Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

some more upset at losing manager than identity

Mon Dec 23, 2013 5:03 pm

why????????......surely our identity has always been the biggest issue......i dont understand. :ayatollah:

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Mon Dec 23, 2013 5:05 pm

krabb wrote:why????????......surely our identity has always been the biggest issue......i dont understand. :ayatollah:


Kevin, I am 100% more upset losing our identity, I am a big Malky fan, but our identity comes first every time. :thumbup:

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Mon Dec 23, 2013 5:07 pm

Forever Blue wrote:
krabb wrote:why????????......surely our identity has always been the biggest issue......i dont understand. :ayatollah:


Kevin, I am 100% more upset losing our identity, I am a big Malky fan, but our identity comes first every time. :thumbup:

spot on annis.....spot on.. :ayatollah:

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Mon Dec 23, 2013 6:11 pm

krabb wrote:why????????......surely our identity has always been the biggest issue......i dont understand. :ayatollah:


I know what you're saying but I think for a lot of people, this was the straw that broke the camels back.
I'm far angrier about the rebrand than about losing any manager, and although I like Malky, I'd swap him for our identity back in a heartbeat.

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Mon Dec 23, 2013 6:18 pm

krabb wrote:why????????......surely our identity has always been the biggest issue......i dont understand. :ayatollah:


Its a case of enough is enough for a lot of fans.

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Mon Dec 23, 2013 6:22 pm

CF14-SE14 wrote:
krabb wrote:why????????......surely our identity has always been the biggest issue......i dont understand. :ayatollah:


I know what you're saying but I think for a lot of people, this was the straw that broke the camels back.
I'm far angrier about the rebrand than about losing any manager, and although I like Malky, I'd swap him for our identity back in a heartbeat.


The colour can be changed back at any time and I'm confident it will.

No-one asked for the colour change, and i don't think anyone GENUINELY liked it,but overall I think we are fair fans and wanted to give the guy a chance - after all he'd saved us from going bust and bankrolled a promotion push.

However the goings on of the last few months (and let's remember, not all have proven to be true) - and now the shameful treatment of a genuine and honourable man who deserved so much better pushed the 'silent majority' a step to far.

Whether we should try to force him out I'm not sure. He HAS done a lot of good - the team, the stadium expansion, the training ground, the charity donations, maybe with a bit of experience he can become a good owner ? If he can change his mind over Malky, then maybe also the kit ? We should give him the chance, but ensure he knows that the patience just isn't there any more.

Just my opinion. ;)

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Mon Dec 23, 2013 6:23 pm

Magners wrote:
krabb wrote:why????????......surely our identity has always been the biggest issue......i dont understand. :ayatollah:


Its a case of enough is enough for a lot of fans.

but surely losing our identity was enough,id like to know how many excepted the red but will fight to keep malky,crazy to me....but just my opinion.... :ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Mon Dec 23, 2013 6:43 pm

krabb wrote:
Magners wrote:
krabb wrote:why????????......surely our identity has always been the biggest issue......i dont understand. :ayatollah:


Its a case of enough is enough for a lot of fans.

but surely losing our identity was enough,id like to know how many excepted the red but will fight to keep malky,crazy to me....but just my opinion.... :ayatollah: :ayatollah:


Why ain't you just happy more people are against Tan as opposed to finding out who is fighting to keep Malkys job and who is fighting for our history.

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Mon Dec 23, 2013 6:45 pm

Magners wrote:
krabb wrote:why????????......surely our identity has always been the biggest issue......i dont understand. :ayatollah:


Its a case of enough is enough for a lot of fans.

Here here pal here f*cking here :thumbup:

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Mon Dec 23, 2013 10:25 pm

Magners wrote:
krabb wrote:
Magners wrote:
krabb wrote:why????????......surely our identity has always been the biggest issue......i dont understand. :ayatollah:


Its a case of enough is enough for a lot of fans.

but surely losing our identity was enough,id like to know how many excepted the red but will fight to keep malky,crazy to me....but just my opinion.... :ayatollah: :ayatollah:


Why ain't you just happy more people are against Tan as opposed to finding out who is fighting to keep Malkys job and who is fighting for our history.

because malky is a manager,and can do as he pleases,he can leave at anytime.......and i find it astonishing that someone will wear a red shirt and then be against a manager being sacked......

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Mon Dec 23, 2013 10:44 pm

CF14-SE14 wrote:
krabb wrote:why????????......surely our identity has always been the biggest issue......i dont understand. :ayatollah:


I know what you're saying but I think for a lot of people, this was the straw that broke the camels back.


It's this for me - sums it up - I'd rather be in blue but as time has gone on, the Malky debacle is just one in a long line of crazy decisions and situations generated by VT. It has got worse for us in many ways, since the rebrand...

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Mon Dec 23, 2013 10:48 pm

krabb wrote:
Magners wrote:
krabb wrote:
Magners wrote:
krabb wrote:why????????......surely our identity has always been the biggest issue......i dont understand. :ayatollah:


Its a case of enough is enough for a lot of fans.

but surely losing our identity was enough,id like to know how many excepted the red but will fight to keep malky,crazy to me....but just my opinion.... :ayatollah: :ayatollah:


Why ain't you just happy more people are against Tan as opposed to finding out who is fighting to keep Malkys job and who is fighting for our history.

because malky is a manager,and can do as he pleases,he can leave at anytime.......and i find it astonishing that someone will wear a red shirt and then be against a manager being sacked......



I always found it astonishing after the rebrand that any Cardiff fan would wear a red shirt, let alone anything else :oops:

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Tue Dec 24, 2013 12:51 am

krabb wrote:
Magners wrote:
krabb wrote:
Magners wrote:
krabb wrote:why????????......surely our identity has always been the biggest issue......i dont understand. :ayatollah:


Its a case of enough is enough for a lot of fans.

but surely losing our identity was enough,id like to know how many excepted the red but will fight to keep malky,crazy to me....but just my opinion.... :ayatollah: :ayatollah:


Why ain't you just happy more people are against Tan as opposed to finding out who is fighting to keep Malkys job and who is fighting for our history.

because malky is a manager,and can do as he pleases,he can leave at anytime.......and i find it astonishing that someone will wear a red shirt and then be against a manager being sacked......


The fans who are shifting against Tan are the fans who have never wore a red shirt. I have always wore Blue and have never purchased one item with the beermat badge on.

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Tue Dec 24, 2013 12:54 am

I think it's a buildup of events that are winding people up.

Many reluctantly accepted the rebrand as par to the deal was a more "secure & stable" club... But every one of VTs gaffes is winding fans up more each time & his mistreatment of Malky was the "last straw" and they changed their tune.

Re: some more upset at losing manager than identity

Tue Dec 24, 2013 1:03 am

Barry Chuckle wrote:I think it's a buildup of events that are winding people up.

Many reluctantly accepted the rebrand as par to the deal was a more "secure & stable" club... But every one of VTs gaffes is winding fans up more each time & his mistreatment of Malky was the "last straw" and they changed their tune.


I fall into the category you describe. I reluctantly accepted the rebrand but still wore Blue to matches. Tan's actions recently have pushed me from a reluctant rebrander to Anti Tan.