Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Player Ratings

Mon Apr 01, 2013 4:32 pm

Marshall - 6 passengers only get a 6, though his distribution was quick and better

Conolly - 6 drove at Rovers really well
Barnett - 7 Will he get enough games for a medal? Brilliant Hudson cover
Turner - 6 made some good tackles, again passenger
Taylor - 7 similar to Conolly, made good use of his space on that side

Bellamy - 7 typical Bellamy Perofmance
Gunnar - 8 brilliant through out, his role in Mason's goal cannot be understated
Mutch - 7 welcome back Mutch. I hated how people wrote him off so early. Brilliant
Kim - 9 MOM dictated the game, though a bit shit at corners
Conway - 7 could have done a bit more with the space he got

Campbell - 8 brilliant in a lone role, never score an easier goal

Mason - 7
Gestede - 6
Whitts - 7

Malky - 9 well done for changing the team around and bringing in new players when needed. Blackburn were battered today.

Re: Player Ratings

Mon Apr 01, 2013 4:38 pm

Marshall - 7 - good at dealing with crosses and apart from Kazim Richard's attempt a rather easy afternoon

Conolly - 7 drove at Rovers really well - agree with you
Barnett - 7 Did very well and mostly composed at the back
Turner - 7 Good in defence and did well to get forward and try and get involved
Taylor - 7 similar to Connolly, made good use of his space on that side

Bellamy - 8 His usual self to be honest
Gunnar - 9 The glue that held the midfield together and even got in on the act setting up Mason with great pass
Mutch - 8 Did very well and
Kim - 9 Only negative in his play was his dead ball delivery
Conway - 7 felt like he was trying too hard at times but rather that than a lazy player

Campbell - 8 brilliant work rate and did well to drop off into space for the goal

Gunnarsson was MOM for me but I wouldn't argue with anyone that chose Kim as they were both equally as great. Both of them should definitely start the next game completely on merit. :ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Re: Player Ratings

Mon Apr 01, 2013 4:53 pm

Marshall-8

Connolly-7
Barnett-8
Turner-9 (MOM)
Taylor-8

Conway-7
Gunnarson-8
Mutch-7
Kim-9

Bellamy-8
Campbell-8

:ayatollah: :ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Re: Player Ratings

Mon Apr 01, 2013 5:05 pm

Kimbo man of the match also thought Conway played very well and deserved an 8.

Re: Player Ratings

Mon Apr 01, 2013 5:07 pm

Marshall 7

Taylor 7
Barnett 7
Turner 7
Conally 7

Conway 7
Gunnar 7
Mutch 7
Kimbo 8 (MOTM)
Bellers7

Campbell 8

Re: Player Ratings

Mon Apr 01, 2013 5:40 pm

RFMH wrote:Marshall - 6 passengers only get a 6, though his distribution was quick and better

Conolly - 6 drove at Rovers really well
Barnett - 7 Will he get enough games for a medal? Brilliant Hudson cover
Turner - 6 made some good tackles, again passenger
Taylor - 7 similar to Conolly, made good use of his space on that side

Bellamy - 7 typical Bellamy Perofmance
Gunnar - 8 brilliant through out, his role in Mason's goal cannot be understated
Mutch - 7 welcome back Mutch. I hated how people wrote him off so early. Brilliant
Kim - 9 MOM dictated the game, though a bit shit at corners
Conway - 7 could have done a bit more with the space he got

Campbell - 8 brilliant in a lone role, never score an easier goal

Mason - 7
Gestede - 6
Whitts - 7

Malky - 9 well done for changing the team around and bringing in new players when needed. Blackburn were battered today.


Bit harsh for the three 6s? Great performance by all today! We are going up!!

Re: Player Ratings

Mon Apr 01, 2013 5:47 pm

Its all about opinions but I think a lot of you allow for Bellers premiership class into your ratings.

Bellers MOM and he also ref'ed the game well ;)

Re: Player Ratings

Mon Apr 01, 2013 6:47 pm

Llanellicardifffan wrote:
RFMH wrote:Marshall - 6 passengers only get a 6, though his distribution was quick and better

Conolly - 6 drove at Rovers really well
Barnett - 7 Will he get enough games for a medal? Brilliant Hudson cover
Turner - 6 made some good tackles, again passenger
Taylor - 7 similar to Conolly, made good use of his space on that side

Bellamy - 7 typical Bellamy Perofmance
Gunnar - 8 brilliant through out, his role in Mason's goal cannot be understated
Mutch - 7 welcome back Mutch. I hated how people wrote him off so early. Brilliant
Kim - 9 MOM dictated the game, though a bit shit at corners
Conway - 7 could have done a bit more with the space he got

Campbell - 8 brilliant in a lone role, never score an easier goal

Mason - 7
Gestede - 6
Whitts - 7

Malky - 9 well done for changing the team around and bringing in new players when needed. Blackburn were battered today.


Bit harsh for the three 6s? Great performance by all today! We are going up!!


More that they had nowt to do :ayatollah:

Re: Player Ratings

Mon Apr 01, 2013 9:29 pm

Marshall 7

Connolly 7
Turner 7
Barnett 8
Taylor 8

Conway 7
Gunnarsson 7
Mutch 7
Kim 8
Bellamy 7

Campbell 8


Whittingham 6
Mason 7
Gestede 6

Mason played a massive part in terms of attacking and took his goal brilliant and won the penalty.

Kim made things look too simple, quality.

Mutch looks like the player I saw against Newcastle in Pre Season.

Barnett was solid. Could possibly be the best loan we ever had.