The best City Keeper and worst

Tough one this. This is sure to stretch fans thoughts

I'll start with best - Neil Alexander ( very underrated). Worst - Peter Zois

Best - Alexander

Worst - Dimi Kanstantoplis

Best - Gavin ward
Allways thought he should have had a bigger career than he did

Worst - konstantopoulus
Enough said

Anybody remember that zoys guy back in the late 90s

Best; David Marshall
Worst; Stephen Bywater

Best - Marshall ( only better than Alexander due to the fact Marshall can save pens )

Worst - Bywater.

Best- Marshall or Alexander

Worst- Konstandopolas or however you spell his name, bywater has got be a close 2nd. Both terrible keepers

Best - Marshall is better than Alexander. That's why he's playing in the Prem and the highest Alexander played was Chamionship with us, still a great stopper though.


Worst - agent Dimi. Or Bywater. Enkleman was pretty shit mind

Best: Gavin Ward

Worst: Roath Magic

In my life time has to be:

Best - David Marshall, Neil Alexander and Tom Heaton
Worst - Turnbull, Warner, Konstantoplos, Howard

BEST- Jim Eadie and Billy Irwin were very good.

WORST - not sure as they all drop clangers and some don't have the opporunity to redeem themselves. I remember Frank Parsons having howlers.

BEST.....Marshall or Gavin Ward

WORST...Warner or Bywater

In the best category include Ron Healey,
worst -Lee Smelt

Worst - Gavin Ward - in his early days at city

Best - Gavin Ward - when we sold him

Marshall Best keeper

Dimi was the worst.

Best: Marshall
Worst: Bywater

I remember when it was announced that Bywater was joining. I googled and read the story below and thought 'Oh Shit'....

metro.co.uk/2010/09/22/stephen-bywaters-toilet-art-infuriates-neighbours-521091/

Best Ron Healey & Jon Hallworth

Worst Peter Zois & Ross Turnbull

Best - Andy Dibble

Worst - Lee Smelt

worst steven byewater total crap!best marshall or gavin ward!

remember the axeman?

best= ron healey or andy dibble
worst= bywater tw*t cost us big time

Best - Marshall or Alexander

Worst - Konstantopolous, Wolves away he was awful
- Bywater, cost us big time absolute shite

Best - Healey or Irwin
Worst - Smelt

Blooobirds

Best ..Gavin Ward

Worst..Stephen Bywater

Best Marshall then Alexandra

Worst DIMI then Enckleman the number of mistakes he made in his career is shocking

Can't believe people think Alexander was better than Marshall.

Marshall best for me by a distance.

Worse Konstopakjsndjdnd

Best - Marshall

Worst (In my time) - Steve Williams

Best - Healey or Irwin but recently Heaton for me.
Worst - Bywater by a long way.

Saw Zois in that game against Rotherham and while he made a few mistakes, he made some good saves too.

hallworth or marshall

dimi or bywater

David Marshall best
Frank Parsons worse

.....Tom Heaton will always be a favorite of mine. Excellent GK when Marshall was out for the season and I imagine that Heatons talent spurred Marshall on for sure. Heatons's expression after the Carling penalty saves were priceless and another iconic Bluebird image. Gave me a pair of signed gloves for my lad too. Top man and Burnley are very lucky to have him.