Mon Feb 10, 2020 1:54 am
BlackMagic wrote:dogfound wrote:BlackMagic wrote:dogfound wrote:proving you wrong is easy.......getting YOU to admit that is quite simply impossible..
and yeah mate im distressed and frustrated.. so distressed and frustrated im not even arguing with you ,just giving you advice.. stick to the one or two things you know a little bit about.. your academy post is a good example .. level and reasonable and not anything in there anyone could disagree with .
Oh great, this should be fun then.
Please prove to me most Welsh football fans come from Cardiff. Should be easy as you say, right?
I shall await with wondrous expectation at what possibly could be typed in response...
the FAW said 80% come from a 25% radius of the CCS , I read it , believed it .. so email them and call them liars .. or just have your own thoughts/agenda that is wrong.. i don't much care which.. its more for you to prove otherwise which really should be very entertaining.. hint..mid Wales is not highly populated..
80% of what?
How can you have a 25% radius?
Why would I email them and call them liars over something I don’t believe they said?
Why did you email them and ask them how many tickets were sold with a certain radius (%?) - this sounds very much like a made up scenario doesn’t it![]()
I ask again. If Liverpool were playing in Mexico, most fans at the game would come from Mexico. Do you reckon most Liverpool fans are Mexican?
Next time Wales play at the Liberty. If I ask if most tickets to the game were sold within a certain radius of Swansea and they obviously say yes - is your opinion then going to be that most Welsh fans come from Swansea?
Finally, have you thought this through?
Mon Feb 10, 2020 2:20 am
Mon Feb 10, 2020 8:15 am
dogfound wrote:
I put the % in instead of miles to give you 1 and make you feel a bit better...must have been a hard day being wrong even more than normal.
answer....the attendance at the library will be much smaller. so therefore the percentage even in the unlikely event of it being as high as 80% will be much less in numbers.. and sorry but yes I had thought it through and actually threw a sprat.. couldn't help myself, your so predictable..lol
Mon Feb 10, 2020 8:17 am
BlackMagic wrote:dogfound wrote:
I put the % in instead of miles to give you 1 and make you feel a bit better...must have been a hard day being wrong even more than normal.
answer....the attendance at the library will be much smaller. so therefore the percentage even in the unlikely event of it being as high as 80% will be much less in numbers.. and sorry but yes I had thought it through and actually threw a sprat.. couldn't help myself, your so predictable..lol
So not percentage then? At least that now makes sense even if it’s logic is utterly ludicrous.
So what you are saying is that if the same standards you have set in Cardiff - are met in Swansea (% of attendance being from within a certain proximity to the stadium)... then it doesn’t count?![]()
And therein lies the flaw in your shoddily cobbled together view.
Not to mention that you are making a geographical argument (which was my point not yours) to back up your club based claim, it wasn’t geographical. For example Newport is within that perimeter and they do not support Cardiff.
So if it’s true that you have thought this view though... that’s frightening in the extreme
Mon Feb 10, 2020 8:39 am
BlackMagic wrote:Igovernor wrote:BlackMagic wrote:And there is the predicted silence...
![]()
Careful now!
your threats don’t interest me. If nobody else faces sanctions for saying “there is the predicted silence” then neither should I. If it annoys you then it annoys you, that’s the things you have to deal with in life. You do not moderate a site based on personal feelings unfortunately, you moderate it by the rules set out by the site.
Mon Feb 10, 2020 9:51 am
Bluedodo wrote:
I'm still waiting for you to prove your claim about mid and north wales.... Been nearly 24 hours now still waiting.
Mon Feb 10, 2020 10:33 am
BlackMagic wrote:Bluedodo wrote:
I'm still waiting for you to prove your claim about mid and north wales.... Been nearly 24 hours now still waiting.
Why are you asking the same questions?
I said, you show me where it clearly shows there are more Welsh football supporters that are Cardiff fans and without doubt that same source will also show the proof you are asking for. Easy
Mon Feb 10, 2020 11:16 am
BlackMagic wrote:Bluedodo wrote:BlackMagic wrote:Bluedodo wrote:
I'm still waiting for you to prove your claim about mid and north wales.... Been nearly 24 hours now still waiting.
Why are you asking the same questions?
I said, you show me where it clearly shows there are more Welsh football supporters that are Cardiff fans and without doubt that same source will also show the proof you are asking for. Easy
No no no my friend, you made the ridiculous claim and I've asked you several times to prove it.
You won't because you can't.
Instead you'll twist it abd tfy to make out I hsve something to prove.
You made a claim, you cant back it up... End of.
You can say no as much as you like. It doesn’t change matters.
The initial claim was that Cardiff fans represent the International fanbase more than any other group. I rightly disagreed. You entered the conversation and seemed to also agree with that initial ridiculous claim.
So you now will have to prove to us all that me disagreeing is ‘ridiculous’ and once you do that - then without doubt that same source will also show you what you are looking for.
If you can’t prove that then I’m not sure how I can help you?
Mon Feb 10, 2020 11:48 am
Mon Feb 10, 2020 1:05 pm
BlackMagic wrote:Bluedodo wrote:
Oh dear poor roathie shown to be wrong..... Yet again.
I don't care about your earlier discussion i joined because of your ridiculous claim that even 24 hours on youve failed to prove.
Bet you wish you hadnt made such a daft claim now eh.
Whether you care is irrelevant. One you join that conversation, the rules of that conversation automatically get transferred to you.
Shown to be wrong? Where? Is this the usual thing where the gang cannot prove me wrong... so just pretend they have![]()
I absolutely stand by my correct comment and will say it every time this debate occurs - because it’s true. Happy for you to show it’s incorrect as you ridiculously claim, you seem unable to?
Over to you.
Mon Feb 10, 2020 2:05 pm
Mon Feb 10, 2020 2:07 pm
BlackMagic wrote:Bluedodo wrote:
Rules ha ha what a numpty.
I called you out on your claim.
You can't back up your claim.
I'm done Roathie you'll reply with your usual twisted B.S.
But know this if I'm going to claim something i always back it up.
Mon Feb 10, 2020 7:56 pm
Mon Feb 10, 2020 7:58 pm
Mon Feb 10, 2020 8:04 pm
Mon Feb 10, 2020 9:21 pm
Tue Feb 11, 2020 9:21 am
Bluebirdbaz1 wrote:Bluedodo wrote:
Rules ha ha what a numpty.
I called you out on your claim.
You can't back up your claim.
I'm done Roathie you'll reply with your usual twisted B.S.
But know this if I'm going to claim something i always back it up.
Yes rules. If someone accuses me of being a thief, they must prove that or I am perfectly entitled to deny it. The burden of proof isn’t on me, it’s on the initial claim. If you then join in that debate and take the side of the initial claim - you still have that burden of proof, those rules of discourse get transferred to you.
Now by all means feel free to back up the ridiculous claim you made that I called you out on, but something tells me you are completely unable to show the majority of the support for Wales comes from Cardiff supporters. You said you back every claim you make so let’s see. Over to you.![]()
(All copied ready to re-post).
Tue Feb 11, 2020 9:27 am
Tue Feb 11, 2020 9:31 am
Igovernor wrote:Talking to himself now
Tue Feb 11, 2020 9:56 am
Bluedodo wrote:
Ha ha ha you'd already replied to this yesterday you numpty, you can't even keep up with your own. Posts.
Tue Feb 11, 2020 10:00 am
Bluedodo wrote:Igovernor wrote:Talking to himself now
Crazy isnt he.
I msy even ask him to quote where i said Cardiff provide the majority of Welsh support.
If he's as clever as he says he can quote me word for word on it surely.
Tue Feb 11, 2020 10:00 am
wez1927 wrote:Roathy is taking a right battering on this
Tue Feb 11, 2020 10:01 am
Bluedodo wrote:
Rules ha ha what a numpty.
I called you out on your claim.
You can't back up your claim.
I'm done Roathie you'll reply with your usual twisted B.S.
But know this if I'm going to claim something i always back it up.
Tue Feb 11, 2020 10:14 am
davidsimmo wrote:Bluedodo wrote:Igovernor wrote:Talking to himself now
Crazy isnt he.
I msy even ask him to quote where i said Cardiff provide the majority of Welsh support.
If he's as clever as he says he can quote me word for word on it surely.
The conversation you joined was who has the bigger following of Wales. Cardiff City FC, Swansea City FC or Mid and North Wales combined.
So I ask again, if you don’t agree with me and you don’t agree with the original claim regarding Cardiff. That only leaves Swansea. So are you saying that you think the largest following of Wales comes from Swansea City FC?
Tue Feb 11, 2020 10:32 am
Bluedodo wrote:
Heres the deal :
1. You can't quote me saying Cardiff provide the majority despite saying you could.
2. You cant provide a shred of evidence to back up your ridiculous claim about Mid and North Wales.
3. Your now replying to posts you've already replied to.
Game over Roathie enjoy chatting to yourself.
Tue Feb 11, 2020 11:15 am
Haraldfromnorway wrote:Bluedodo wrote:
Heres the deal :
1. You can't quote me saying Cardiff provide the majority despite saying you could.
2. You cant provide a shred of evidence to back up your ridiculous claim about Mid and North Wales.
3. Your now replying to posts you've already replied to.
Game over Roathie enjoy chatting to yourself.
No, that is not the deal.
1. You entered a debate where the claim was Cardiff City have the biggest contingency of Wales fans as a group. I disagreed and gave my valid and fair reasons.
2. You claimed ridiculously to disagree with my post disagreeing. You have not been able to prove this claim as of yet, but still waiting.
3. I am indeed, thats because they are so cutting and telling that people feel the need to get rid of them. But that is always a victory for me. Whenever someone feels their only option in a debate is to silence the other side that is being perfectly respectful and reasonable then who has the upper hand is obvious.
I am not chatting to myself, I am chatting to you
Tue Feb 11, 2020 11:27 am
splottthedog wrote:
I dont think calling people "thick" is respectful by anyone's standards...but im sure there's a reason why you felt the need to
Tue Feb 11, 2020 11:43 am
Haraldfromnorway wrote:splottthedog wrote:
I dont think calling people "thick" is respectful by anyone's standards...but im sure there's a reason why you felt the need to
Calling someone thick? Seems you may have misread one of my posts?
I said I DON'T believe someone is that thick, did I not?
Tue Feb 11, 2020 11:58 am
Haraldfromnorway wrote:splottthedog wrote:
oh dear, my apologies. in that case the implication is ENTIRELY different
Indeed it is, it means I do not believe he is that thick - implying that he must only be saying that due to some form of argumentative predisposition. That is not rude in the slightest.
But the apology is accepted of course.
Tue Feb 11, 2020 3:45 pm