Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Should we hang on to Whitts?

You may select 1 option

 
 
View results

Re: The great Peter Whittingham debate!

Fri Jan 06, 2017 1:53 pm

polo wrote:
wez1927 wrote:
polo wrote:
wez1927 wrote:
polo wrote:
wez1927 wrote:
polo wrote:Lex Immers let go for free 6 months after arriving, another in a long list of signings that weve just thrown money down the drain on and people complain Peter Whittinghams wages are a waste of money. :roll:

Wheres has anyone said his wages are a waste ? People have been commenting on he should be on lower in his new contract just like the rest of the players should be ,we got far too many players on premiership contracts when we are a championship club


Tony has said, several times, and stop talking nonsense Wez. I wouldnt say 20k a week could be classed as a Premiership contract anymore.

It certainly not an average championship contract remember what position we are in 20k a week is too much for Whitts in his new contract


Yes he may have to come down from 20k although to ask him to take 5k a week plus incentives if he "proves himself" is a f*cking insult!!!!

I wouldnt expect the club to be so insulting to a club legend.

5k is a bit low but I do think 10 k a week plus bonuses is fair


Appearence bonus maybe but to put an "Assist" bonus is absurd IMO.



I think somones getting carried away with football manager lol

Re: The great Peter Whittingham debate!

Sun Jan 08, 2017 1:23 pm

After watching this shite I suggest we get PW7 signed up ASAP.

We haven't got one other midfielder who can pass them ball 10 f*cking yards!!!

Re: The great Peter Whittingham debate!

Sun Jan 08, 2017 1:34 pm

polo wrote:After watching this shite I suggest we get PW7 signed up ASAP.

We haven't got one other midfielder who can pass them ball 10 f*cking yards!!!


I disagree.
Ralls passed a few today.
Trouble was they went to a white shirt or a 30 metre pass for Lambert to chase and use his electric pace.

Re: The great Peter Whittingham debate!

Sun Jan 08, 2017 1:38 pm

polo wrote:After watching this shite I suggest we get PW7 signed up ASAP.

We haven't got one other midfielder who can pass them ball 10 f*cking yards!!!


And showed how vital to have a battler like Gunnarson.

Re: The great Peter Whittingham debate!

Sun Jan 08, 2017 1:44 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:
polo wrote:After watching this shite I suggest we get PW7 signed up ASAP.

We haven't got one other midfielder who can pass them ball 10 f*cking yards!!!


And showed how vital to have a battler like Gunnarson.


True, Gunnarsson would have made a huge difference today. He's vital to us.

Re: The great Peter Whittingham debate!

Sun Jan 08, 2017 2:05 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:
polo wrote:After watching this shite I suggest we get PW7 signed up ASAP.

We haven't got one other midfielder who can pass them ball 10 f*cking yards!!!


And showed how vital to have a battler like Gunnarson.


I thought Ralls battled well tbh but NONE of the midfielders can pass the ball. Ralls, whi I thought was the best of a bad bunch in midfield, broke between the lines 2nd half but then just passed the ball straight to their full back when trying to play a simple 5 yard pass to Harris. Pilkington the same. Useless.

Re: The great Peter Whittingham debate!

Sun Jan 08, 2017 2:12 pm

polo wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:
polo wrote:After watching this shite I suggest we get PW7 signed up ASAP.

We haven't got one other midfielder who can pass them ball 10 f*cking yards!!!


And showed how vital to have a battler like Gunnarson.


I thought Ralls battled well tbh but NONE of the midfielders can pass the ball. Ralls, whi I thought was the best of a bad bunch in midfield, broke between the lines 2nd half but then just passed the ball straight to their full back when trying to play a simple 5 yard pass to Harris. Pilkington the same. Useless.


Ralls did get into some tackles when no one else didn't and Pilkington wouldn't care if he left tomorrow and Harris needs to work on his end product because he just runs into his full back.

Re: The great Peter Whittingham debate!

Sun Jan 08, 2017 2:13 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:
polo wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:
polo wrote:After watching this shite I suggest we get PW7 signed up ASAP.

We haven't got one other midfielder who can pass them ball 10 f*cking yards!!!


And showed how vital to have a battler like Gunnarson.


I thought Ralls battled well tbh but NONE of the midfielders can pass the ball. Ralls, whi I thought was the best of a bad bunch in midfield, broke between the lines 2nd half but then just passed the ball straight to their full back when trying to play a simple 5 yard pass to Harris. Pilkington the same. Useless.


Ralls did get into some tackles when no one else didn't and Pilkington wouldn't care if he left tomorrow and Harris needs to work on his end product because he just runs into his full back.


If Kadeem Harris is a champiobnship level footballer then my name is Russell Slade. Crap.

Re: The great Peter Whittingham debate!

Sun Jan 08, 2017 2:22 pm

polo wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:
polo wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:
polo wrote:After watching this shite I suggest we get PW7 signed up ASAP.

We haven't got one other midfielder who can pass them ball 10 f*cking yards!!!


And showed how vital to have a battler like Gunnarson.


I thought Ralls battled well tbh but NONE of the midfielders can pass the ball. Ralls, whi I thought was the best of a bad bunch in midfield, broke between the lines 2nd half but then just passed the ball straight to their full back when trying to play a simple 5 yard pass to Harris. Pilkington the same. Useless.


Ralls did get into some tackles when no one else didn't and Pilkington wouldn't care if he left tomorrow and Harris needs to work on his end product because he just runs into his full back.


If Kadeem Harris is a champiobnship level footballer then my name is Russell Slade. Crap.


Harris did try to to get some crosses in but need to work on end product but hes a useful player to have with his pace maybe he's just an impact player.

Re: The great Peter Whittingham debate!

Sun Jan 08, 2017 2:24 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:
polo wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:
polo wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:
polo wrote:After watching this shite I suggest we get PW7 signed up ASAP.

We haven't got one other midfielder who can pass them ball 10 f*cking yards!!!


And showed how vital to have a battler like Gunnarson.


I thought Ralls battled well tbh but NONE of the midfielders can pass the ball. Ralls, whi I thought was the best of a bad bunch in midfield, broke between the lines 2nd half but then just passed the ball straight to their full back when trying to play a simple 5 yard pass to Harris. Pilkington the same. Useless.


Ralls did get into some tackles when no one else didn't and Pilkington wouldn't care if he left tomorrow and Harris needs to work on his end product because he just runs into his full back.


If Kadeem Harris is a champiobnship level footballer then my name is Russell Slade. Crap.


Harris did try to to get some crosses in but need to work on end product but hes a useful player to have with his pace maybe he's just an impact player.


Usain Bolt has pace. Sign him up.

Harris does not look to me like he understands the game at all and hes not exactly a kid. We havent got time to waste teaching him the basics.

Re: The great Peter Whittingham debate!

Sun Jan 08, 2017 2:30 pm

Give him a pay rise !!!!

We have no transition from defense to attack without him, Yes Gunnarson at the moment is very important as the stopper, but to be a team in the top 6 we'll need to own the ball and this emphasizes Gunnars deficiencies.

Can some of you non believers actually see what he does now ?

The ball is not toxic, they are paid a fortune to be able to control it, but at the moment we kick it as high and far as possible.

Re: The great Peter Whittingham debate!

Sun Jan 08, 2017 2:35 pm

Harris after 33 league games has 1 goal and has 1 assist, both in the league cup 2 seasons ago.

League 1 player at best