POLL " GREAT PLAYERS EVER TO WEAR A CITY SHIRT"

Hang on a minute why the feck isn't Robbie Fowler on that list ?..................................................................................................................................................Oh yeah he was a useless unloyal rob us blind cocaine snorting washed up scouser.

I can't decide. Great players or City legends. Most would lean towards players from their childhood. Gibson, Woodruff, Tony Evans, Alan Campbell and Willie Anderson could also be on that list.

why cant i vote, its a fix the votes are rigged i say

Why Keenor should win...

Being our greatest footballer is MORE than being a Footballer...it is US...the fans in the shirt.

Hence our love for people like Jason Perry...he was a fan on the pitch playing with pride for the badge on his chest..

Fred Keenor went to Wembley with Cardiff in 1925 for the FA Cup final
We have to remember the FA Cup was then THE most famous competition in the world..THE Cup to win.
It was also very difficult to win as the talent used to be spread throughout football...this was before you could 'buy' success...
To make the final was HUGE...a massive achievement....
In front of a watching Lloyd George the Welsh team gallantly lost.
But a bit like 2008...thousands of fans turned out for the losing team..only at City Hall rather than the bay.

Fred (who'd faced German machine guns) said to the fans of his home City....his fellow Welshmen, Women and Children..

'Don't be down in the mouth! I promise I'll bring that Cup home for you in the next two years!!'

He was as good as his word folks....

Will now leave it to Carl to sort it all out

Just been reading up on some of the older posts and came upon this one after researching Don Murray.(remember him well)

Apparently only top 25 all time best city players allowed on this list in 2010.

I cannot believe that the 70's best goal scoring talents are not even on the list - Tony Evans and Adrian Alston - they would be in my top 10 never mind top 25.

What about the likes of Ian Gibson, Ron Healy, Jeff Hemmerman ?

Craig Bellamy in the 25? yes a player but not as a city player - far more worthy players over the years.

Blooobirds Forever !!!

No players in there that got promoted to PL and played there one season?

No Whittingham, howler.

Ernie near top??? Just because scored record goals in one season, that was all nothing else before or after!! Besides his greed in trying to score more goals and ignoring other players cost us promotion! We should have won more games but he wouldn't pass for others to score!!

Prefer Willie Anderson or Carl dale and the legendary Phil stant!

Your missing Ron Healy best ever city keeper

I would agree. Until Marshall came along

This is a daft list. Meaningless without Allchurch and Gibson who were both miles better than John Charles. For Cardiff city anyway.

NO BILLY HARDY OR LEN DAVIES WHAT A LOAD OF SHITE .... sorry but that list is littered with lower league players!