Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

"LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 12:52 pm

Compulsory life sentence for anybody who kills a policeman or a prison guard- I just don't get it!! Surely it should apply to anyone who is murdered regardless of their standing in society.We are all human beings and all equals in this world.I do feel for the police in this day and age.but this is a scandalous decision.!!

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 12:54 pm

Yes should be for anyone not just police

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 12:58 pm

darran1927 wrote:Yes should be for anyone not just police

All these child killers out there and they get 30 years(out in 20)but life if its a cop or prison guard! what a fucked up legal system we have!!!

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 1:08 pm

What about paedophiles, child killers. Although still bad and deserves a massive sentence- "natural life even", when you join the policeforce you know the risks. if police officers do there job properly then they should be trained well enough to avoid being killed in the line of duty. Its our children we should be prioritising by making sure we hand down atleast mandatory natural life sentences to people who have bad intentions towards children

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 1:12 pm

OddBalls wrote:What about paedophiles, child killers. Although still bad and deserves a massive sentence- "natural life even", when you join the policeforce you know the risks. if police officers do there job properly then they should be trained well enough to avoid being killed in the line of duty. Its our children we should be prioritising by making sure we hand down atleast mandatory life sentences to people who have bad intentions towards them

Whilst I disagree with Teresa May's change to the sentence, what you just said is utter bollox.

"If they do their job properly they are trained well enough to avoid being killed"
So those policewomen who answered a breaking and entering call had grenades thrown at them and shot weren't doing their jobs properly?

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 1:18 pm

CraigCCFC wrote:
OddBalls wrote:What about paedophiles, child killers. Although still bad and deserves a massive sentence- "natural life even", when you join the policeforce you know the risks. if police officers do there job properly then they should be trained well enough to avoid being killed in the line of duty. Its our children we should be prioritising by making sure we hand down atleast mandatory life sentences to people who have bad intentions towards them

Whilst I disagree with Teresa May's change to the sentence, what you just said is utter bollox.

"If they do their job properly they are trained well enough to avoid being killed"
So those policewomen who answered a breaking and entering call had grenades thrown at them and shot weren't doing their jobs properly?

For a start, 2 females, should have never been sent to that call... "A burglary in progress" And yes, in my opinion, when yor a police officer you should expect the unexpected. It was uncalled for what happen to them police officers. But should the bloke who carried it out deserve a longer sentence than say, ian Huntley who killed 2 ten year old children?

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 1:21 pm

OddBalls wrote:
CraigCCFC wrote:
OddBalls wrote:What about paedophiles, child killers. Although still bad and deserves a massive sentence- "natural life even", when you join the policeforce you know the risks. if police officers do there job properly then they should be trained well enough to avoid being killed in the line of duty. Its our children we should be prioritising by making sure we hand down atleast mandatory life sentences to people who have bad intentions towards them

Whilst I disagree with Teresa May's change to the sentence, what you just said is utter bollox.

"If they do their job properly they are trained well enough to avoid being killed"
So those policewomen who answered a breaking and entering call had grenades thrown at them and shot weren't doing their jobs properly?

For a start, 2 females, should have never been sent to that call... "A burglary in progress" And yes, in my opinion, when yor a police officer you should expect the unexpected. It was uncalled for what happen to them police officers. But should the bloke who carried it out deserve a longer sentence than say, ian Huntley who killed 2 ten year old children?

Read the top of my post, I disagree with the change but to say what you said about training is tripe mate.

If they were to expect things like that for every call then the police wouldnt go anywhere as they'd have to wait for armed support for a cat up a tree.

Women shouldnt be sent on a call like that? What calls would you allow them on?

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 1:29 pm

Women on the beat is a joke full stop. Its no wonder people have no fear of the police.

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 1:33 pm

That training statement is ridiculous to be fair :lol:

The police are not Chuck Norris or Batfink ffs :lol:

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 1:34 pm

CraigCCFC wrote:
OddBalls wrote:
CraigCCFC wrote:
OddBalls wrote:What about paedophiles, child killers. Although still bad and deserves a massive sentence- "natural life even", when you join the policeforce you know the risks. if police officers do there job properly then they should be trained well enough to avoid being killed in the line of duty. Its our children we should be prioritising by making sure we hand down atleast mandatory life sentences to people who have bad intentions towards them

Whilst I disagree with Teresa May's change to the sentence, what you just said is utter bollox.

"If they do their job properly they are trained well enough to avoid being killed"
So those policewomen who answered a breaking and entering call had grenades thrown at them and shot weren't doing their jobs properly?

For a start, 2 females, should have never been sent to that call... "A burglary in progress" And yes, in my opinion, when yor a police officer you should expect the unexpected. It was uncalled for what happen to them police officers. But should the bloke who carried it out deserve a longer sentence than say, ian Huntley who killed 2 ten year old children?

Read the top of my post, I disagree with the change but to say what you said about training is tripe mate.

If they were to expect things like that for every call then the police wouldnt go anywhere as they'd have to wait for armed support for a cat up a tree.

Women shouldnt be sent on a call like that? What calls would you allow them on?

But we ain't talking about a cat up a tree, we were talking about a "burglary in progress" that was the call! Even if it was a real burglary in progress, then you'd have to assume the culprits were tooled up, and take every precaution, sending 2 female officers to a call like that was in my opinion a mistake.

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 1:41 pm

OddBalls wrote:What about paedophiles, child killers. Although still bad and deserves a massive sentence- "natural life even", when you join the policeforce you know the risks. if police officers do there job properly then they should be trained well enough to avoid being killed in the line of duty. Its our children we should be prioritising by making sure we hand down atleast mandatory natural life sentences to people who have bad intentions towards children


:lol: :lol: :lol:

How do you train someone to prevent grenades exploding in under 3 seconds? If you know, then you should sell that information to the military!

Ludicrous statement.

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 1:55 pm

OhhhGa wrote:
OddBalls wrote:What about paedophiles, child killers. Although still bad and deserves a massive sentence- "natural life even", when you join the policeforce you know the risks. if police officers do there job properly then they should be trained well enough to avoid being killed in the line of duty. Its our children we should be prioritising by making sure we hand down atleast mandatory natural life sentences to people who have bad intentions towards children


:lol: :lol: :lol:

How do you train someone to prevent grenades exploding in under 3 seconds? If you know, then you should sell that information to the military!

Ludicrous statement.

Well for a start, there should have been more than 2 female officers answering that call! But like in any job in any walk of life you are going to get extreme cases where you can't avoid it! But in my opinion, when you're a police officer, you should have had enough training to minimise the risk... Especially when answering calls where there is certainly a good chance of getting injured. if there were male police officers at that call, would have more than likely got ontop of that fella before he went and executed atleast the one officer who he chased after and shot

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 2:32 pm

on a more serious note-if a steward at the ccs keeps nagging you to sit down all game and you unfortunately kill him then that carries a maximum sentence of 20 hours community service and a 3 game ban!!

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 3:16 pm

A bit harsh for killing a steward don't you think.

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 3:25 pm

darran1927 wrote:Yes should be for anyone not just police


Agree.

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 4:09 pm

sir ninian wrote:
darran1927 wrote:Yes should be for anyone not just police

All these child killers out there and they get 30 years(out in 20)but life if its a cop or prison guard! what a fucked up legal system we have!!!

Unfortunately there is not a lot LEGAL about our "Legal System"!!

The overiding law of the land is "Common Law" which is very rarely adhered to by the judiciary as they are now part of the establishment.

How one persons life is more valuable than any others, regardless of the job you do, is beyond me!

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 4:19 pm

Pre meditated murder = execution, no matter who the victim was :old:

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 4:51 pm

absolutely disgusting to imply a police officers life is more valuable than that of someone of a different profession. the solution is a life sentence for murder, not to let people off with lower sentences.

what an absolute idiot that politician is, to come up with crap like that.

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 5:02 pm

What about the loads of people who have died in police custody, and not one copper has been charged, let alone given a life sentance.

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 5:18 pm

wkdblue wrote:What about the loads of people who have died in police custody, and not one copper has been charged, let alone given a life sentance.

Good point. They get away with murder...literally. Even the sly digs they dish out when there twisting you up just for being drunk and swearing Lol. Coppers get enough protection, by closing ranks. Its joe public who need protecting from them half the time

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 5:41 pm

CraigCCFC wrote:
OddBalls wrote:What about paedophiles, child killers. Although still bad and deserves a massive sentence- "natural life even", when you join the policeforce you know the risks. if police officers do there job properly then they should be trained well enough to avoid being killed in the line of duty. Its our children we should be prioritising by making sure we hand down atleast mandatory life sentences to people who have bad intentions towards them

Whilst I disagree with Teresa May's change to the sentence, what you just said is utter bollox.

"If they do their job properly they are trained well enough to avoid being killed"
So those policewomen who answered a breaking and entering call had grenades thrown at them and shot weren't doing their jobs properly?

So if they had been male they would of been able to stop bullets and grenades ? Hmmmmm yeah right

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 6:20 pm

Nuclearblue wrote:
CraigCCFC wrote:
OddBalls wrote:What about paedophiles, child killers. Although still bad and deserves a massive sentence- "natural life even", when you join the policeforce you know the risks. if police officers do there job properly then they should be trained well enough to avoid being killed in the line of duty. Its our children we should be prioritising by making sure we hand down atleast mandatory life sentences to people who have bad intentions towards them

Whilst I disagree with Teresa May's change to the sentence, what you just said is utter bollox.

"If they do their job properly they are trained well enough to avoid being killed"
So those policewomen who answered a breaking and entering call had grenades thrown at them and shot weren't doing their jobs properly?

So if they had been male they would of been able to stop bullets and grenades ? Hmmmmm yeah right

No, what I'm saying is, if they had sufficient backup with them at a call of that nature like they should've had, instead of 2 female officers casualy strolling up the garden path as if they were posting leaflets, then maybe they would have stood a better chance. Certainly the one female officer may have been saved that nearly got away. You look how many will turn up on a saturday night for a drunk taking a piss in a doorway! You can bet a van full of big burley pigs turn up with vasaline in tow all wanting to get involved. Yet you report a burglary and yor lucky if you see one of them plastic community beat bobbies turn up lol. For me, the ones calling the shots have to take a bit of responsibility over the deaths of them to officers for sending them to a call like that in the first place. It was uncalled for I know, and the fella that done it was bang out of order.. Not for going after the police, but for killing 2 females, and he should rightly be banged up for the rest of his life for that reason alone, and not just because they were police... Not that he probably gives a fuk about dying in prison anyway.. The fella was obviously beyond repair even before he done that.

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Wed May 15, 2013 7:05 pm

redordead wrote:A bit harsh for killing a steward don't you think.


:lol:

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Sat May 18, 2013 3:55 pm

OddBalls wrote:
OhhhGa wrote:
OddBalls wrote:What about paedophiles, child killers. Although still bad and deserves a massive sentence- "natural life even", when you join the policeforce you know the risks. if police officers do there job properly then they should be trained well enough to avoid being killed in the line of duty. Its our children we should be prioritising by making sure we hand down atleast mandatory natural life sentences to people who have bad intentions towards children


:lol: :lol: :lol:

How do you train someone to prevent grenades exploding in under 3 seconds? If you know, then you should sell that information to the military!

Ludicrous statement.

Well for a start, there should have been more than 2 female officers answering that call! But like in any job in any walk of life you are going to get extreme cases where you can't avoid it! But in my opinion, when you're a police officer, you should have had enough training to minimise the risk... Especially when answering calls where there is certainly a good chance of getting injured. if there were male police officers at that call, would have more than likely got ontop of that fella before he went and executed atleast the one officer who he chased after and shot


So for every 999 call there should be how many officers attending? Two is perfectly acceptable considering they had no intelligence linking him with the address. The call claimed that someone had thrown a concrete slab through a window and run off. Why would you need more officers for that?

Are you suggesting they didn't have enough training? All officers are well-trained in 'minimising the risk' however this was completely unavoidable. Training has absolutely nothing to do with this tragedy. Male or female they would have been killed sadly.

What? He opened the front door and immediately shot both of them. As they were trying to take cover he emptied an entire round of 32 bullets in 31 seconds into them. How the hell could anyone 'get on top of that fella'?! They'd both been shot!

Evidently you don't understand the details of the case whatsoever.

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Sat May 18, 2013 4:17 pm

So where does it weigh in if the person was not of stable mind? Or it was in reaction? Self defense?

It's all well and good saying "If you kill someone, prison for life" - there are so many circumstances to acknowledge.

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Sat May 18, 2013 4:22 pm

And by the way, the Police Control Centre issues out 'codes' to calls and the officers base their response times, types of response and whatnot off of these codes.

You wouldn't send a full van of PSU Officers to a call for vandalism where the culprit was no longer on scene. Nor would they send ARVs there for the call either. They'd send a bog standard of two PC's in the closest vicinity to take details and build from there.

If it had come through as the man had a gun, then quite simply ARVs would have been sent to the call and a large incident would have been made.

Risk is minimized by these codes and at the end of the day, a call is only as good as what the call centre staff receive. They're not psychic at all.

Re: "LIFE SENTENCE IF YOU KILL A COP OR PRISON GUARD!!!"

Sun May 19, 2013 6:29 am

Mario Polotelli wrote:That training statement is ridiculous to be fair :lol:

The police are not Chuck Norris or Batfink ffs :lol:



You mean to tell me, they don't have Super Sonic Sonar :shock: or Wings Of Steel? :o