Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Changing manager often means no change in performance

Thu Jan 02, 2014 4:45 pm

Hi,

How does everyone feel re. the appointment of Solskjaer?

I think he's a solid candidate to become a good Premier League manager, but as this article shows, it's very easy to overestimate the impact a new manager can have in his first season.

The cliche of the "bounce" a new appointment can bring is all too often just that, a cliche.

This article shows that more often than not, a side's form will stay exactly the same regardless of who is in charge within a single season.

http://hitrowz.com/2013/12/16/changing- ... provement/

Change takes longer. Do Cardiff have that time?

Ben

Re: Changing manager often means no change in performance

Thu Jan 02, 2014 4:47 pm

The players began the game against Sunderland like a house on fire. Played well against Arsenal, if not for late, late mistakes.

That was under Kerslake and McBride.

What happens to those two now?. The players were clearly up for it with those two in charge.

Re: Changing manager often means no change in performance

Thu Jan 02, 2014 4:53 pm

New managers may not effect a team to often but a manager who can buy players might.



Willy-Wonka wrote:The players began the game against Sunderland like a house on fire. Played well against Arsenal, if not for late, late mistakes.

That was under Kerslake and McBride.

What happens to those two now?. The players were clearly up for it with those two in charge.


They also cost us points with negative subs, ala Malky.
Both can go now.

Re: Changing manager often means no change in performance

Thu Jan 02, 2014 5:54 pm

2blue2handle wrote:New managers may not effect a team to often but a manager who can buy players might.



Willy-Wonka wrote:The players began the game against Sunderland like a house on fire. Played well against Arsenal, if not for late, late mistakes.

That was under Kerslake and McBride.

What happens to those two now?. The players were clearly up for it with those two in charge.


They also cost us points with negative subs, ala Malky.
Both can go now.


They have gone! According to radio Wales

Re: Changing manager often means no change in performance

Thu Jan 02, 2014 5:55 pm

pembroke allan wrote:
2blue2handle wrote:New managers may not effect a team to often but a manager who can buy players might.



Willy-Wonka wrote:The players began the game against Sunderland like a house on fire. Played well against Arsenal, if not for late, late mistakes.

That was under Kerslake and McBride.

What happens to those two now?. The players were clearly up for it with those two in charge.


They also cost us points with negative subs, ala Malky.
Both can go now.


Thank f**k.for that.

They have gone! According to radio Wales

Re: Changing manager often means no change in performance

Thu Jan 02, 2014 6:15 pm

Ever the optimistic bunch our fans are, have some faith for once

Re: Changing manager often means no change in performance

Thu Jan 02, 2014 6:57 pm

Changing manager often means no change in performance.....Lets be real here it can not get much worse than what we have had to watch under malky this season in most games :ayatollah:

Re: Changing manager often means no change in performance

Thu Jan 02, 2014 7:22 pm

BenHarrison wrote:Hi,

How does everyone feel re. the appointment of Solskjaer?

I think he's a solid candidate to become a good Premier League manager, but as this article shows, it's very easy to overestimate the impact a new manager can have in his first season.

The cliche of the "bounce" a new appointment can bring is all too often just that, a cliche.

This article shows that more often than not, a side's form will stay exactly the same regardless of who is in charge within a single season.

http://hitrowz.com/2013/12/16/changing- ... provement/

Change takes longer. Do Cardiff have that time?

Ben



If your club is becoming a circus and the manager and owner are waging a full blown war via the media and that is ended then there is a fairly good chance that performances will improve. Don't you agree?

Re: Changing manager often means no change in performance

Thu Jan 02, 2014 7:48 pm

BenHarrison wrote:Hi,

How does everyone feel re. the appointment of Solskjaer?

I think he's a solid candidate to become a good Premier League manager, but as this article shows, it's very easy to overestimate the impact a new manager can have in his first season.

The cliche of the "bounce" a new appointment can bring is all too often just that, a cliche.

This article shows that more often than not, a side's form will stay exactly the same regardless of who is in charge within a single season.

http://hitrowz.com/2013/12/16/changing- ... provement/

Change takes longer. Do Cardiff have that time?

Ben

the southampton comparison excludes the first 6 games with adkins......1 win 5 defeats..a very biased article...Sunderland, Palace, Fulham.............no bounce?