Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Re: “ WOW IAN EVATT IS NOT LIKED OR RATED:

Thu May 22, 2025 2:07 pm

We’ve graduated to being negative about someone before they’re even confirmed as a manager now. Let’s see who we bring in and judge them on performances with our Cardiff City team.

Re: “ WOW IAN EVATT IS NOT LIKED OR RATED:

Fri May 23, 2025 5:22 pm

Underhill1927 wrote:We’ve graduated to being negative about someone before they’re even confirmed as a manager now. Let’s see who we bring in and judge them on performances with our Cardiff City team.


Your statement seems just as bizarre,
flip a coin choose a manager and see how he goes , we judged tiza on performance look what happened.
What happened to looking at results pedigree record etc ,
then choosing the best candidate.
Fans don' t want a rookie and are right to question any manager before he is given the reigns at this football club.

Re: “ WOW IAN EVATT IS NOT LIKED OR RATED:

Fri May 23, 2025 5:28 pm

montyblue wrote:
Underhill1927 wrote:We’ve graduated to being negative about someone before they’re even confirmed as a manager now. Let’s see who we bring in and judge them on performances with our Cardiff City team.


Your statement seems just as bizarre,
flip a coin choose a manager and see how he goes , we judged tiza on performance look what happened.
What happened to looking at results pedigree record etc ,
then choosing the best candidate.
Fans don' t want a rookie and are right to question any manager before he is given the reigns at this football club.


The results Evatt has had in the lower leagues have been good - the stats have been posted and mentioned but he’s being written off without even being announced as our manager.

Re: “ WOW IAN EVATT IS NOT LIKED OR RATED:

Fri May 23, 2025 6:13 pm

Underhill1927 wrote:We’ve graduated to being negative about someone before they’re even confirmed as a manager now. Let’s see who we bring in and judge them on performances with our Cardiff City team.

Bang on ,50% win rate or higher will do me

Re: “ WOW IAN EVATT IS NOT LIKED OR RATED:

Fri May 23, 2025 7:01 pm

wez1927 wrote:
Underhill1927 wrote:We’ve graduated to being negative about someone before they’re even confirmed as a manager now. Let’s see who we bring in and judge them on performances with our Cardiff City team.

Bang on ,50% win rate or higher will do me


I think it'll be quite a small pool of managers in the lower leagues who have a 50%+ win rate - be interested to know who qualifies though.

He wouldn't touch us, but I'd love Sean Dyche - he'd kick some serious arse, ditch the tippy tappy crap and have a definitive playing style / approach - probably 442, get it forward quickly. We'd romp League 1 with him in charge.