Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Duff Ratings

Tue Sep 24, 2013 6:55 pm

I had a look at the Independent's aggregated player ratings and couldn't believe my eyes, The Times gave Marshall only a 7, whereas the other papers gave him a more accurate 9, although I would have given him a 10. When I looked at some of the other Times rating's they were almost as bad. I thought Gunner and Taylor had an off day, yet they scored the same as Kimbo, who looked good with a 6. Furthermore, Dembele and Paulinho only scored 5's, yet Lloris scored 7, and as much as I support City I don't think I would give us an aggregate score higher than Spurs.

http://www.independent.co.uk/sport/foot ... or-88372...

Marshall 7, TC 6, Caulker 6, Turner 6, Taylor 6, Medel 6, Gunner 6, Bellers 5, Whitts 5, Kimbo 6, Campbell 6. Total = 65.

Lloris 7, Walker 5, Dawson 6, Vertonghen 5, Naughton 4, Dembele 5, Paulinho 5, Townsend 6, Sigurdsson 6, Eriksen 7, Soldado 5. Total = 61.

Re: Duff Ratings

Tue Sep 24, 2013 7:01 pm

aggregate scores are weird though. One team is on top but cant score, so the opposition keeper gets a high mark where the strikers dont.


i thought dembele was superb personally, one of their better players and about 10 times better than fellaini

Re: Duff Ratings

Tue Sep 24, 2013 7:15 pm

Echo wasn't much better and they watch the games.