 31, 2014 9:42 am

powysblue wrote:Glad you're not the manager. You've just put most of our midfield up for sale. :lol:


I think we have to remember that we are now in the championship and we have to save some money, so selling some assets, deadwood or large wage takers would make sense if the price was right - we need a team for the championship.

How can you say we would not have enough Midfielders?

Cowie
Gunnerson
Dahali
Berghet
Mutch,
Noone
Burgenstaller
Eikram
Harris
Zaha

That's 10 midfielders without any extras Ole may bring in the summer. How many more do we need FFS ?

Blooobirds Forever !!! :old: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf: :thumbup:

You had Cowie and Gunner up for sale in your original post. Zaha is not even ours :lol: :oops: you're a right beaut by the looks.

Re: Who would you sell?

Sat May 31, 2014 9:59 am

Metal Handkerchief wrote:Most notably Mutch. Because I identify him as the most likely to steeply become worse in a short amount of time, his slump at the season's end in Premier the warning sign. He can command a considerable fee right now; but the next time the chance arrives he most probably won't.

Thus, not selling Mutch could be a major loss.

Other than that, among the large amount of squad players, I only see Gunnarsson, Campbell, Kim and Berget as worth keeping.

The 'must keep' list:
-Noone
-Dæhli
-Fabio
-Whittcream (Whittingham and Eikrem)

Pretty short.

Please never ever ever use the word whittcream again :lol:
Eikrem has along way to go before he will ever be compared to whitts

Re: Who would you sell?

Sat May 31, 2014 10:15 am

Bluebird86 wrote:
Metal Handkerchief wrote:Most notably Mutch. Because I identify him as the most likely to steeply become worse in a short amount of time, his slump at the season's end in Premier the warning sign. He can command a considerable fee right now; but the next time the chance arrives he most probably won't.

Thus, not selling Mutch could be a major loss.

Other than that, among the large amount of squad players, I only see Gunnarsson, Campbell, Kim and Berget as worth keeping.

The 'must keep' list:
-Noone
-Dæhli
-Fabio
-Whittcream (Whittingham and Eikrem)

Pretty short.

Please never ever ever use the word whittcream again :lol:
Eikrem has along way to go before he will ever be compared to whitts


Nah, Eikrem has comparable if not better passing and set piece abilities already, Whittingham is stronger, with more experience and a better tackler, all their attributes added together and they're roughly the same, but Whittingham will remain first choice until Eikrem builds more muscle.

That Eikrem will be better than Whitts is right now when he reaches his current age, I have no doubt of.

Also 'Krem' means Cream in Norwegian so it just popped to mind.

Re: Who would you sell?

Sat May 31, 2014 11:14 am

Vincent Tan :thumbup:

Re: Who would you sell?

Sat May 31, 2014 2:03 pm

It's not just about who is good enough it's also about who fits into ogs brand of football. I would guess players who aren't comfortable on the ball will struggle to get into his team. Such as Gunnar, turner and ktc.

Re: Who would you sell?

Sat May 31, 2014 2:37 pm

Marshall for big money
Taylor
Campbell if we get a good offer and good cover. Id personally like him to stay.
Kiss
Cowie released
Gunnar is we get a decent replacement
Medel & Caulker for good money
Kimbo

Re: Who would you sell?

Sat May 31, 2014 3:24 pm

Marshall - Sell - Hope for 7-12m then

Connolly - Sell of fee - Would hope for 500k
Theophile - Sell - Any kind of Fee - Would hope for 500k
Caulker - Sell - 8m - Any extra would be a bonus
Nugent - Allow to Leave on a free if any interest

Medel - Sell - Anything between 4-6m
Kim - Sell - Anything between 1-2m
Mutch - Sell - Around 5m
Gunnarrson - Sell - Around 1-2m

Campbell - Id like to keep but it seems he will go for around 1m
Mason - Sell - Around 1m (with sell on clause)
Maynard - Sell - Around 500k to 1m


Loan out for full seasons
John
Moore
Oshilaja

Re: Who would you sell?

Sun Jun 01, 2014 5:58 am

Marshall
Theo
Taylor
Caulker
Medel
Whittingham
Cowie
Jones
Campbell
Hudson
Smith
Maynard
Berget
Gunnarsson
..............................and keep John Toshack! Maybe the likes of Liverpool will snap him up for a good price one day!

Re: Who would you sell?

Sun Jun 01, 2014 6:00 am

Marshall
Theo
Taylor
Caulker
Medel
Whittingham
Cowie
Jones
Campbell
Hudson
Smith
Maynard
Berget
Gunnarsson
..............................and keep John Toshack! Maybe the likes of Liverpool will snap him up for a good price one day!