Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 12:36 am

If it doesn't work plan B is bring on Jones, Daehli and Whitts and just launch balls in and hope he can do something.

Putting Turner in the team just leaves us exposed to any counter attack as he doesn't have the pace. Mutch and Eikrem can both pass fine and control play and Bellamy can drift and do his thing in a free role off Campbell and Zaha and Noone can go either wide or cut in etc. Bellamy on the edge of the box to finish. Mutch can be a box to box which we need, reminds me of Yaya at times with his carrying of the ball. Modern day ball winners need to do more than just tackle which is why I don't think Medel should be there. He can win the ball but then its a sideways or backwards pass or long ball to nothing.

In this system our entire back line has the pace to cope on the counter. Fabio, Caulker and Medel as well as John all have the speed to cope and avoid getting overrun on the break. Turner is a massive liability and Medel does the job there for Chile and on corners Mutch has height and can get back and mark the opponents taller players.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 12:41 am

Green Arrow wrote:If it doesn't work plan B is bring on Jones, Daehli and Whitts and just launch balls in and hope he can do something.

Putting Turner in the team just leaves us exposed to any counter attack as he doesn't have the pace. Mutch and Eikrem can both pass fine and control play and Bellamy can drift and do his thing in a free role off Campbell and Zaha and Noone can go either wide or cut in etc. Bellamy on the edge of the box to finish. Mutch can be a box to box which we need, reminds me of Yaya at times with his carrying of the ball. Modern day ball winners need to do more than just tackle which is why I don't think Medel should be there. He can win the ball but then its a sideways or backwards pass or long ball to nothing.

In this system our entire back line has the pace to cope on the counter. Fabio, Caulker and Medel as well as John all have the speed to cope and avoid getting overrun on the break. Turner is a massive liability and Medel does the job there for Chile and on corners Mutch has height and can get back and mark the opponents taller players.


Fair play I quite like that lineup! I would also like to see medel partner caulker in defence! :ayatollah:

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 12:46 am

I know Medel plays there for Chile but id be concerned having such a short CB, for all Turners faults he is a defemder who does his defensive job fairly well, its his distribution and decison making that are questionable.

Also in regards to Medel, he seems to leave passes short lately giving the ball away a fair bit, imagine if he was doing that from a centre half position *shudders*

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 12:47 am

Descent bench and all!

Turner, ktc, jones, whitts, Dhaeli, Bergst,Lewis

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 12:53 am

Gavin wrote:I know Medel plays there for Chile but id be concerned having such a short CB, for all Turners faults he is a defemder who does his defensive job fairly well, its his distribution and decison making that are questionable.


I strongly disagree with that. Go watch the Sunderland game again. Woefully inadequate defensive performance against Fletcher

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 12:55 am

CardiffOz wrote:
Gavin wrote:I know Medel plays there for Chile but id be concerned having such a short CB, for all Turners faults he is a defemder who does his defensive job fairly well, its his distribution and decison making that are questionable.


I strongly disagree with that. Go watch the Sunderland game again. Woefully inadequate defensive performance against Fletcher


As did Hudson against Carlton Cole, Turner is our best option in my opinion. Our options are fairly limited unfortunately.

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 12:59 am

Gavin wrote:
CardiffOz wrote:
Gavin wrote:I know Medel plays there for Chile but id be concerned having such a short CB, for all Turners faults he is a defemder who does his defensive job fairly well, its his distribution and decison making that are questionable.


I strongly disagree with that. Go watch the Sunderland game again. Woefully inadequate defensive performance against Fletcher


As did Hudson against Carlton Cole, Turner is our best option in my opinion. Our options are fairly limited unfortunately.



I think both turner and hudson have been at fault for giving goals away! I would like to give medel ago in defence but he was also at fault for standing off Ashley cole against man utd! Gutted we didn't sign another centre back!

But we need to get behind the team now! Looking forward to tomorrow!

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 1:01 am

Gavin wrote:
CardiffOz wrote:
Gavin wrote:I know Medel plays there for Chile but id be concerned having such a short CB, for all Turners faults he is a defemder who does his defensive job fairly well, its his distribution and decison making that are questionable.


I strongly disagree with that. Go watch the Sunderland game again. Woefully inadequate defensive performance against Fletcher


As did Hudson against Carlton Cole, Turner is our best option in my opinion. Our options are fairly limited unfortunately.


I think Medel is the only viable option

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 1:03 am

CardiffOz wrote:
Gavin wrote:
CardiffOz wrote:
Gavin wrote:I know Medel plays there for Chile but id be concerned having such a short CB, for all Turners faults he is a defemder who does his defensive job fairly well, its his distribution and decison making that are questionable.


I strongly disagree with that. Go watch the Sunderland game again. Woefully inadequate defensive performance against Fletcher


As did Hudson against Carlton Cole, Turner is our best option in my opinion. Our options are fairly limited unfortunately.


I think Medel is the only viable option


No he's too short and he's not that quick either so it would be a terrible decision

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 1:05 am

Medel plays as CB in a three and is dreadful at tracking runners.

Given what we've seen from Oly and who we have brought in id say he's going for
Marshall
KTC Caulker Turner Fabio
Medel Eikrem
Noone Mutch Bellamy
Campbell/Jones

Lewis, McNaughton, Whittingham, Dælhia, Berget, Zaha, Campbell/Jones

Tough to call who goes up top. Campbell has a pretty good scoring record under Ole but you think Jones is how he wants to play. If Ole is looking at a flatter 4-3-3 without a number ten behind the striker then it'll be Jones relying on the two wingers to give him support.

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 1:06 am

RFMH wrote:Medel plays as CB in a three and is dreadful at tracking runners.

Given what we've seen from Oly and who we have brought in id say he's going for
Marshall
KTC Caulker Turner Fabio
Medel Eikrem
Noone Mutch Bellamy
Campbell/Jones

Lewis, McNaughton, Whittingham, Dælhia, Berget, Zaha, Campbell/Jones

Tough to call who goes up top. Campbell has a pretty good scoring record under Ole but you think Jones is how he wants to play. If Ole is looking at a flatter 4-3-3 without a number ten behind the striker then it'll be Jones relying on the two wingers to give him support.


I would play this but probably sway bellers for Zaha

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 1:39 am

Marshall
Fabio Caulker KTC/Connolly John
Medel
Noone Mutch Daehli
Jones Campbell

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 1:40 am

CardiffOz wrote:
Gavin wrote:
CardiffOz wrote:
Gavin wrote:I know Medel plays there for Chile but id be concerned having such a short CB, for all Turners faults he is a defemder who does his defensive job fairly well, its his distribution and decison making that are questionable.


I strongly disagree with that. Go watch the Sunderland game again. Woefully inadequate defensive performance against Fletcher


As did Hudson against Carlton Cole, Turner is our best option in my opinion. Our options are fairly limited unfortunately.


I think Medel is the only viable option


You think the only viable option is creating a new defensive partnership using someone who naturally plays in midfield going into the most important month of fixtures in our clubs history??

To risky for me, stick with Turner, hopefully a new full back playing next to him will help with his distribution and keep our fingers crossed.

I was up for using Medel myself after watching the Chile v England game but its a bit late in the season to try out a risky strategy, especially after witnessing Medels recent iffy form

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 5:15 am

I'd personally go with this

4-1-2-1-2

------------------------------------------------------------------- -----Marshall-----------------------------------------------------------------

-------KTC------------------------------------------------CAULKER-----------------TURNER-----------------------------------FABIO



--------------------------------------------------------------------------MEDEL------------------------------------------------------------------



-----NOONE-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ZAHA




-------------------------------------------------------------------------MUTCH------------------------------------------------------------------





-----------------------------------------------------------FRAIZER------------------JONES------------------------------------------------------

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 6:44 am

ccfc95 wrote:I'd personally go with this

4-1-2-1-2

------------------------------------------------------------------- -----Marshall-----------------------------------------------------------------

-------KTC------------------------------------------------CAULKER-----------------TURNER-----------------------------------FABIO



--------------------------------------------------------------------------MEDEL------------------------------------------------------------------


Well youre not boring mate, he who dares wins!




-----NOONE-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ZAHA




-------------------------------------------------------------------------MUTCH------------------------------------------------------------------





-----------------------------------------------------------FRAIZER------------------JONES------------------------------------------------------



Marshall
Fabio Turner Caulker KTC
Medal Whitts Mutch
Noone Zaha
Campbell

Bloooobirds! :ayatollah:

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 7:07 am

ccfc95 wrote:I'd personally go with this

4-1-2-1-2

------------------------------------------------------------------- -----Marshall-----------------------------------------------------------------

-------KTC------------------------------------------------CAULKER-----------------TURNER-----------------------------------FABIO



--------------------------------------------------------------------------MEDEL------------------------------------------------------------------



-----NOONE-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ZAHA




-------------------------------------------------------------------------MUTCH------------------------------------------------------------------





-----------------------------------------------------------FRAIZER------------------JONES------------------------------------------------------



Two attacking full backs, two attacking wingers and no central midfielder.

If we'd play that then may as well say we're down.

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 7:27 am

Its my go playing Cardiff City manager now!!!

Marshall

McNaughton Caulker Turner Fabio

Medel

Daelli Mutch

Noone Zaha

Jones

Manager: ThomasC

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 7:33 am

--------Marshall--------
-KTC-Caulker-Turner-John-
-------------Medel-------
-Noone----Mutch-----Zaha-
----------Dæhli----------
--------Campbell--------

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 7:33 am

ThomasC wrote:Its my go playing Cardiff City manager now!!!

--------------------------------------- Marshall

McNaughton-----------Caulker-----------------Turner--------------------Fabio

--------------------------------------- Medel

Daelli--------------------------Mutch

Noone----------------------------------------------------------------- Zaha

-----------------------------------Jones

Manager: ThomasC

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 7:35 am

ThomasC wrote:
ThomasC wrote:Its my go playing Cardiff City manager now!!!

--------------------------------------- Marshall

--McNaughton-----------Caulker-----------------Turner--------------------Fabio

--------------------------------------- Medel

------------------------- Daelli--------------------------Mutch

-- Noone----------------------------------------------------------------- Zaha

-----------------------------------Jones

Manager: ThomasC

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 7:37 am

ThomasC wrote:
ThomasC wrote:
ThomasC wrote:Its my go playing Cardiff City manager now!!!

--------------------------------------- Marshall

--McNaughton-----------Caulker-----------------Turner--------------------Fabio

--------------------------------------- Medel

------------------------- Daelli--------------------------Mutch

-- Noone----------------------------------------------------------------- Zaha

----------------------------------------Jones (60mins)

Manager: ThomasC

Re: I'd play this

Sat Feb 01, 2014 7:47 am

Agree with aderynglas. Can't believe so many are leaving daehli out. Kids a class act...really hope ole starts him today.