Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 3:28 pm

Can this actually happen or not..?

There are more and more rumours that the City is going to be dropped for Cardiff Dragons FC and can that really happen..?

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 3:33 pm

Angry Man wrote:Can this actually happen or not..?

There are more and more rumours that the City is going to be dropped for Cardiff Dragons FC and can that really happen..?


Yes it can dont believe the people who say it can't !
Tan would have to go in front of a panel,of 3 EFA members and successfully argue that the club as it stands is not financially viable and could collapse under the current guise . Now if he can prove to them that the only way forward is to continue his so far successful rebrand they can grant him permission to change the name under fa rules . And he will win the case !
This happened with mk dons when wanting to move towns and they won

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 3:44 pm

I heard a bigger rumor that the rumours are a lie.

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 3:46 pm

Lies damned lies and statistics

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 4:26 pm

If it happens it will be the last straw for many people.

There would be no point in watching anymore as it would not even be Cardiff City F.C.

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 5:17 pm

thomasblue wrote:
Angry Man wrote:Can this actually happen or not..?

There are more and more rumours that the City is going to be dropped for Cardiff Dragons FC and can that really happen..?


Yes it can dont believe the people who say it can't !
Tan would have to go in front of a panel,of 3 EFA members and successfully argue that the club as it stands is not financially viable and could collapse under the current guise . Now if he can prove to them that the only way forward is to continue his so far successful rebrand they can grant him permission to change the name under fa rules . And he will win the case !
This happened with mk dons when wanting to move towns and they won


thanks for that mate. However I'm sure it would make more people nervous now.

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 5:19 pm

As this season has proved he could change the name and fans will still turn up in their droves, Adam.

:old:

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 5:50 pm

thomasblue wrote:
Angry Man wrote:Can this actually happen or not..?

There are more and more rumours that the City is going to be dropped for Cardiff Dragons FC and can that really happen..?


Yes it can dont believe the people who say it can't !
Tan would have to go in front of a panel,of 3 EFA members and successfully argue that the club as it stands is not financially viable and could collapse under the current guise . Now if he can prove to them that the only way forward is to continue his so far successful rebrand they can grant him permission to change the name under fa rules . And he will win the case !
This happened with mk dons when wanting to move towns and they won


Firstly, that is not the way it worked with mk dons and, secondly, can you produce the fa rules on the drivel you've just written?? if so, lets see it please.

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 6:51 pm

cityone wrote:
thomasblue wrote:
Angry Man wrote:Can this actually happen or not..?

There are more and more rumours that the City is going to be dropped for Cardiff Dragons FC and can that really happen..?


Yes it can dont believe the people who say it can't !
Tan would have to go in front of a panel,of 3 EFA members and successfully argue that the club as it stands is not financially viable and could collapse under the current guise . Now if he can prove to them that the only way forward is to continue his so far successful rebrand they can grant him permission to change the name under fa rules . And he will win the case !
This happened with mk dons when wanting to move towns and they won


Firstly, that is not the way it worked with mk dons and, secondly, can you produce the fa rules on the drivel you've just written?? if so, lets see it please.

premier league chairman has come out and said names cannot be changed ,people just posting bull shit on here again :o

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 7:45 pm

wez1927 wrote:
cityone wrote:
thomasblue wrote:
Angry Man wrote:Can this actually happen or not..?

There are more and more rumours that the City is going to be dropped for Cardiff Dragons FC and can that really happen..?


Yes it can dont believe the people who say it can't !
Tan would have to go in front of a panel,of 3 EFA members and successfully argue that the club as it stands is not financially viable and could collapse under the current guise . Now if he can prove to them that the only way forward is to continue his so far successful rebrand they can grant him permission to change the name under fa rules . And he will win the case !
This happened with mk dons when wanting to move towns and they won


Firstly, that is not the way it worked with mk dons and, secondly, can you produce the fa rules on the drivel you've just written?? if so, lets see it please.

premier league chairman has come out and said names cannot be changed ,people just posting bull shit on here again :o


There's some reall sad bullshitters and stirring arsewipes on here at present. City can't change their name - end of.

If they do they will have to go to the conference or leave the FA! FACT!!

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 7:48 pm

If either the name Cardiff or city gets dropped,I ll never go to a game again

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 8:09 pm

People who actually think we will change our name is incredibly stupid let's be honest now :roll: :lol:

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 9:09 pm

DONT WORRY THE WHOLE THING'S A LOAD OF BOLLOCKS.

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 9:14 pm

Brownie was this one of on good authority, a fact or rumour off a good mate again :lol:

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 9:26 pm

It's been against FL rules since 2004.

Re: Name change

Fri Feb 22, 2013 9:27 pm

murphy wrote:It's been against FL rules since 2004.

Are the rules different in the PL to the FL?
Genuine Question

Re: Name change

Sat Feb 23, 2013 1:16 am

eighty_8 wrote:
murphy wrote:It's been against FL rules since 2004.

Are the rules different in the PL to the FL?
Genuine Question

Not sure.

Re: Name change

Sat Feb 23, 2013 1:25 am

It can happen. People saying it cant are chatting a load of bollocks.

and I quote;


Premier League rules do not proscribe team name changes, although that may be addressed in the future but it is not allowed under FA regulations, which state: “A club competing in the Premier League (and other leagues) shall not be permitted to change its playing name without the prior written permission of the FA Council.”

In any event, it is understood that League chief executive Richard Scudamore would be fervently opposed to such a move by any of his member clubs.

A Premier League source said: “We just don’t believe it would be culturally acceptable in England. The value of the clubs comes from their heritage. It is highly unlikely that this could happen here.”


Proscribe means forbid, basically. 'Premier League rules do not forbid team name changes. A change needs prior written permission from the FA Council to do so. They said it is highly unlikely but that doesn't mean its impossible. Each case is independently assessed. If Tan puts forward a legitimate argument and takes finances into account then its likely they'll be all for it. Scudamore is one of many who will be making the decision just as a jury does so just because he opposes a move it does not mean it won't happen.

Seriously, are the FA going to let Tan change the name and keep pouring money into the club or are they going to risk him walking over the decision, us going into administration and further tarnishing the British game? Not to mention the TV deals that basically run football will make a killing from 2 Welsh derbies in the Prem. Football is a money game now and it would be in the FA's best interests from a money point of view to grant Tan his wish.

Re: Name change

Sat Feb 23, 2013 1:54 am

They will change us to just Cardiff dropping the city.

Re: Name change

Sat Feb 23, 2013 1:57 am

birchblue wrote:They will change us to just Cardiff dropping the city.


Like Arsenal, Liverpool, etc.

Makes sense given the scarf.