BRISTOL CITY CHARGED WITH VINCENT TAN CHANTS AS CARDIFF COMP

We are becoming a laughing stock may as well appoint Judge Judy as our CEO

There were Swansea fans doing the aeroplane in reference to Emiliano Salas death after we smashed them , will they get any punishment?

It's been reported it was at the Ashton Gatev game Oct 6th! And nothing to do with

“Bristol City have been charged with misconduct by the FA due to alleged derogatory chants about Cardiff City owner Vincent Tan. The charge stems from two chants during the Championship match between the two sides on 6 October 2024 at Ashton Gate, which ended in a 1-1 draw.”

It was at Ashton Gate and no mention of who made the ‘complaint’


https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/arti ... vdxnyo.amp

Come on Chris,

It as Cardiff City on behalf of Tan and that’s a Fact.

It's been reported it was at the Ashton Gatev game Oct 6th! And nothing to do with

“Bristol City have been charged with misconduct by the FA due to alleged derogatory chants about Cardiff City owner Vincent Tan. The charge stems from two chants during the Championship match between the two sides on 6 October 2024 at Ashton Gate, which ended in a 1-1 draw.”

It was at Ashton Gate and no mention of who made the ‘complaint’


https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/arti ... vdxnyo.amp

Chris I realised afterwards but couldn't edit things..... it seems City staff are responsible for telling BC or FA what was shouted...unfortunately tan and ccfc come as a pair when something happens......and it never rains but pours where city's concerned..

Allan,


I’m glad you’ve come to be honest about it.

I heard the chant didn't think much of it at the time, I hear songs sung by our fans week in week out which are just as bad but it's football shit like this is sung through grounds all over the country every week, the chant was "you sold your souls to a lady boy"

Well isn't that calling him a transvestite or similar? If called a player a ladyboy sure it would be deemed offensive an owner is part of football club so while it's doesn't sound much in grand scheme of things nowadays it will be looked at as transfobia or something

Oh yea I agree in this day and age something like that would get flagged up but as football fans who been following cardiff for so long you become desensitised to chants like that so at the time I didn't really pay any attention to it but when I saw they had been charged that chant came into my mind and I thought it has to be thats what the charge was for

We as fans may not agree with the action but cannot hide from the fact its racist ...and if fa are citing club for it that shows how they view it? So condeming club for bringing it to fa attention is wrong no matter how people feel about tan..like said if aimed at player same action taken end of story..

Allan,


WHAT CHANTS THAT THEY ACTUALLY CHANTED HAVE NOT BEEN PUBLICLY PUT OUT:


I have to say as well, not ever heard of this happening in the UK before??

Cardiff fans use to sing about Elton John at Watford, about Swansea players etc etc

Never makes it right

And more recently away at Portsmouth and Plymouth about the Death of Queen Elizabeth.

Tan could open a can of worms here.

Allan ?

Bristol City will have to pay a fine for this and will be left with the responsibility of cleaning their own house up.

Fans caught singing such songs will be banned from supporting the club. Its the only direction that is offered to them. Its not an easy job that.

However it can work. It reminds me of the monkey chants at Black players back in the day. There came a law out making it racist and carrying a sentence. Overnight it stopped and rightly so.

Pathetic
Not much backbone have they? Cardiff City have a habit of reporting clubs to the police and FA
I find it hilarious, especially knowing what you lot chat week in week out
Hopefully other clubs now start giving you your own medicine
Spineless babies, you whole club is soft , like you haven't got enough to be embarrassed about already

Pathetic
Not much backbone have they? Cardiff City have a habit of reporting clubs to the police and FA
I find it hilarious, especially knowing what you lot chat week in week out
Hopefully other clubs now start giving you your own medicine
Spineless babies, you whole club is soft , like you haven't got enough to be embarrassed about already

Why are you on this forum? You lot are totally obsessed with us, it's pathetic and embarrassing. You all want to be us

Bristol City will have to pay a fine for this and will be left with the responsibility of cleaning their own house up.

Fans caught singing such songs will be banned from supporting the club. Its the only direction that is offered to them. Its not an easy job that.

However it can work. It reminds me of the monkey chants at Black players back in the day. There came a law out making it racist and carrying a sentence. Overnight it stopped and rightly so.

Bit of a difference between outright racist abuse, and a pisstake.

Bristol City will have to pay a fine for this and will be left with the responsibility of cleaning their own house up.

Fans caught singing such songs will be banned from supporting the club. Its the only direction that is offered to them. Its not an easy job that.

However it can work. It reminds me of the monkey chants at Black players back in the day. There came a law out making it racist and carrying a sentence. Overnight it stopped and rightly so.

Bit of a difference between outright racist abuse, and a pisstake.

We are living in a woke.

Bristol City will have to pay a fine for this and will be left with the responsibility of cleaning their own house up.

Fans caught singing such songs will be banned from supporting the club. Its the only direction that is offered to them. Its not an easy job that.

However it can work. It reminds me of the monkey chants at Black players back in the day. There came a law out making it racist and carrying a sentence. Overnight it stopped and rightly so.

Bit of a difference between outright racist abuse, and a pisstake.

We are living in a woke.

The tide is turning and Wokery is in retreat. Most of those who feign offence, at chants or banners, don’t attend football games.

Replies:

You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

It's been reported it was at the Ashton Gatev game Oct 6th! And nothing to do with

“Bristol City have been charged with misconduct by the FA due to alleged derogatory chants about Cardiff City owner Vincent Tan. The charge stems from two chants during the Championship match between the two sides on 6 October 2024 at Ashton Gate, which ended in a 1-1 draw.”

It was at Ashton Gate and no mention of who made the ‘complaint’


https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/arti ... vdxnyo.amp

Come on Chris,

It as Cardiff City on behalf of Tan and that’s a Fact.

Annis, it wasn’t aimed at Allan. I was just posting in response to some saying it was at the CCS and the article I saw didn’t say who had made the complaint

However, it is reasonable that it would have come from the club and if so, likely Wayne Nash

I’m actually with those who believe that if it was our club who made the complaint, it leaves a high risk of reciprocal complaints from other clubs (particularly the obvious one) for some of the chants (some of) our own supporters sing

One longstanding supporter who sits with me received an email a couple of weeks ago from said Mr Nash, telling him he was ‘on warning’ for his ‘over exuberant’ goal celebrations! It seems they have positioned the same (horrid jobsworth) steward to keep an eye on him and report back on his ‘behaviour’ whilst celebrating a goal!

Best left alone IMHO; particularly as our owner wasn’t at the game and I’m sure his hearing isn’t that good from thousands of miles away! Very few (if any) of us heard it ‘’live’, so assuming it was from our club, it must have been relayed to him after the game!

It's been reported it was at the Ashton Gatev game Oct 6th! And nothing to do with

“Bristol City have been charged with misconduct by the FA due to alleged derogatory chants about Cardiff City owner Vincent Tan. The charge stems from two chants during the Championship match between the two sides on 6 October 2024 at Ashton Gate, which ended in a 1-1 draw.”

It was at Ashton Gate and no mention of who made the ‘complaint’


https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/arti ... vdxnyo.amp

Come on Chris,

It as Cardiff City on behalf of Tan and that’s a Fact.

Annis, it wasn’t aimed at Allan. I was just posting in response to some saying it was at the CCS and the article I saw didn’t say who had made the complaint

However, it is reasonable that it would have come from the club and if so, likely Wayne Nash

I’m actually with those who believe that if it was our club who made the complaint, it leaves a high risk of reciprocal complaints from other clubs (particularly the obvious one) for some of the chants (some of) our own supporters sing

One longstanding supporter who sits with me received an email a couple of weeks ago from said Mr Nash, telling him he was ‘on warning’ for his ‘over exuberant’ goal celebrations! It seems they have positioned the same (horrid jobsworth) steward to keep an eye on him and report back on his ‘behaviour’ whilst celebrating a goal!

Best left alone IMHO; particularly as our owner wasn’t at the game and I’m sure his hearing isn’t that good from thousands of miles away! Very few (if any) of us heard it ‘’live’, so assuming it was from our club, it must have been relayed to him after the game!

Cheers Chris:

Unbelievable Chris,

They are killing our atmosphere with that type of email.

If it opens a can of worms then so be it. We have enough songs to not require anything relating to fathers abusing kids or the Queen. Maybe we can show some imagination and not put the F word in songs as well so that kids can join in to? Super Ollie Tanner for example.
Time to grow up everybody.

So the FA deem its not acceptable to call the owner of a football club a ladyboy but perfectly OK for thousands of people to call the club supporters sheep shaggers. World has gone very mad.

If it opens a can of worms then so be it. We have enough songs to not require anything relating to fathers abusing kids or the Queen. Maybe we can show some imagination and not put the F word in songs as well so that kids can join in to? Super Ollie Tanner for example.
Time to grow up everybody.

I agree with you but it's not going to happen unfortunately.

People will continue to sing those songs, sanctions or not, because they can't help themselves.

Other Spanish clubs have had serious sanctions put against them for racist abuse of Vinicius, but it hasn't stopped them.

So the FA deem its not acceptable to call the owner of a football club a ladyboy but perfectly OK for thousands of people to call the club supporters sheep shaggers. World has gone very mad.

Well if we call ourselves sheep shaggers how can we complain about away fans singing it? Tottenham fans been in trouble for several years about singing a self derogatory song which club hates.... football authorities all over world investigate things like Bristol so just let it run its course like every other incident ... Bristol probably get fine slap on wrist and fans probably find something else to sing at city in response... Mountain out of mole Hill springs to mind regarding city fans..

If anyone is in doubt about what fans called tan wasn't wrong. Since 2022 calling Chelsea fans rent boys ( something to do with owner) is classed as homophobic and can be arrested for hate crime fan given 3 Yr banning order after shouting it after a game .... People may think its nothing and part of fans rivalry.... I suggest they go into an Asian restaurant and call waiter one and see what happens to them...

If anyone is in doubt about what fans called tan wasn't wrong. Since 2022 calling Chelsea fans rent boys ( something to do with owner) is classed as homophobic and can be arrested for hate crime fan given 3 Yr banning order after shouting it after a game .... People may think its nothing and part of fans rivalry.... I suggest they go into an Asian restaurant and call waiter one and see what happens to them...

To be fair, I read the article this morning about the fans who shouted that at Chelsea fans.

He said he regretted it.

But also said that he didn't really know what it meant at the time, goes to show that fans get involved in these things without realising the significance of what they're saying.

If anyone is in doubt about what fans called tan wasn't wrong. Since 2022 calling Chelsea fans rent boys ( something to do with owner) is classed as homophobic and can be arrested for hate crime fan given 3 Yr banning order after shouting it after a game .... People may think its nothing and part of fans rivalry.... I suggest they go into an Asian restaurant and call waiter one and see what happens to them...

To be fair, I read the article this morning about the fans who shouted that at Chelsea fans.

He said he regretted it.

But also said that he didn't really know what it meant at the time, goes to show that fans get involved in these things without realising the significance of what they're saying.

Ned he didn't realise it was a criminal offence which is fair enough ..... but I highlighted it because people on here think there's nothing wrong in singing it at tan..... not backing tan just making point anyone could have reported the singing and as we know all clubs are responsible for fans actions in and out ground? FA response is just a process that will take its course and that's end of it! no need to go ott like our fans have done...

If anyone is in doubt about what fans called tan wasn't wrong. Since 2022 calling Chelsea fans rent boys ( something to do with owner) is classed as homophobic and can be arrested for hate crime fan given 3 Yr banning order after shouting it after a game .... People may think its nothing and part of fans rivalry.... I suggest they go into an Asian restaurant and call waiter one and see what happens to them...

To be fair, I read the article this morning about the fans who shouted that at Chelsea fans.

He said he regretted it.

But also said that he didn't really know what it meant at the time, goes to show that fans get involved in these things without realising the significance of what they're saying.

Ned he didn't realise it was a criminal offence which is fair enough ..... but I highlighted it because people on here think there's nothing wrong in singing it at tan..... not backing tan just making point anyone could have reported the singing and as we know all clubs are responsible for fans actions in and out ground? FA response is just a process that will take its course and that's end of it! no need to go ott like our fans have done...

I suspect tan didn't do anything it was more fact it was reported and as pointed out its a criminal offence so as to be investigated ..... this is happening nearly every week across Europe and UK at games ..... down the line club will be fined and warned about their fans behaviour .....

Pathetic
Not much backbone have they? Cardiff City have a habit of reporting clubs to the police and FA
I find it hilarious, especially knowing what you lot chat week in week out
Hopefully other clubs now start giving you your own medicine
Spineless babies, you whole club is soft , like you haven't got enough to be embarrassed about already

And here he comes; the whiter than white ‘Jack’!

If you had any credibility, you’d be saying ‘I’m off to my own site to discuss proper football things in a manner befitting our own environment and forward thinking”

Oh no! I forgot (not!), your Planet Swamp site is an embarrassment, so you get your ‘kicks’ from jealously trawling your capital club’s web-site looking for ‘snippets’ of garbage to soothe your inferiority complex!

Your club ain’t without its faults, fella. In fact, far from it!

Pathetic
Not much backbone have they? Cardiff City have a habit of reporting clubs to the police and FA
I find it hilarious, especially knowing what you lot chat week in week out
Hopefully other clubs now start giving you your own medicine
Spineless babies, you whole club is soft , like you haven't got enough to be embarrassed about already

And here he comes; the whiter than white ‘Jack’!

If you had any credibility, you’d be saying ‘I’m off to my own site to discuss proper football things in a manner befitting our own environment and forward thinking”

Oh no! I forgot (not!), your Planet Swamp site is an embarrassment, so you get your ‘kicks’ from jealously trawling your capital club’s web-site looking for ‘snippets’ of garbage to soothe your inferiority complex!

Your club ain’t without its faults, fella. In fact, far from it!

Chris, I bet he doesn't go on other clubs forums after they get pulled up for racist or other chants? But at least they'll win an Oscar for ‘Most obsessed fans in football!’