" Fickleness / We have some Fickle fans "

Tonight’s result proves to me that if we follow this with another couple of bad results and we lose the next three there are certain fans who will be on Mick’s back.

Not many but they are rotten apples and spread more and more.

We have some fickle fans.

They will turn on Mick.

They have already turned on Murphy.

Horrible fans.

Surely fans can voice their opinions?

Everyone can. As can I and that is my opinion.

Tonight’s result proves to me that if we follow this with another couple of bad results and we lose the next three there are certain fans who will be on Mick’s back.

Not many but they are rotten apples and spread more and more.

We have some fickle fans.

They will turn on Mick.

They have already turned on Murphy.

Horrible fans.

Surely fans can voice their opinions?

Everyone can. As can I and that is my opinion.

That we are fickle mate for saying what we feel about certain players or the way we feel about a match if it’s not to your liking

Your having a giraffe

Tonight’s result proves to me that if we follow this with another couple of bad results and we lose the next three there are certain fans who will be on Mick’s back.

Not many but they are rotten apples and spread more and more.

We have some fickle fans.

They will turn on Mick.

They have already turned on Murphy.

Horrible fans.

Surely fans can voice their opinions?

Everyone can. As can I and that is my opinion.

That we are fickle mate for saying what we feel about certain players or the way we feel about a match if it’s not to your liking

Your having a giraffe

Why can I not say someone is fickle if everyone is entitled to an opinion.

As I have explained many times the fickle fans isn’t Aimed at people saying we played badly or Murphy played badly per se. It’s people criticising his character after 30 minutes. That’s less someone’s opinion and more someone being OTT. Hence fickle.

This is the definition of fickle

likely to change, especially due to caprice, irresolution, or instability; casually changeable: fickle weather. not constant or loyal in affections: a fickle lover

Absolutely what we have at our club.

Who gives the right to this fan called Maccydee , to call us fans FICKLE?

i do not post much on here, but i come on for my daily read and yes we played not so good at Hudders, so am i fickle?

Who gives the right to this fan called Maccydee , to call us fans FICKLE?

i do not post much on here, but i come on for my daily read and yes we played not so good at Hudders, so am i fickle?

In fairness I don’t think he’s on about anyone making comments about the not so good performance from the team, it’s more about a certain somebody that after 30 minutes said that Murphy looked disinterested. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, of course they are, nobody has to agree but everyone should respect other people’s opinions.

Who gives the right to this fan called Maccydee , to call us fans FICKLE?

i do not post much on here, but i come on for my daily read and yes we played not so good at Hudders, so am i fickle?

Nope not fickle for saying that.

See my above definition of fickle.

Who gives the right to this fan called Maccydee , to call us fans FICKLE?

i do not post much on here, but i come on for my daily read and yes we played not so good at Hudders, so am i fickle?

Nope not fickle for saying that.

See my above definition of fickle.

I said he looked disinterested, so im fickle too!! Perhaps Murphy needs to adress his body language during games,as for me,at times thats how it looks,his head drops,he loses possession, gets pushed off the ball (more than once in last game) he looks sulky! I said he would get equal amounts of praise,IF he shows up & plays well,but thats my opinion on him,not the managers,and its he that picks the team.
ALL supporters/fans have the right to comment on ANY particular player(and we do!) Whether its in criticism or praise,I dont get this judgement of fellow fans,because of their opinion??

Who gives the right to this fan called Maccydee , to call us fans FICKLE?

i do not post much on here, but i come on for my daily read and yes we played not so good at Hudders, so am i fickle?

Nope not fickle for saying that.

See my above definition of fickle.

I said he looked disinterested, so im fickle too!! Perhaps Murphy needs to adress his body language during games,as for me,at times thats how it looks,his head drops,he loses possession, gets pushed off the ball (more than once in last game) he looks sulky! I said he would get equal amounts of praise,IF he shows up & plays well,but thats my opinion on him,not the managers,and its he that picks the team.
ALL supporters/fans have the right to comment on ANY particular player(and we do!) Whether its in criticism or praise,I dont get this judgement of fellow fans,because of their opinion??

I admit it, I am fickle as fcuk during the game when I am pumped up on emotion.

I really think we have used Josh incorrectly for 18 months as he is a forward who does his bit defending but that's it. And luckily for Ralls, he should be quite comfortable because between Harris and Warnock we stunted his growth as a championship midfielder with his safety-first hoofs. What i am saying here is I am really rooting for these two a tad more than the other boys in blue....

But, on Friday if I wrote what I was saying during the game about their two performances it would have come across as incredibly negative, and that's it. When you read the comments, not in real-time they lose their relevance and they do look ridiculously negative.

Another example... when Pack gave away the ball and was too slow to even grab the lad against Bournemouth and said "That's what you get from Pack" I was saying it phlegmatically, coldly. IMO its a fact, we improve our passing and he takes more risks, but lose a lot of mobility. That could be read as aggressive & resentful.

We have had 1000's of years of understanding body & verbal language and a decade of instant social media. Its a poor medium

Reading what Sven says Maccydee its actual you who is very fickle and you do not even attend matches

Reading what Sven says Maccydee its actual you who is very fickle and you do not even attend matches

Man there are some people using their multis to have a pop at me more than once.

f*cking clowns.

How the f**k do you know if I attend matches? Are you my diary keeper? I’ve attended as many games as you this season prick.

Go away and learn to spell. It will help all of your usernames.

Tonight’s result proves to me that if we follow this with another couple of bad results and we lose the next three there are certain fans who will be on Mick’s back.

Not many but they are rotten apples and spread more and more.

We have some fickle fans.

They will turn on Mick.

They have already turned on Murphy.

Horrible fans.

The better the run, the more the expectancy, the bigger the drama when we lose

Tonight’s result proves to me that if we follow this with another couple of bad results and we lose the next three there are certain fans who will be on Mick’s back.

Not many but they are rotten apples and spread more and more.

We have some fickle fans.

They will turn on Mick.

They have already turned on Murphy.

Horrible fans.

The better the run, the more the expectancy, the bigger the drama when we lose

I will always remember promotion season under Warnock and how over Christmas fans wanted him out and said we had no chance of going up. It’s opinions yes but it’s fickle. There’s no other way to describe it.

Encouraging Josh Murphy would only be of benefit to Cardiff City FC in my opinion. I’ve been in the ground and heard him being booed and refuse to believe he has ever had a bad game on purpose, despite being frustrating on occasions. The manager is employed to provide an analytical observation of his performance and much more qualified than I am. Booing doesn’t help the reflective process when identifying specific areas of self-improvement and the fact things were done historically, hardly provides a counter argument for this negative, regressive mindset to continue.



Part of my job is coaching and mentoring and I have seen first hand the positive impact confidence can have on results.

Encouraging Josh Murphy would only be of benefit to Cardiff City FC in my opinion. I’ve been in the ground and heard him being booed and refuse to believe he has ever had a bad game on purpose, despite being frustrating on occasions. The manager is employed to provide an analytical observation of his performance and much more qualified than I am. Booing doesn’t help the reflective process when identifying specific areas of self-improvement and the fact things were done historically, hardly provides a counter argument for this negative, regressive mindset to continue.



Part of my job is coaching and mentoring and I have seen first hand the positive impact confidence can have on results.

Exactly my point. Lol

Difficult to prove mate.. if those showing disapproval of Murphy are consistent in that view, then fickle they are not. They just have a view that’s different to yours.

Positive mentoring wasn’t your original point.

Difficult to prove mate.. if those showing disapproval of Murphy are consistent in that view, then fickle they are not. They just have a view that’s different to yours.

Positive mentoring wasn’t your original point.

They won’t be on his back when he’s doing well will they?

That’s my point. Half hour in to the game saying he doesn’t look interested. Half hour.

I think that’s their point.. he’s got all the ability in the World, but for whatever reason seems unable to reproduce it with any consistency. Hopefully that will change with this Manager.

I think that’s their point.. he’s got all the ability in the World, but for whatever reason seems unable to reproduce it with any consistency. Hopefully that will change with this Manager.

And he has been proving it and then half hour into a game he gets criticism.

You don’t mean..half an hour.. could be career ending.

I think that’s their point.. he’s got all the ability in the World, but for whatever reason seems unable to reproduce it with any consistency. Hopefully that will change with this Manager.

And he has been proving it and then half hour into a game he gets criticism.

He has had one good game,lets not beat around the bush here! A couple of good passes/runs doesnt mean he has proved anything as of yet.
I hope he can now push on,and become the £11m player we hoped he would become,but the jury is still out for me.being consistent means more than what he has been of late to me.As I have said,and i have done,he will get equal amounts of praise when he plays well,as the amount of stick he gets when he doesnt.but his body language needs to change,especially when he isnt doing too good.he gives off the wrong kind of messages at present,thus leaving himself open to being criticized.

I think that’s their point.. he’s got all the ability in the World, but for whatever reason seems unable to reproduce it with any consistency. Hopefully that will change with this Manager.

And he has been proving it and then half hour into a game he gets criticism.

He has had one good game,lets not beat around the bush here! A couple of good passes/runs doesnt mean he has proved anything as of yet.
I hope he can now push on,and become the £11m player we hoped he would become,but the jury is still out for me.being consistent means more than what he has been of late to me.As I have said,and i have done,he will get equal amounts of praise when he plays well,as the amount of stick he gets when he doesnt.but his body language needs to change,especially when he isnt doing too good.he gives off the wrong kind of messages at present,thus leaving himself open to being criticized.

He doesn’t need to become an £11 million player in my opinion as he didn’t ask to be purchased for that amount, but I agree that he does need to be more consistent. As for the body language, that depends on how people interpret it and just because he doesn’t go slapping the badge, doesn’t necessarily mean he doesn’t care. Whittingham was often criticised for his laid back approach, despite being one of the best players to ever represent the club. I think if Murphy’s performances are good, the body language is irrelevant, but there will always be fans who want 11 “fist pumpers” on the pitch.

Fickle fans that's just it fans not supporters. Those with the biggest mouths are usually the ones who never go and support the club just chopse off on here.

Fickle fans that's just it fans not supporters. Those with the biggest mouths are usually the ones who never go and support the club just chopse off on here.

My original post has been proven correct in many ways.

Criticism is due but over reaction is crazy.

He has made mistakes (not picking Wilson) but many of what people are saying is hindsight.

Tonight’s result proves to me that if we follow this with another couple of bad results and we lose the next three there are certain fans who will be on Mick’s back.

Not many but they are rotten apples and spread more and more.

We have some fickle fans.

They will turn on Mick.

They have already turned on Murphy.

Horrible fans.

Nice of you to give them the platform to start, Neil...

He’s just on a wind up again mate.

A few comments about how poor the team played and Murphy in particular.
Was just some posters speaking the truth and I see nothing wrong with that.

WUM

Nor me Paul, fans are allowed to express their feelings after a game and how they feel, does not make them fickle? because they feel a player had a bad game.

you’re right lads you see the game as you see it we have a right to have a opinion we pay enough money to follow city

Ah well I’ve seen plenty of worse results etc supporting the city in the early 1970s ,win ,lose or draw always be a bluebirds C.C.F.C for Life

Tonight’s result proves to me that if we follow this with another couple of bad results and we lose the next three there are certain fans who will be on Mick’s back.

Not many but they are rotten apples and spread more and more.

We have some fickle fans.

They will turn on Mick.

They have already turned on Murphy.

Horrible fans.

Nice of you to give them the platform to start, Neil...

He’s just on a wind up again mate.

A few comments about how poor the team played and Murphy in particular.
Was just some posters speaking the truth and I see nothing wrong with that.

WUM

Nor me Paul, fans are allowed to express their feelings after a game and how they feel, does not make them fickle? because they feel a player had a bad game.

you’re right lads you see the game as you see it we have a right to have a opinion we pay enough money to follow city

Exactly Martin

Tonight’s result proves to me that if we follow this with another couple of bad results and we lose the next three there are certain fans who will be on Mick’s back.

Not many but they are rotten apples and spread more and more.

We have some fickle fans.

They will turn on Mick.

They have already turned on Murphy.

Horrible fans.

Nice of you to give them the platform to start, Neil...

He’s just on a wind up again mate.

A few comments about how poor the team played and Murphy in particular.
Was just some posters speaking the truth and I see nothing wrong with that.

WUM

Nor me Paul, fans are allowed to express their feelings after a game and how they feel, does not make them fickle? because they feel a player had a bad game.

you’re right lads you see the game as you see it we have a right to have a opinion we pay enough money to follow city

And I am too entitled to have an opinion and to be fair my post was correct.

Some have turned on him after a couple of bad results. As I predicted.

They are also turning on the players.

Of course it’s their right to do that. As it is my right to call them out for it.

Ah well I’ve seen plenty of worse results etc supporting the city in the early 1970s ,win ,lose or draw always be a bluebirds C.C.F.C for Life

Hear hear

Ah well I’ve seen plenty of worse results etc supporting the city in the early 1970s ,win ,lose or draw always be a bluebirds C.C.F.C for Life

Hear hear