Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

WHITTS GTFO

Sat Mar 30, 2013 9:28 pm

Sorry, but I have to say it, once again..shambles. Doesn't even know what he's doing at the moment.

If Conway started a game and ended it like he did, no way would he start the next game, whittingham has to be dropped ,

CONWAY IN FOR HIM.
NOONE IN FOR SMITH
BELLAMY IN FOR HELGUSON

smith not good enough
Whitts not good enough I don't care if he is 'whittingham' he's not good enough
we need bellamys hunger and speed

I'm still positive that we won't slip up, I believe in malky!!

Re: WHITTS GTFO

Sat Mar 30, 2013 9:38 pm

Any comment on the fact we were winning before Whittingham was subbed?

Re: WHITTS GTFO

Sat Mar 30, 2013 9:52 pm

Aramore wrote:Any comment on the fact we were winning before Whittingham was subbed?



Fair comment...but my opinion (don't have a go) I was stood there thinking to myself when he was taken off...what he actually did in the game to be influential..and I couldn't think of one..i don't know if I missed anything but I still can't think it..

I believe as whittingham was the left mid..his job is to get backk and go forward, he hardly ever went forward, didn't attempt to skill the defender and didn't threat, he was back by Taylor all game,

As soon as Conway come on, bang!! Instant impact. That's what you want from your wingers..understand?

Re: WHITTS GTFO

Sat Mar 30, 2013 10:53 pm

No wonder craig conway looks agressive all the time

Re: WHITTS GTFO

Sat Mar 30, 2013 11:13 pm

ryanbluebird1 wrote:
Aramore wrote:Any comment on the fact we were winning before Whittingham was subbed?



Fair comment...but my opinion (don't have a go) I was stood there thinking to myself when he was taken off...what he actually did in the game to be influential..and I couldn't think of one..i don't know if I missed anything but I still can't think it..

I believe as whittingham was the left mid..his job is to get backk and go forward, he hardly ever went forward, didn't attempt to skill the defender and didn't threat, he was back by Taylor all game,

As soon as Conway come on, bang!! Instant impact. That's what you want from your wingers..understand?


What doesn't help is when teams play 3 in midfield up against whits and gunner. End up getting pushed back too deep. When was the last time they bossed the midfield? Come on MM ffs do something different.

As for noone coming in, he's been poor for months.

Re: WHITTS GTFO

Sat Mar 30, 2013 11:27 pm

He contributed so little, that I didn't realise for ages that he'd been taken off.
That said, it was tricky to see at times through the smoke. tw*t should be banned for life.
Threw it onto the pitch when City were defending. What would of happened if Marshall had of let one in because of being unsighted. Some will never learn.

Re: WHITTS GTFO

Sat Mar 30, 2013 11:46 pm

Conway frustrates me so much, never takes on a man just runs it to silly positions, no pace at all, was at fault for our second penalty by dicking around with it and was at fault when we conceded to Derby. Much prefer Noone I'm sorry, need to be more attacking away

Re: WHITTS GTFO

Sun Mar 31, 2013 5:53 pm

Carpe Diem wrote:
ryanbluebird1 wrote:
Aramore wrote:Any comment on the fact we were winning before Whittingham was subbed?



Fair comment...but my opinion (don't have a go) I was stood there thinking to myself when he was taken off...what he actually did in the game to be influential..and I couldn't think of one..i don't know if I missed anything but I still can't think it..

I believe as whittingham was the left mid..his job is to get backk and go forward, he hardly ever went forward, didn't attempt to skill the defender and didn't threat, he was back by Taylor all game,

As soon as Conway come on, bang!! Instant impact. That's what you want from your wingers..understand?


What doesn't help is when teams play 3 in midfield up against whits and gunner. End up getting pushed back too deep. When was the last time they bossed the midfield? Come on MM ffs do something different.

As for noone coming in, he's been poor for months.


I agree that MM needs to try something different. I'd go with a midfield trio of Gunnar, Whitts and Kimbo with the latter having a roaming role as he holds the ball well, twists and turns and plays lovely short probing passes. I'd have Bellamy and Noone out wide with Campbell leading the line. This way we have a better chance of dominating midfield and playing Campbell in with some nice little passes in and around the box rather than just hoofing it forward as we have been doing lately. If Malky wants to play those tactics why didn't he get a big target man in during January? :ayatollah:

Re: WHITTS GTFO

Sun Mar 31, 2013 6:04 pm

moonboots wrote:
Carpe Diem wrote:
ryanbluebird1 wrote:
Aramore wrote:Any comment on the fact we were winning before Whittingham was subbed?



Fair comment...but my opinion (don't have a go) I was stood there thinking to myself when he was taken off...what he actually did in the game to be influential..and I couldn't think of one..i don't know if I missed anything but I still can't think it..

I believe as whittingham was the left mid..his job is to get backk and go forward, he hardly ever went forward, didn't attempt to skill the defender and didn't threat, he was back by Taylor all game,

As soon as Conway come on, bang!! Instant impact. That's what you want from your wingers..understand?


What doesn't help is when teams play 3 in midfield up against whits and gunner. End up getting pushed back too deep. When was the last time they bossed the midfield? Come on MM ffs do something different.

As for noone coming in, he's been poor for months.


I agree that MM needs to try something different. I'd go with a midfield trio of Gunnar, Whitts and Kimbo with the latter having a roaming role as he holds the ball well, twists and turns and plays lovely short probing passes. I'd have Bellamy and Noone out wide with Campbell leading the line. This way we have a better chance of dominating midfield and playing Campbell in with some nice little passes in and around the box rather than just hoofing it forward as we have been doing lately. If Malky wants to play those tactics why didn't he get a big target man in during January? :ayatollah:


Sounds good to me. Should have a least tried it by now, as how MM can be satisfied with our performances these past 2 months beggars belief

Re: WHITTS GTFO

Sun Mar 31, 2013 6:28 pm

Theres a surprise,we lose a game and we've got people that know better than Malky.

Re: WHITTS GTFO

Sun Mar 31, 2013 7:54 pm

Sneggyblubird wrote:Theres a surprise,we lose a game and we've got people that know better than Malky.


This.