Thu Sep 12, 2013 12:58 pm
Thu Sep 12, 2013 1:40 pm
Thu Sep 12, 2013 1:41 pm
Mario Polotelli wrote:best set piece delivery in the country
Thu Sep 12, 2013 2:54 pm
Thu Sep 12, 2013 2:54 pm
Cardiff Daft! wrote:One of these days he's gonna score straight from a corner, the guys left foot is a wand.
Thu Sep 12, 2013 2:57 pm
Cardiff Daft! wrote:One of these days he's gonna score straight from a corner, the guys left foot is a wand.
Thu Sep 12, 2013 3:00 pm
Thu Sep 12, 2013 3:23 pm
paulh_85 wrote:Cardiff Daft! wrote:One of these days he's gonna score straight from a corner, the guys left foot is a wand.
![]()
he already has.
Thu Sep 12, 2013 3:23 pm
Forever Blue wrote:I still have very big doubts about Whittingham being able to be consistent in the Premier League, in my opinion, he was not consistent in the Championship. On his day Whitts is Class, but we dont see him perform like that week in week out.
Thu Sep 12, 2013 3:31 pm
Forever Blue wrote:I still have very big doubts about Whittingham being able to be consistent in the Premier League, in my opinion, he was not consistent in the Championship. On his day Whitts is Class, but we dont see him perform like that week in week out.
Thu Sep 12, 2013 3:31 pm
Cardiff Daft! wrote:paulh_85 wrote:Cardiff Daft! wrote:One of these days he's gonna score straight from a corner, the guys left foot is a wand.
![]()
he already has.
which game was that???
Thu Sep 12, 2013 3:36 pm
Mario Polotelli wrote:Forever Blue wrote:I still have very big doubts about Whittingham being able to be consistent in the Premier League, in my opinion, he was not consistent in the Championship. On his day Whitts is Class, but we dont see him perform like that week in week out.
How can you say he was not consistent in the Championship?![]()
Hes been consistently our best and highest goal scoring midfielder in the championship for the last 4 seasons.
He was consistent enough to be named in the PFA championship team of the year 3 of the last 4 years as voted for by his peers and was Cardiff Citys player of the year 2 of the last 4 years.
Yes he has quieter games, but if he was MOTM every game he would be Ronaldo or Messi, which obviously he isnt. They are a rare breed.
We see his class in far more games than we dont see it thats for sure. He has far more good games than he has stinkers.
And before you mention him fading last season thats cos he played more minutes than anyone and Malky burnt him out.
Thu Sep 12, 2013 3:56 pm
llangainbluebird wrote:Forever Blue wrote:I still have very big doubts about Whittingham being able to be consistent in the Premier League, in my opinion, he was not consistent in the Championship. On his day Whitts is Class, but we dont see him perform like that week in week out.
Know what you mean, Annis, but can't help feeling that you're being a little bit harsh on Whitts. He's a great player, and a top bloke. We call this or that payer a 'Cardiff City legend', which is fair enough. But Peter Whittingham has done more than most City payers over the years. Hopefully, he can prove himself in the top flight this season.
Thu Sep 12, 2013 3:58 pm
Mario Polotelli wrote:Forever Blue wrote:I still have very big doubts about Whittingham being able to be consistent in the Premier League, in my opinion, he was not consistent in the Championship. On his day Whitts is Class, but we dont see him perform like that week in week out.
How can you say he was not consistent in the Championship?![]()
Hes been consistently our best and highest goal scoring midfielder in the championship for the last 4 seasons.
He was consistent enough to be named in the PFA championship team of the year 3 of the last 4 years as voted for by his peers and was Cardiff Citys player of the year 2 of the last 4 years.
Yes he has quieter games, but if he was MOTM every game he would be Ronaldo or Messi, which obviously he isnt. They are a rare breed.
We see his class in far more games than we dont see it thats for sure. He has far more good games than he has stinkers.
And before you mention him fading last season thats cos he played more minutes than anyone and Malky burnt him out.
Thu Sep 12, 2013 4:09 pm
Forever Blue wrote:Mario Polotelli wrote:Forever Blue wrote:I still have very big doubts about Whittingham being able to be consistent in the Premier League, in my opinion, he was not consistent in the Championship. On his day Whitts is Class, but we dont see him perform like that week in week out.
How can you say he was not consistent in the Championship?![]()
Hes been consistently our best and highest goal scoring midfielder in the championship for the last 4 seasons.
He was consistent enough to be named in the PFA championship team of the year 3 of the last 4 years as voted for by his peers and was Cardiff Citys player of the year 2 of the last 4 years.
Yes he has quieter games, but if he was MOTM every game he would be Ronaldo or Messi, which obviously he isnt. They are a rare breed.
We see his class in far more games than we dont see it thats for sure. He has far more good games than he has stinkers.
And before you mention him fading last season thats cos he played more minutes than anyone and Malky burnt him out.
Only my opinion Chris and I stand by it.
On nearly all the big games he has gone missing and 7 years in the Championship surely a Premier Club would of signed him up? Like I say I really hope he proves me wrong this season.
Thu Sep 12, 2013 4:53 pm
Forever Blue wrote:I still have very big doubts about Whittingham being able to be consistent in the Premier League, in my opinion, he was not consistent in the Championship. On his day Whitts is Class, but we dont see him perform like that week in week out.
Thu Sep 12, 2013 8:52 pm
Thu Sep 12, 2013 8:54 pm
Mario Polotelli wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Mario Polotelli wrote:Forever Blue wrote:I still have very big doubts about Whittingham being able to be consistent in the Premier League, in my opinion, he was not consistent in the Championship. On his day Whitts is Class, but we dont see him perform like that week in week out.
How can you say he was not consistent in the Championship?![]()
Hes been consistently our best and highest goal scoring midfielder in the championship for the last 4 seasons.
He was consistent enough to be named in the PFA championship team of the year 3 of the last 4 years as voted for by his peers and was Cardiff Citys player of the year 2 of the last 4 years.
Yes he has quieter games, but if he was MOTM every game he would be Ronaldo or Messi, which obviously he isnt. They are a rare breed.
We see his class in far more games than we dont see it thats for sure. He has far more good games than he has stinkers.
And before you mention him fading last season thats cos he played more minutes than anyone and Malky burnt him out.
Only my opinion Chris and I stand by it.
On nearly all the big games he has gone missing and 7 years in the Championship surely a Premier Club would of signed him up? Like I say I really hope he proves me wrong this season.
Clubs did come in for him but hes settled here, plus clubs who, even in the Premier League, do not pay the kind of wages Cardiff pay / paid. Fulham were rebuffed, West Brom also.
Cant agree on him going missing in the big games either. Was one of our best players in the Carling Cup final and set up 2 goals in the play off final loss to Blackpool. Also, who could possibly forget his free kick in the play-off semi final win over Leicester??
Thu Sep 12, 2013 9:11 pm
Forever Blue wrote:Mario Polotelli wrote:Forever Blue wrote:I still have very big doubts about Whittingham being able to be consistent in the Premier League, in my opinion, he was not consistent in the Championship. On his day Whitts is Class, but we dont see him perform like that week in week out.
How can you say he was not consistent in the Championship?![]()
Hes been consistently our best and highest goal scoring midfielder in the championship for the last 4 seasons.
He was consistent enough to be named in the PFA championship team of the year 3 of the last 4 years as voted for by his peers and was Cardiff Citys player of the year 2 of the last 4 years.
Yes he has quieter games, but if he was MOTM every game he would be Ronaldo or Messi, which obviously he isnt. They are a rare breed.
We see his class in far more games than we dont see it thats for sure. He has far more good games than he has stinkers.
And before you mention him fading last season thats cos he played more minutes than anyone and Malky burnt him out.
Only my opinion Chris and I stand by it.
On nearly all the big games he has gone missing and 7 years in the Championship surely a Premier Club would of signed him up? Like I say I really hope he proves me wrong this season.
Thu Sep 12, 2013 9:23 pm
Fri Sep 13, 2013 5:12 am
Mario Polotelli wrote:If there was a medel for best set piece delivery in the country then Whitts would win gold.
Fri Sep 13, 2013 7:43 am
Cardiff Daft! wrote:paulh_85 wrote:Cardiff Daft! wrote:One of these days he's gonna score straight from a corner, the guys left foot is a wand.
![]()
he already has.
which game was that???
Fri Sep 13, 2013 8:29 am
Mario Polotelli wrote:Forever Blue wrote:I still have very big doubts about Whittingham being able to be consistent in the Premier League, in my opinion, he was not consistent in the Championship. On his day Whitts is Class, but we dont see him perform like that week in week out.
How can you say he was not consistent in the Championship?![]()
Hes been consistently our best and highest goal scoring midfielder in the championship for the last 4 seasons.
He was consistent enough to be named in the PFA championship team of the year 3 of the last 4 years as voted for by his peers and was Cardiff Citys player of the year 2 of the last 4 years.
Yes he has quieter games, but if he was MOTM every game he would be Ronaldo or Messi, which obviously he isnt. They are a rare breed.
We see his class in far more games than we dont see it thats for sure. He has far more good games than he has stinkers.
And before you mention him fading last season thats cos he played more minutes than anyone and Malky burnt him out.
Fri Sep 13, 2013 10:12 am
tenerife_blu wrote:Cardiff Daft! wrote:paulh_85 wrote:Cardiff Daft! wrote:One of these days he's gonna score straight from a corner, the guys left foot is a wand.
![]()
he already has.
which game was that???
Against Palarse away not last season but the season before, he took a corner by where we were standing and it went straight in on the keepers near post, I think it was the league game there but it could have been the carling cup semi I'm not sure as I went to both.![]()
![]()
Fri Sep 13, 2013 10:18 am
Fri Sep 13, 2013 10:33 am
paulh_85 wrote:i think the palace one was disallowed wasnt it.
Fri Sep 13, 2013 9:30 pm
JONNY012697 wrote:paulh_85 wrote:i think the palace one was disallowed wasnt it.
It wasnt but I dont think it was a corner it was a free kick (might aswell have been a corner) could be wrong though didnt have the best view at the time
Fri Sep 13, 2013 11:47 pm
Mario Polotelli wrote:JONNY012697 wrote:paulh_85 wrote:i think the palace one was disallowed wasnt it.
It wasnt but I dont think it was a corner it was a free kick (might aswell have been a corner) could be wrong though didnt have the best view at the time
F. off Roathy