“ Very poor window “

Steve kodiak

Wigans manager confirmed they had rejected the bid

Camarasa was all reports but like I said was probably talk to look good
For the fans.

Why didn't either player go elsewhere in England ?

Because nobody was stupid enough to match Wigans valuation and Camarasa chose to go back to spain and la liga.

Doesnt mean we couldn't have signed him. And I wouldnt pay £2mill for him anyway. Hes shit

Thats a contradictory statement? You saying one minute should be getting him then saying to expensive and crap? And camerasa didn't want come here which I have consistently told you its about players wanting to come here but you wouldn't have it... January is all about topping up squads if required due to injuries or are willing to pay over the odds for a striker ! We don't need a striker that's for sure.. and probably no midfielder available at right price or quality required..

We dont need a striker ?

We have Ward who is constantly injured and league 1 standard at best

Vassell is the hide and seek champion of the world

Glatzel is a carthorse and the biggest waste of money since Cornelius.

The only other option is a converted right back .

But no we dont need a striker at all

I never said we should be getting him hes no better than Madine was. We would have overpaid at £2mill. But it begs the question if we had that money available why didnt we get anyone. There are plenty of strikers in that price range who would jump at the chance to play here. Dont give time the same old bollocks of nobody wants to come that's just a cop out , you've obviously got a very low opinion of the club you supposedly support. We didnt try its blatently obvious.

Camarasa is a different matter, nobody can blame him for choosing la-liga over the championship.

There are always players available you just have to have the contacts but it's quite obvious that Harris doesnt.
Swansea only got Brewster because the manager knew him from England set up and the player said that himself. They have even less money than us so how do they get good players ? Or are they more attractive

Your bonkers! What strikers were jumping to join us in window? Wheres you contacts that told you we didnt try to sign these strikers that would jump at chance to sign for us? If I was a striker I wouldn't come here why? Because 6 strikers have failed thats why its because of way we play! Its not case of dont want to come here its case of do we want them did other teams want them was cost to high with wages taking into account! did manager want him to come here all are valid reasons for not signing players whatever position.. you've answered you own points with brewster he went where he knew manager and they play possession football plus are liverpool paying all his wages. This is precisely the points I've made previously yet you've ignored them and then use same reason why a player signed for swans and not another club! I give up let someone who have more patience than me to explain that you simply cannot sign players because you want them.. there are influences like manager or player connections, or style of play, or a manager preference where his player goes, or the overall cost everyone of these reasons will prevent a player coming here no matter how much we want them .

Why do you even support this club if you think so low of it ?
Every player is different but you bracket them all the same and nobody in the world wants to come here according to you. We better not sell any more because we wobt have enough players to put a team out next season according to your logic

all players are different yet you class all our strikers as useless and not actually strikers..... are you roathy in disguise never said no one will sign but gave you the reason why they may not have signed this window massive difference to your statement which are getting more and more contradictory! I've consistently said need to wait for summer to sign the 6/8 players we need when better players are available and at better prices than January is that clear enough for you?

Ok well even though this has been fun we will never agree. I think it's been a poor window and we could and should have done better . You think all we can attract are players from other teams youth set ups who have never played a game because we are not attractive as a club.

No need to carry it on any further but I'm definitely not Roathie lol

Put down the crack pipe Thomas, you're taking jibberish.

Fair play this thread is great

Its like talking to our unwanted friend just cannot get through about the January window being a bad time to sign players and the whys and nots of reasons players dont sign for a club any club that is..

Same could be said the other way.
You argue blind and never allow another opinion but your own

I've already said we wont agree on this but you carry on trying to justify your opinion anyway. Even though it shows a poor opinion of our club and its appeal

Not justifying anything and I'm not only one in this thread am I? You totally fail to see that you cannot simply buy player of the shelf as you are implying it is just a question of going to club and buy him and he'll come no questions asked. Anyway had enough of this nonsense time to have a drink and leave you to it