Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

should we rule out bringing in another Goalkeeper,

Wed Jul 31, 2013 8:27 pm

If marshall Had bad form or didn't handle the added pressure whats the answer? Joe lewis... would you put your faith in joe lewis.
and do you view marshall as a top 12 or better keeper in the PL.

it wasn't so long ago half of the trolls on here were saying we need a better championship keeper.
what do you regard marshall now? Vote of confidence or vote of caution?
just food for thought...

Re: should we rule out bringing in another Goalkeeper,

Wed Jul 31, 2013 8:28 pm

we signed simon moore

Re: should we rule out bringing in another Goalkeeper,

Wed Jul 31, 2013 8:33 pm

sloper_road_legend wrote:If marshall Had bad form or didn't handle the added pressure whats the answer? Joe lewis... would you put your faith in joe lewis.
and do you view marshall as a top 12 or better keeper in the PL.

it wasn't so long ago half of the trolls on here were saying we need a better championship keeper.
what do you regard marshall now? Vote of confidence or vote of caution?
just food for thought...

Marshall is an amazing keeper and will do right for us this season, we dont need a new keeper :malky:

Re: should we rule out bringing in another Goalkeeper,

Wed Jul 31, 2013 8:33 pm

I think another keeper would be a possibility with Lewis going out on loan and Moore being more involved with the Dvp matches and maybe carling cup etc...

Re: should we rule out bringing in another Goalkeeper,

Wed Jul 31, 2013 8:33 pm

sloper_road_legend wrote:If marshall Had bad form or didn't handle the added pressure whats the answer? Joe lewis... would you put your faith in joe lewis.
and do you view marshall as a top 12 or better keeper in the PL.

it wasn't so long ago half of the trolls on here were saying we need a better championship keeper.
what do you regard marshall now? Vote of confidence or vote of caution?
just food for thought...



In my opinion yes. Marshall has improved and is a pretty competent keeper, but Swansea's first season survival relied heavily on Vorm, I don't think Marshall is has good as him and I would imagine will cost us points.

I hope Marshall steps up and proves me wrong, but either way I think he needs a stronger challenger for the number one shirt.

Re: should we rule out bringing in another Goalkeeper,

Wed Jul 31, 2013 8:43 pm

Bluebina wrote:
sloper_road_legend wrote:If marshall Had bad form or didn't handle the added pressure whats the answer? Joe lewis... would you put your faith in joe lewis.
and do you view marshall as a top 12 or better keeper in the PL.

it wasn't so long ago half of the trolls on here were saying we need a better championship keeper.
what do you regard marshall now? Vote of confidence or vote of caution?
just food for thought...



In my opinion yes. Marshall has improved and is a pretty competent keeper, but Swansea's first season survival relied heavily on Vorm, I don't think Marshall is has good as him and I would imagine will cost us points.

I hope Marshall steps up and proves me wrong, but either way I think he needs a stronger challenger for the number one shirt.


my thoughts exactly the hardest thing to in the prem is usually keeping the ball out of the net especially away from home
he needs more competition, that would be at present my feelings

as for moore how good is he?

Re: should we rule out bringing in another Goalkeeper,

Wed Jul 31, 2013 8:58 pm

I wish we kept hold of Tom Heaton but we have a promising young goalkeeper in Simon Moore. I pray nothing happens to David Marshall but we should be fine :ayatollah:

Re: should we rule out bringing in another Goalkeeper,

Wed Jul 31, 2013 9:01 pm

Joe Lewis is crap.

Faith in Simon Moore though

Re: should we rule out bringing in another Goalkeeper,

Wed Jul 31, 2013 9:01 pm

Mynachdy_Bluebird wrote:I wish we kept hold of Tom Heaton but we have a promising young goalkeeper in Simon Moore. I pray nothing happens to David Marshall but we should be fine :ayatollah:


Tom Heaton for me was the biggest loss for us. But cant blame him for leaving either, he wanted to play games, and Marshall was in excellent form as well.