A SIMPLE YES OR NO

No way, people keep on saying we werent in the bottom three when malky was here, but im sure we would have been with the first four games ole had after malky had gone , once your in that bottom three its hard to get out of it who ever the manager

Would we have got only one point from Sunderland home, Arsenal away, West Ham home........?

and Hull and Palace...

The man relegated Wigan and people still sport him. Deluded or what?

The man relegated Wigan and people still sport him. Deluded or what?

This board loves and idolises Malky. No surprise that UKIP is the party that most members on the board voted for!

He relegated Wigan even with decent players at his disposal, he is a FRAUD. His next job will be in the SPL

No

Absolutely no. Especially with what I heard last week about how much he made from the Cornelius debacle.

That is one of the reasons why I say No. The real scandal of MM's management has never really been revealed but the Cornelius transfer gives us a massive clue.

Another being the ultra defensive tactics even in games where we should have had a chance of gaining something (C Palace away being an example).

100% Yes!

defo not we played some awful football under him, Norwich and palace I remember we made them look
like barca. he had plenty of time to turn wigan around??

From FB

Annis Abrahamii YES
Like · Reply · 16 mins

Richard Kingdon NO
Like · Reply · 15 mins

Steve Ccfc Scaccia YES
Like · Reply · 14 mins

Ferret Angel Thats a yes from me
Like · Reply · 13 mins

Richard Lewis Debatable but I'd say no.
Like · Reply · 1 · 11 mins

Carl Douglas Newman Yes
Like · Reply · 7 mins

We will never know the answer to this question !


In my opinion Tan made a simple choice of removing a manager who at the very least had kept us largely outside of the bottom three or losing face himself if Mackay continued in the role !

Tan chose himself above the potential PL future of CCFC .... for that reason I will never trust him !

We will never know the answer to this question !


In my opinion Tan made a simple choice of removing a manager who at the very least had kept us largely outside of the bottom three or losing face himself if Mackay continued in the role !

Tan chose himself above the potential PL future of CCFC .... for that reason I will never trust him !

He got rid of a racist, good for him.

we finished on 30 points from 38 games, we would have needed (with our goal difference) 37 to stay up.
I say with malky ---
SUNDERLAND home 2-0 with 7 mins to play, Malky`s team would have held on for the 3 points (Finished 2-2)
HULL home lost 4-0 -shocking defending ------under Malky a dour 0-0 but a point gained
PALACE home lost 3-0 ground out a draw at least a point gained

Everton away ? last minute miscued goal ? Point lost

Gone into the last 2 aways SUNDERLAND - a six pointer and we lost 4-0. a dour draw, a la Norwich away, a la Stoke away would have put us on the brink of safety.
Newcastle away with all the talk of disgruntled Geordies walking out cos of the poor form / losing run- we could have got something.

Malky found Fraser Campbell in the january window, who knows with a little backing , another gem could have been found.


i say YES.

Not a chance

we finished on 30 points from 38 games, we would have needed (with our goal difference) 37 to stay up.
I say with malky ---
SUNDERLAND home 2-0 with 7 mins to play, Malky`s team would have held on for the 3 points (Finished 2-2)
HULL home lost 4-0 -shocking defending ------under Malky a dour 0-0 but a point gained
PALACE home lost 3-0 ground out a draw at least a point gained

Everton away ? last minute miscued goal ? Point lost

Gone into the last 2 aways SUNDERLAND - a six pointer and we lost 4-0. a dour draw, a la Norwich away, a la Stoke away would have put us on the brink of safety.
Newcastle away with all the talk of disgruntled Geordies walking out cos of the poor form / losing run- we could have got something.

Malky found Fraser Campbell in the january window, who knows with a little backing , another gem could have been found.

Everton were chasing a Champions League spot at the time, our away form was poor under Malky, do you remember the shambolic performance away at Palace? Sunderland we would have got nothing from.

'With a little backing' lmao he had £50m in the summer, not to mention the Championship squad had high wages, £30m in wages I think it was? He had the backing, he didn't use it

i say YES.

Yes

You are gonna need Apollo on this

we finished on 30 points from 38 games, we would have needed (with our goal difference) 37 to stay up.
I say with malky ---
SUNDERLAND home 2-0 with 7 mins to play, Malky`s team would have held on for the 3 points (Finished 2-2)
HULL home lost 4-0 -shocking defending ------under Malky a dour 0-0 but a point gained
PALACE home lost 3-0 ground out a draw at least a point gained

Everton away ? last minute miscued goal ? Point lost

Gone into the last 2 aways SUNDERLAND - a six pointer and we lost 4-0. a dour draw, a la Norwich away, a la Stoke away would have put us on the brink of safety.
Newcastle away with all the talk of disgruntled Geordies walking out cos of the poor form / losing run- we could have got something.

Malky found Fraser Campbell in the january window, who knows with a little backing , another gem could have been found.


i say YES.

Excellent argument put forward.
Those against Malky just keep repeating...Wigan, Racist, Cornelius blah blah blah.
I often wonder if the anti Malky people sang, danced and ran on the pitch the night we played Charlton to go up ? Of course they did.

We will never know about the season before...but based on that season ( IMO ) = YES .

we finished on 30 points from 38 games, we would have needed (with our goal difference) 37 to stay up.
I say with malky ---
SUNDERLAND home 2-0 with 7 mins to play, Malky`s team would have held on for the 3 points (Finished 2-2)
HULL home lost 4-0 -shocking defending ------under Malky a dour 0-0 but a point gained
PALACE home lost 3-0 ground out a draw at least a point gained

Everton away ? last minute miscued goal ? Point lost

Gone into the last 2 aways SUNDERLAND - a six pointer and we lost 4-0. a dour draw, a la Norwich away, a la Stoke away would have put us on the brink of safety.
Newcastle away with all the talk of disgruntled Geordies walking out cos of the poor form / losing run- we could have got something.

Malky found Fraser Campbell in the january window, who knows with a little backing , another gem could have been found.


i say YES.

Excellent argument put forward.
Those against Malky just keep repeating...Wigan, Racist, Cornelius blah blah blah.
I often wonder if the anti Malky people sang, danced and ran on the pitch the night we played Charlton to go up ? Of course they did.

Roberto Martinez won the FA Cup for Wigan, does that negate his role in them being relegated?