Ruud Van Nistelrooy or Robin Van Persie?

If you had to choose one of these two at the top of their game, in their prime. Which one?

Still haven't seen the best of RVP yet IMO.

Easily RVP, RVN didn't carry United like RVP does

If you had to choose one of these two at the top of their game, in their prime. Which one?

Thats a tough one with both being world class, If i could have one in their prime i would choose RVP as he has a better all round game in my opinion.

RVP by far. One of the best striker of the ball in the Premier Leauge.

Van Persie for me. He's just a goalscorer but his overall contribution to the team performance is superior to that of RVN. RVN was arguably a better finisher though. RVP though can play virtually any forward role required, whether it be to play up on his own, out wide or in a deeper role. Van Nistelrooy was limited in that respect.

If you had to choose one of these two at the top of their game, in their prime. Which one?

I've seen a few threads from you which relates to man utd! Question for you...who u gunna support next season when we are in the same league. Cardiff or Man utd?

If you had to choose one of these two at the top of their game, in their prime. Which one?

I've seen a few threads from you which relates to man utd! Question for you...who u gunna support next season when we are in the same league. Cardiff or Man utd?

Look at my reply on the other one!

Ooooo that's a very good question.

I'm goin to say Van Nistelhorse tho

Theards like this just piss me off,this sould be confined to a manc mb.
Its pretty obvious who this guy will be supporting next season should we go up,afterall why these two when there have been many great players over the years,imo those 2 would not get near the top twenty.

Theards like this just piss me off,this sould be confined to a manc mb.
Its pretty obvious who this guy will be supporting next season should we go up,afterall why these two when there have been many great players over the years,imo those 2 would not get near the top twenty.

Why? All sorts are discussed.

I found it a very interesting question, both top strikers of recent years.

Theards like this just piss me off,this sould be confined to a manc mb.
Its pretty obvious who this guy will be supporting next season should we go up,afterall why these two when there have been many great players over the years,imo those 2 would not get near the top twenty.

Maybe because it's two foreign players of the same country, playing in the same position, for the same club in a different era?
I get where you're coming from, seen the thread hours ago, but didn't appeal to me as not City related

Got me thinking now though, gotta be Van Persie, much more versatile!

Another United related post from the OP

Theards like this just piss me off,this sould be confined to a manc mb.
Its pretty obvious who this guy will be supporting next season should we go up,afterall why these two when there have been many great players over the years,imo those 2 would not get near the top twenty.

You know me do you? I made a thread because I was watching some videos on YouTube so I thought I'll see what other people think. It's a football message board, deal with it! I support CARDIFF CITY FC and that is the only club I will support in my life time!

I love talking about Football in general

I think RVP cuts it for me due to the different kinds of qualitys he has as a striker.