Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed today )

Fri Jan 31, 2014 10:56 am

4-4-2 Formation

Marshall
KTC
Ciani
Caulker
Fabio
Noone
Medel
Rincon
Zaha
Campbell
Jones. :ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 10:58 am

----------------Marshall-------------------

Theo-----Turner--------Caulker----John

------------Medel-------Mutch-------------

Noone-----------Kim------------------Zaha

-----------------Frazier---------------

Don't know why people think swapping everyone will work. Fabio is not better than John.

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 11:02 am

Willy-Wonka wrote:----------------Marshall-------------------

Theo-----Turner--------Caulker----John

------------Medel-------Mutch-------------

Noone-----------Kim------------------Zaha

-----------------Frazier---------------

Don't know why people think swapping everyone will work. Fabio is not better than John.


Hm true but I would have to go with 2 strikers imo. If we get Dann or Ciani I would start one of them ahead of Turner. Turner = Championship football next season.

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 11:05 am

cant imagine anyone signed today will play tomorrow. (though im assuming zaha has been around the team for a few days?)


Marshall

mcnaughton
hudson
caulker
john

noone
whitts
medel
zaha

jones
campbell

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 11:09 am

Willy-Wonka wrote:----------------Marshall-------------------

Theo-----Turner--------Caulker----John

------------Medel-------Mutch-------------

Noone-----------Kim------------------Zaha

-----------------Frazier---------------

Don't know why people think swapping everyone will work. Fabio is not better than John.


Kim and FC are too light wright need some strength in that area or opposition CBs will win balls all day long. any two of Eikrem, Whitts and Medel with Mutch in front. I think Fabio will play not because I rate him but because clearly OGS does.

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 11:20 am

If they sign rincon I'd play this

image.jpg

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 11:29 am

thomasblue wrote:If they sign rincon I'd play this

image.jpg


Not bad :thumbup:

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 11:38 am

paulh_85 wrote:cant imagine anyone signed today will play tomorrow. (though im assuming zaha has been around the team for a few days?)


Marshall

mcnaughton
hudson
caulker
john

noone
whitts
medel
zaha


jones
campbell


Zaha has trained with City most of the week apparently.

Rincon? ....... Lol

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 11:47 am

thomasblue wrote:If they sign rincon I'd play this

image.jpg



Spot on :thumbup:

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 11:49 am

OriginalGrangeEndBlue wrote:
paulh_85 wrote:cant imagine anyone signed today will play tomorrow. (though im assuming zaha has been around the team for a few days?)


Marshall

mcnaughton
hudson
caulker
john

noone
whitts
medel
zaha


jones
campbell


Zaha has trained with City most of the week apparently.

Rincon? ....... Lol


Rincon's quality..hamberg midfielder we've agreed a deal for him. better than whittingham by a mile

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 11:51 am

thomasblue wrote:If they sign rincon I'd play this

image.jpg

You do realise this is real life not Football Manager.

Were bottom of the league fighting for our lives, we can't just go places with basically 5 attackers and one holding midfielder and expect not to get outplayed by at least 15 teams who are better than us right now.

What's worse is you haven't included Medel in the team, the one world class player we have, and replaced him with a player you've probably never seen play.

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 11:55 am

GarethDay95x wrote:
OriginalGrangeEndBlue wrote:
paulh_85 wrote:cant imagine anyone signed today will play tomorrow. (though im assuming zaha has been around the team for a few days?)


Marshall

mcnaughton
hudson
caulker
john

noone
whitts
medel
zaha


jones
campbell


Zaha has trained with City most of the week apparently.

Rincon? ....... Lol


Rincon's quality..hamberg midfielder we've agreed a deal for him. better than whittingham by a mile



we've agreed a deal for him?

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 11:58 am

paulh_85 wrote:
GarethDay95x wrote:
OriginalGrangeEndBlue wrote:
paulh_85 wrote:cant imagine anyone signed today will play tomorrow. (though im assuming zaha has been around the team for a few days?)


Marshall

mcnaughton
hudson
caulker
john

noone
whitts
medel
zaha


jones
campbell


Zaha has trained with City most of the week apparently.

Rincon? ....... Lol


Rincon's quality..hamberg midfielder we've agreed a deal for him. better than whittingham by a mile



we've agreed a deal for him?



http://www1.skysports.com/football/news ... mas-rincon

We are in talks actually :thumbup: Someone mentioned to me we've agreed a deal but obviously not. We could get him though

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 11:59 am

scott_w_ccfc wrote:
thomasblue wrote:If they sign rincon I'd play this

image.jpg

You do realise this is real life not Football Manager.

Were bottom of the league fighting for our lives, we can't just go places with basically 5 attackers and one holding midfielder and expect not to get outplayed by at least 15 teams who are better than us right now.

What's worse is you haven't included Medel in the team, the one world class player we have, and replaced him with a player you've probably never seen play.


It's a 4-4-2 showing rincon as the defensive midfielder and mutch as the attacking . With two wingers . Campbell will play off the main striker filling the gap between the target man and the midfield .

Medel as a centre back where he is more than capable of playing as proven by his record at international level with chile .

It suits the players we have available and gives a good balance to the team

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 12:03 pm

hmmm lets hope so but you catnreally believe anything at this time of year.

Also that report is 2 days old and there isnt anything new on it.

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 1:27 pm

He has rejected our advances..

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 1:29 pm

where are people getting this from?

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 2:27 pm

Ole has been very unpredictable conserning his starting 11,he is known for his extreme rotation philosophy. Transferwindow says it all, you will most likely fail to predict his starting 11 match to match. ;) This has big positive effects in my eyes, teamspirit ftw :ayatollah:

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 2:58 pm

GarethDay95x wrote:
OriginalGrangeEndBlue wrote:
paulh_85 wrote:cant imagine anyone signed today will play tomorrow. (though im assuming zaha has been around the team for a few days?)


Marshall

mcnaughton
hudson
caulker
john

noone
whitts
medel
zaha


jones
campbell


Zaha has trained with City most of the week apparently.

Rincon? ....... Lol


Rincon's quality..hamberg midfielder we've agreed a deal for him. better than whittingham by a mile


The 'lol' was because people on here thinking we'd sign someone like him.

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 3:03 pm

FFS you can't just start making up a team with players we haven't even signed yet, whats wrong with you lot.

And Medel CB in the prem is mental and would never work. Only works with Chile as they play high up, with 3 CBs and a very different style to us. His height would get taken advantage of big time in the prem.

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 3:15 pm

Wasn't both Ciani and Rincon transfers debunked?

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 3:17 pm

Walter White wrote:FFS you can't just start making up a team with players we haven't even signed yet, whats wrong with you lot.

And Medel CB in the prem is mental and would never work. Only works with Chile as they play high up, with 3 CBs and a very different style to us. His height would get taken advantage of big time in the prem.


Best & most sensible post of the week on both points.
Idiots on here picking players not signed, probably not even on our radar & wanting them to play against Norwich!!!!!!!!

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 3:44 pm

:ayatollah:

Image

Even if we do sign another one or two they wont be involved tomorrow.

Re: My starting 11including Ciani and Rincon.( If signed tod

Fri Jan 31, 2014 3:49 pm

thomasblue wrote:
scott_w_ccfc wrote:
thomasblue wrote:If they sign rincon I'd play this

image.jpg

You do realise this is real life not Football Manager.

Were bottom of the league fighting for our lives, we can't just go places with basically 5 attackers and one holding midfielder and expect not to get outplayed by at least 15 teams who are better than us right now.

What's worse is you haven't included Medel in the team, the one world class player we have, and replaced him with a player you've probably never seen play.


It's a 4-4-2 showing rincon as the defensive midfielder and mutch as the attacking . With two wingers . Campbell will play off the main striker filling the gap between the target man and the midfield .

Medel as a centre back where he is more than capable of playing as proven by his record at international level with chile .

It suits the players we have available and gives a good balance to the team

Genuinely wasn't having a dig at you by the way mate, i just think that if we play a straight 4-4-2 with Zaha as a winger than we will get absolutely ripped to shreads as he will have very little intention of tracking back.

Playing Zaha will only work in 433 in my opinion, or at the VERY least two holding midfielders, and Mutch is best going forward.

About Medel, yes he plays CB for Chile but that's in back 5 and i've said a million times that it's such a different role because he's almost still playing as a midfielder just dropping in as an extra CB.

Medel is so underrated in the role he plays for us by people on this forum, just because he doesn't do anything special going forward people think he goes missing in games but the amount of times he's in the right place at the right time to put a tackle or stop danger is unreal. So I just don't see why we should move him, for me he's the first name on the team sheet in CDM.

Yes he makes the odd lapse every now and then but if he were perfect he'd be at Barca/Man Utd by now with his range of passing and how comfortable he is on the ball too.

For me, our best team would be...

Marshall
Theophile Caulker Turner McNaughton
Medel Whittingham
Noone Mutch Zaha
Jones

As much as I'd love to get Campbell in the team too, I just think we need a better target man up front to stop the ball constantly coming back at us because he's not a hold-up player.