Maiga or Cornelious

Both shit , both cost big bucks both earn big bucks

Who has the biggest flop ?

maiga plays every week usually and he's crap. cornelius hasn't had a chance yet. anyone who bases him on a couple of sub appearances is just looking for a scapegoat. clueless. i didn't know Maiga cost a lot.....how much?

Can see you flying up the league with Carroll fit and that 7ft beanpole Traore signing, got goals written all over them two. And who have we got, cornflake and Campbell, not 10 goals between em

Cornelious with out a doubt. People keep saying he needs to be given a chance. We don't have time to give people a chance anymore, Mason is 10 times the player.

On the note of strikers Cole played very well for you whats his contract situation now is it until the end of the season?

Both shit , both cost big bucks both earn big bucks

Who has the biggest flop ?

Too early to tell yet for Cornelius, Steve - you'd know that. He's still a kid.

Carroll didn't look much better - a touch like an elephant and beaten every time by Caulker when Hudson went off - funny to see the press creaming it after he played Noble in, bloody hell it wasn't difficult.

Congratulations on your win, considering the injuries and lack of confidence it wasn't surprising your team looked sh1t, still they showed more balls than our lot did, particularly first half and took advantage of the lucky breaks (mostly helped by Mason) on yesterday's showing we both need to improve dramatically to stay up.

We were naiive too, letting the time wasting go on, allowing ourselves to be physically pushed aorund, not testing the keeper with enough balls under the bar, particularly after Tomkins went off - too slow to turn defense to attack when you had 10 and to switch from side to side...

Your best player IMHO was Noble, but he always seems to do well against us.

It was Carroll's first game back, so the fact some of his touches were off was not surprising, looked very good considering though, made himself a threat and the pass to Noble was good, on his weaker foot too.

It was Carroll's first game back, so the fact some of his touches were off was not surprising, looked very good considering though, made himself a threat and the pass to Noble was good, on his weaker foot too.

I'm not sure that's enough of an excuse for the awful touches - they were worse than mine in 5-a-side, he's a pro-footballer who trains every day and not once but 3 times lost control of a simple pass.