Rate Malkys' signings

I'll start - Etien - didn't see him so its a =0
Connolly = 5 won't cut it at right back that's for sure.
Maynard - injured for most of the season but he also had a poor injury record before he came to us = 2
Noone - Had his moments but has to be more consistent = 6.5
Kimbo - star of the show for me, a real premier talent= 8
Mutch - like Noone showed what he can do in glimpses = 6.5
Campbell - Needs a target man to play off IMO but certainly has an eye for goal before his injury = 7
Bellers - No one can doubt his commitment, but maybe not has magical has his first stint = 7.5

7 goals in 11 games and a 7...........
Maynard looked fantastic before his injury, which was his other knee before so hardly anybodies fault.

Rate Malky's signings by dicey nuff said