Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Player ratings v Birmingham

Wed Jan 02, 2013 12:36 pm

Can someone post their opinions and player ratings for yesterday's game, I had a full day on the piss, I am only aware of the result and I've seen the goal on YouTube, no idea how we played and how to managed without Whitts??

Thanks in advance.

Re: Player ratings v Birmingham

Wed Jan 02, 2013 3:43 pm

Bump

Re: Player ratings v Birmingham

Wed Jan 02, 2013 3:49 pm

Not going to type them all out as the ratings are in the captions.

Here they are: -

http://www.walesonline.co.uk/footballna ... -32528233/

Re: Player ratings v Birmingham

Wed Jan 02, 2013 3:51 pm

Gavlar wrote:Can someone post their opinions and player ratings for yesterday's game, I had a full day on the piss, I am only aware of the result and I've seen the goal on YouTube, no idea how we played and how to managed without Whitts??

Thanks in advance.

We were below average in my opinion.

The defence played okay and Lappin had a dodgy start but was solid in 2nd half.

In midfield we tackled well but lacked creativity with the only creative spark being between Kimbo and Conway which lead to our goal.

Up front Bellers and Mason ran themselves into the ground.

It was not a great game but we won and that is the sign of a team going up.

Re: Player ratings v Birmingham

Wed Jan 02, 2013 3:54 pm

Gareth (Wilts) wrote:
Gavlar wrote:Can someone post their opinions and player ratings for yesterday's game, I had a full day on the piss, I am only aware of the result and I've seen the goal on YouTube, no idea how we played and how to managed without Whitts??

Thanks in advance.

We were below average in my opinion.

The defence played okay and Lappin had a dodgy start but was solid in 2nd half.

In midfield we tackled well but lacked creativity with the only creative spark being between Kimbo and Conway which lead to our goal.

Up front Bellers and Mason ran themselves into the ground.

It was not a great game but we won and that is the sign of a team going up.


Thanks for that, Walesonline gave all the players 7s and 8s with the exception of Mutch who was rated 6

Re: Player ratings v Birmingham

Wed Jan 02, 2013 3:55 pm

Gavlar wrote:
Gareth (Wilts) wrote:
Gavlar wrote:Can someone post their opinions and player ratings for yesterday's game, I had a full day on the piss, I am only aware of the result and I've seen the goal on YouTube, no idea how we played and how to managed without Whitts??

Thanks in advance.

We were below average in my opinion.

The defence played okay and Lappin had a dodgy start but was solid in 2nd half.

In midfield we tackled well but lacked creativity with the only creative spark being between Kimbo and Conway which lead to our goal.

Up front Bellers and Mason ran themselves into the ground.

It was not a great game but we won and that is the sign of a team going up.


Thanks for that, Walesonline gave all the players 7s and 8s with the exception of Mutch who was rated 6


I would say that's about fair to be honest! :ayatollah:

Re: Player ratings v Birmingham

Wed Jan 02, 2013 9:05 pm

Gavlar wrote:
Gareth (Wilts) wrote:
Gavlar wrote:Can someone post their opinions and player ratings for yesterday's game, I had a full day on the piss, I am only aware of the result and I've seen the goal on YouTube, no idea how we played and how to managed without Whitts??

Thanks in advance.

We were below average in my opinion.

The defence played okay and Lappin had a dodgy start but was solid in 2nd half.

In midfield we tackled well but lacked creativity with the only creative spark being between Kimbo and Conway which lead to our goal.

Up front Bellers and Mason ran themselves into the ground.

It was not a great game but we won and that is the sign of a team going up.


Thanks for that, Walesonline gave all the players 7s and 8s with the exception of Mutch who was rated 6

i'd give them all 6 apart from Bellers and Marshall who would get 7 and Mutch who would get 5

Re: Player ratings v Birmingham

Wed Jan 02, 2013 9:14 pm

Hudson was solid as was turner,bellamy worked his arse off as usual
mutch was very poor,i really hope the lad finds some form,he definetly has the ability
Like mentioned we were below par but won away when the teams around us faltered-definite promotion material