Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 5:16 pm

Squad:

GK Lewis, Moore (We will need to replace Marshall if he goes)
RB Brayford, McNaughton and Fabio back up (Let go of KTC)
LB Fabio, Taylor, John
CB Hudson, Cala, Turner, Connolly, Nugent (We'll lose Caulker)
CM Gunnarson, Whitts, Cowie, Eikrem, Kiss (We'll lose Medal)
AM Noone, Kim, daehli, Harris, Ralls, Mutch, Zaha?
ST Campbell, Mason, Maynard, Berget, Velikonja (Get rid of Jones)

Possible XI

GK: Marshall?
LB Fabio
CB Cala
CB Turner/Hudson?
RB Brayford
CM Whitts
RM Noone
LM Daehli
CAM Mutch
ST Campbell
ST Maynard

:thumbright:

We need to let go of players like Cowie and Gunnarson, also we have to reduce the wage bill getting rid of players like Jones which is on summin like 30k a week :o

Players IN ?

Need another CM and maybe a CB depending on players leaving
Who's do you wanna see IN?

:bluescarf:

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 5:31 pm

Aye we ought to go in for that young Bolton striker,not Rhodes,the other one.(name escapes me :lol: )

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 5:35 pm

Id like to see Mcmanaman from Wigan here.

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 5:45 pm

Think what will happen is that newly promoted teams and a few of the lower premier clubs will be looking at your squad, and honestly believe you will lose Marshall, Caulker,Mutch,Medel and Cala.

It all depends on Solskjaer if he can persuade them to stay, but I think Marshall will go, he's got a taste for it. I hope that Mr Tan doesn't allow Cardiff to go the way. of Leeds and to some extent Southampton,

As for Jordan Rhodes if he goes anywhere it will be to a premier club, he's got the ability but has he got the ambition, as can be seen by going to Blackburn.

Malky had assembled a squad to get promotion, but didn't really have the nous to recruit players to consolidate, as much as I like him I think Cardiff needed a Pullis type manager when they outed Malky. Pullis would have dragged Cardiff through the rough patch as he has done for Palace, it's not pretty football but it is effective. I hoping you bounce straight back, but with Tan anything could happen

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 5:57 pm

JD Bluebird 4 life ! wrote:Squad:

GK Lewis, Moore (We will need to replace Marshall if he goes)
RB Brayford, McNaughton and Fabio back up (Let go of KTC)
LB Fabio, Taylor, John
CB Hudson, Cala, Turner, Connolly, Nugent (We'll lose Caulker)
CM Gunnarson, Whitts, Cowie, Eikrem, Kiss (We'll lose Medal)
AM Noone, Kim, daehli, Harris, Ralls, Mutch, Zaha?
ST Campbell, Mason, Maynard, Berget, Velikonja (Get rid of Jones)

Possible XI

GK: Marshall?
LB Fabio
CB Cala
CB Turner/Hudson?
RB Brayford
CM Whitts
RM Noone
LM Daehli
CAM Mutch
ST Campbell
ST Maynard

:thumbright:

We need to let go of players like Cowie and Gunnarson, also we have to reduce the wage bill getting rid of players like Jones which is on summin like 30k a week :o

Players IN ?

Need another CM and maybe a CB depending on players leaving
Who's do you wanna see IN?

:bluescarf:



GK Lewis, Moore (We will need to replace Marshall if he goes)
RB Brayford, McNaughton and Fabio back up (Let go of KTC, McNuaghton and Fabio)
LB Fabio, Taylor, John (let go of Fabio and Taylor)
CB Hudson, Cala, Turner, Connolly, Nugent (We'll lose Caulker, let Hudson go))
CM Gunnarson, Whitts, Cowie, Eikrem, Kiss (We'll lose Medal, let Gunnarsson, Cowie, Eikrem and Kiss go))
AM Noone, Kim, daehli, Harris, Ralls, Mutch, Zaha (boot Zaha back!)
ST Campbell, Mason, Maynard, Berget, Velikonja (Get rid of Jones, Berget and Velikonja)


Full clearout!!! :old: :thumbup:

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 6:38 pm

Austin In
Rhodes in

Bellamy out
Jones out.

Mcmannaman in
Kim Out

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 6:51 pm

Out
Connolly
Taylor
Turner
Bellamy
KTC
Medel
Mutch
Kim
Gunnarson
Cowie
McNaugton
Jones
Cambell

In
Who ever the manager choose to sign

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 6:59 pm

We will lose Marshall, Caulker, Medel, Mutch, Noone, Campbell and Bellamy will retire so we need a malky esc rebuild

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 7:23 pm

Keep
Daehli
Noone

Get fees for
Mutch 5-6m caulker 8m medel 3m Marshall 6-8m Campbell 4-5m

Out
The rest

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 10:42 pm

Let go: Gunnarson, Turner, Taylor, KTC, Berget,Cowie, Jones, Mcnaugton, Connolly
Retire: Bellamy

Medel supposedly has a relegation clause and will leave.

Ideally keep: Marshall. Chaulker, Daehli, Mutch, Noone, Fabio, John, Whitts, Cala

Realistically: Marshall, Chaulker, Daehli and Mutch will be approached by PL teams. Most if not all will leave.

Unsure about Campell, Kim and Eikrem, might be useful in the championship but if we go straight back up it would be better to buy some new players that strengthen the team in their positions and has potential for the PL.

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 10:54 pm

I think eikram will do well for us in the championship.

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 10:54 pm

Need to strengthen the left back position asap.....don't know how many goals we conceded from that side of the field..Taylor not good enough, John nowhere near ready enough and not convinced he's a natural defender.

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 10:57 pm

Daft Dave wrote:Need to strengthen the left back position asap.....don't know how many goals we conceded from that side of the field..Taylor not good enough, John nowhere near ready enough and not convinced he's a natural defender.


I think Fabio could do a job, I think he do a very good job in the championship actually.
Taylor can do a job in the championship, John should be out to a league 1 club.

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 11:33 pm

2blue2handle wrote:I think eikram will do well for us in the championship.

He is very similar to whitts though. Cant see us playing them together. They are also both quite slow and one thing i want to see is us getting some midfielders and defenders with pace.

Re: IN's & OUT's

Sun May 04, 2014 11:39 pm

LonCar wrote:
2blue2handle wrote:I think eikram will do well for us in the championship.

He is very similar to whitts though. Cant see us playing them together. They are also both quite slow and one thing i want to see is us getting some midfielders and defenders with pace.


Funny I thought the same as I posted.

I'd move whitts on now. Surely a high earner with the amount of contracts he has had.

Re: IN's & OUT's

Mon May 05, 2014 6:21 am

Out:

Medel
Caulker
Kim
Whittingham (If Eikrem stays)
Campbell
Theophile (If Kev doesn't retire)

In:

Ross McCormack
Vegard Forren

Re: IN's & OUT's

Mon May 05, 2014 2:33 pm

Metal Handkerchief wrote:Out:

Medel
Caulker
Kim
Whittingham (If Eikrem stays)
Campbell
Theophile (If Kev doesn't retire)

In:

Ross McCormack
Vegard Forren


Vegard Forren a good shout

Re: IN's & OUT's

Mon May 05, 2014 2:51 pm

Marshall
Noone
Medel
Campbell
Caulker
Cala
Mutch

Would not be surprised to see teams come in for the above

Would not let players like Turner, Gunnarson and Cowie leave. Can all do a good job at Championship level.

Sell or release Jones, Bellamy

Re: IN's & OUT's

Mon May 05, 2014 8:02 pm

MacNaughton won't be going anywhere. He's only just signed a new contract or do people here not follow news about the club?

Re: IN's & OUT's

Mon May 05, 2014 8:13 pm

1 Scotland GK David Marshall - Gone
2 England DF Matthew Connolly - keep
3 England DF Andrew Taylor - let him find another club
4 England DF Steven Caulker - Gone
5 England DF Mark Hudson (captain) - Keep
6 England DF Ben Turner - Sell
7 England MF Peter Whittingham - Keep
8 Chile MF Gary Medel _ Gone
9 Trinidad FW Kenwyne Jones - let him find another club (no chance)
10 England FW Fraizer Campbell - Sell
13 South Korea MF Kim Bo-Kyung - Sell
14 England MF Tommy Smith - let him find another club
15 Norway MF Magnus Wolff Eikrem - Keep
16 England MF Craig Noone - Keep
17 Iceland MF Aron Gunnarsson - Sell
18 England MF Jordon Mutch - Sell
19 Scotland MF Don Cowie - let him find another club
20 Republic FW Joe Mason - Keep
24 Scotland DF Simon Lappin - let him find another club
25 Scotland DF Kevin McNaughton - Keep
27 Spain DF Cala Keep (no chance)
28 France DF Kévin Théophile-Catherine - sell
29 Norway MF Mats Møller Dæhli - Keep
32 England GK Joe Lewis - Keep
34 Norway FW Jo Inge Berget - Keep
35 Brazil DF Fábio - Keep
39 Wales FW Craig Bellamy - Retires
42 Wales DF Declan John - Keep (Re position into midfield)

Keep all the kids except Nugent, who just can't play football at championship level