' Cardiff City want £15 Million '

Ummm no it's not

Yep, it is

How much you reckon he is worth now then after banging in 20 plus goals? The same?

No not the same but no where near 25million+

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

Who gives a shit what you think you sad little man ,spending all day on a rivals message board claiming to be in oz what a f*cking mug you are

Hi again chubs. many many people care what i think, thanks for asking

Are you suggesting im not in Australia wesley?

Oh dear you have had a mare

Hi again chubs. many many people care what i think, thanks for asking

Are you suggesting im not in Australia wesley?

Oh dear you have had a mare

Keep telling yourself that you sad little man ,why don't you f**k off on your dirty Jack websites instead of sprouting your Bullshit on here ,go get a life

Hi again chubs. many many people care what i think, thanks for asking

Are you suggesting im not in Australia wesley?

Oh dear you have had a mare

Keep telling yourself that you sad little man ,why don't you f**k off on your dirty Jack websites instead of sprouting your Bullshit on here ,go get a life

So no committing to the Australia thing.. I will assume you have then backed out of the accusation and indeed apologise. Apology acceoted

Nearly made yourself look a major plum there Chubs

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

I never said we'd get 15 million for Marshall. That's the point in pricing him at 15 million we don't want to sell.

A striker does not go up 12.5 million in price because he had four good months

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

I never said we'd get 15 million for Marshall. That's the point in pricing him at 15 million we don't want to sell.

A striker does not go up 12.5 million in price because he had four good months

He has had a good career not just 5 months. However in the last 5 months he was the best striker in the league. Better than Aguero, Van Persie, Rooney, Dzeko, Suarez

His value would have increased 100% that much is absolutely obvious.

Im glad you agrew with Marshall

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

I never said we'd get 15 million for Marshall. That's the point in pricing him at 15 million we don't want to sell.

A striker does not go up 12.5 million in price because he had four good months

He has had a good career not just 5 months. However in the last 5 months he was the best striker in the league. Better than Aguero, Van Persie, Rooney, Dzeko, Suarez

His value would have increased 100% that much is absolutely obvious.

Im glad you agrew with Marshall

With a post like that I know your on drugs lol

I think Swansea can expect anywhere from £20m-£25m - I don't think anyone would pay anymore than that.

If Chelsea came in for him, alongside Costa, with Fabregas behind - Wow.

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

I never said we'd get 15 million for Marshall. That's the point in pricing him at 15 million we don't want to sell.

A striker does not go up 12.5 million in price because he had four good months

He has had a good career not just 5 months. However in the last 5 months he was the best striker in the league. Better than Aguero, Van Persie, Rooney, Dzeko, Suarez

His value would have increased 100% that much is absolutely obvious.

Im glad you agrew with Marshall

With a post like that I know your on drugs lol

Quality post as always Chubs

The post was fact. You are by all means welcome to offer a £50 donation to Ty Hafan should Swansea not recieve at least a £25 offer for him. Put your money where your mouth is, just dont eat it my mistake

I think Swansea can expect anywhere from £20m-£25m - I don't think anyone would pay anymore than that.

If Chelsea came in for him, alongside Costa, with Fabregas behind - Wow.

I agree. I think we would probably get a squeak more though. I think bidding would get to £25 with relative ease, we would probably hold out for more like £28m. He is one of the best strikers in Europe and scoring a shed full in the premier league, to suggest he isnt worth that figure considering he was worth £12.5m completely untested shows a completed lack of understanding of our beautiful game and the values put on young prolific goalscorers.

I think Swansea can expect anywhere from £20m-£25m - I don't think anyone would pay anymore than that.

If Chelsea came in for him, alongside Costa, with Fabregas behind - Wow.

I agree. I think we would probably get a squeak more though. I think bidding would get to £25 with relative ease, we would probably hold out for more like £28m. He is one of the best strikers in Europe and scoring a shed full in the premier league, to suggest he isnt worth that figure considering he was worth £12.5m completely untested shows a completed lack of understanding of our beautiful game and the values put on young prolific goalscorers.

He's a top player, and will be at a big club very soon - if not this season, then for sure next season. He's another Drogba to me - he seems to fit the mould of a Jose Mourinho player. But thats just imo

He's a top player, who can perform at the highest level, the Jacks have a gem here,

wasn't he your all time record signing?

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

I never said we'd get 15 million for Marshall. That's the point in pricing him at 15 million we don't want to sell.

A striker does not go up 12.5 million in price because he had four good months

He has had a good career not just 5 months. However in the last 5 months he was the best striker in the league. Better than Aguero, Van Persie, Rooney, Dzeko, Suarez

His value would have increased 100% that much is absolutely obvious.

Im glad you agrew with Marshall

With a post like that I know your on drugs lol

Quality post as always Chubs

The post was fact. You are by all means welcome to offer a £50 donation to Ty Hafan should Swansea not recieve at least a £25 offer for him. Put your money where your mouth is, just dont eat it my mistake

It's not a fact it's your opinion

I think Swansea can expect anywhere from £20m-£25m - I don't think anyone would pay anymore than that.

If Chelsea came in for him, alongside Costa, with Fabregas behind - Wow.

I agree. I think we would probably get a squeak more though. I think bidding would get to £25 with relative ease, we would probably hold out for more like £28m. He is one of the best strikers in Europe and scoring a shed full in the premier league, to suggest he isnt worth that figure considering he was worth £12.5m completely untested shows a completed lack of understanding of our beautiful game and the values put on young prolific goalscorers.

He's a top player, and will be at a big club very soon - if not this season, then for sure next season. He's another Drogba to me - he seems to fit the mould of a Jose Mourinho player. But thats just imo

He's a top player, who can perform at the highest level, the Jacks have a gem here,

wasn't he your all time record signing?

Chelsea wont buy him this season if they are already buying Costa. To be honest I would rather Bony as he would be cheaper and has shown he can score in this league, even though it did take him half a season to get into it.

I think Swansea can expect anywhere from £20m-£25m - I don't think anyone would pay anymore than that.

If Chelsea came in for him, alongside Costa, with Fabregas behind - Wow.

I agree. I think we would probably get a squeak more though. I think bidding would get to £25 with relative ease, we would probably hold out for more like £28m. He is one of the best strikers in Europe and scoring a shed full in the premier league, to suggest he isnt worth that figure considering he was worth £12.5m completely untested shows a completed lack of understanding of our beautiful game and the values put on young prolific goalscorers.

He's a top player, and will be at a big club very soon - if not this season, then for sure next season. He's another Drogba to me - he seems to fit the mould of a Jose Mourinho player. But thats just imo

He's a top player, who can perform at the highest level, the Jacks have a gem here,

wasn't he your all time record signing?

Chelsea wont buy him this season if they are already buying Costa. To be honest I would rather Bony as he would be cheaper and has shown he can score in this league, even though it did take him half a season to get into it.

They badly need fire power up front though.

How torres is still at the club is beyond me..... And how he got to the world cup - unbelievable

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

I never said we'd get 15 million for Marshall. That's the point in pricing him at 15 million we don't want to sell.

A striker does not go up 12.5 million in price because he had four good months

He has had a good career not just 5 months. However in the last 5 months he was the best striker in the league. Better than Aguero, Van Persie, Rooney, Dzeko, Suarez

His value would have increased 100% that much is absolutely obvious.

Im glad you agrew with Marshall

With a post like that I know your on drugs lol

Quality post as always Chubs

The post was fact. You are by all means welcome to offer a £50 donation to Ty Hafan should Swansea not recieve at least a £25 offer for him. Put your money where your mouth is, just dont eat it my mistake

It's not a fact it's your opinion

but roathy thinks that anything he makes up is fact the guy is a clown

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

I never said we'd get 15 million for Marshall. That's the point in pricing him at 15 million we don't want to sell.

A striker does not go up 12.5 million in price because he had four good months

He has had a good career not just 5 months. However in the last 5 months he was the best striker in the league. Better than Aguero, Van Persie, Rooney, Dzeko, Suarez

His value would have increased 100% that much is absolutely obvious.

Im glad you agrew with Marshall

With a post like that I know your on drugs lol

Quality post as always Chubs

The post was fact. You are by all means welcome to offer a £50 donation to Ty Hafan should Swansea not recieve at least a £25 offer for him. Put your money where your mouth is, just dont eat it my mistake

It's not a fact it's your opinion

Nope he DID outscore Rooney, Aguero, Suarez, Sturridge, Dzeko and Van persie from Xmas on . Fact

I think Swansea can expect anywhere from £20m-£25m - I don't think anyone would pay anymore than that.

If Chelsea came in for him, alongside Costa, with Fabregas behind - Wow.

I agree. I think we would probably get a squeak more though. I think bidding would get to £25 with relative ease, we would probably hold out for more like £28m. He is one of the best strikers in Europe and scoring a shed full in the premier league, to suggest he isnt worth that figure considering he was worth £12.5m completely untested shows a completed lack of understanding of our beautiful game and the values put on young prolific goalscorers.

He's a top player, and will be at a big club very soon - if not this season, then for sure next season. He's another Drogba to me - he seems to fit the mould of a Jose Mourinho player. But thats just imo

He's a top player, who can perform at the highest level, the Jacks have a gem here,

wasn't he your all time record signing?

Chelsea wont buy him this season if they are already buying Costa. To be honest I would rather Bony as he would be cheaper and has shown he can score in this league, even though it did take him half a season to get into it.

They badly need fire power up front though.

How torres is still at the club is beyond me..... And how he got to the world cup - unbelievable

Because they spent £50 million on him and they know they wont get anywhere near that now. I still think he will go to Athletico as part of the deal but probably not now they have got rid of Eto. They have a good striker in Demba Ba but Mourinho seems not to want to play him.

I agree on how he got to the world cup over Negredo is simply amazing

I think Swansea can expect anywhere from £20m-£25m - I don't think anyone would pay anymore than that.

If Chelsea came in for him, alongside Costa, with Fabregas behind - Wow.

I agree. I think we would probably get a squeak more though. I think bidding would get to £25 with relative ease, we would probably hold out for more like £28m. He is one of the best strikers in Europe and scoring a shed full in the premier league, to suggest he isnt worth that figure considering he was worth £12.5m completely untested shows a completed lack of understanding of our beautiful game and the values put on young prolific goalscorers.

He's a top player, and will be at a big club very soon - if not this season, then for sure next season. He's another Drogba to me - he seems to fit the mould of a Jose Mourinho player. But thats just imo

He's a top player, who can perform at the highest level, the Jacks have a gem here,

wasn't he your all time record signing?

Yep £12.5m. He certainly is Drogba mark 2. Very similar records so far in their careers like for like, in fact Bony has had a better debut Premier League season.

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

I never said we'd get 15 million for Marshall. That's the point in pricing him at 15 million we don't want to sell.

A striker does not go up 12.5 million in price because he had four good months

He has had a good career not just 5 months. However in the last 5 months he was the best striker in the league. Better than Aguero, Van Persie, Rooney, Dzeko, Suarez

His value would have increased 100% that much is absolutely obvious.

Im glad you agrew with Marshall

With a post like that I know your on drugs lol

Quality post as always Chubs

The post was fact. You are by all means welcome to offer a £50 donation to Ty Hafan should Swansea not recieve at least a £25 offer for him. Put your money where your mouth is, just dont eat it my mistake

It's not a fact it's your opinion

Nope he DID outscore Rooney, Aguero, Suarez, Sturridge, Dzeko and Van persie from Xmas on . Fact

The part about being the best striker in the league was a whopper

I think Swansea can expect anywhere from £20m-£25m - I don't think anyone would pay anymore than that.

If Chelsea came in for him, alongside Costa, with Fabregas behind - Wow.

I agree. I think we would probably get a squeak more though. I think bidding would get to £25 with relative ease, we would probably hold out for more like £28m. He is one of the best strikers in Europe and scoring a shed full in the premier league, to suggest he isnt worth that figure considering he was worth £12.5m completely untested shows a completed lack of understanding of our beautiful game and the values put on young prolific goalscorers.

He's a top player, and will be at a big club very soon - if not this season, then for sure next season. He's another Drogba to me - he seems to fit the mould of a Jose Mourinho player. But thats just imo

He's a top player, who can perform at the highest level, the Jacks have a gem here,

wasn't he your all time record signing?

Yep £12.5m. He certainly is Drogba mark 2. Very similar records so far in their careers like for like, in fact Bony has had a better debut Premier League season.

and they paid £20m for Drogba... how many years ago?

Prices have inflated massively since then - I'de still say between 20-25 though. Which you should still be pleased with.

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

I never said we'd get 15 million for Marshall. That's the point in pricing him at 15 million we don't want to sell.

A striker does not go up 12.5 million in price because he had four good months

He has had a good career not just 5 months. However in the last 5 months he was the best striker in the league. Better than Aguero, Van Persie, Rooney, Dzeko, Suarez

His value would have increased 100% that much is absolutely obvious.

Im glad you agrew with Marshall

With a post like that I know your on drugs lol

Quality post as always Chubs

The post was fact. You are by all means welcome to offer a £50 donation to Ty Hafan should Swansea not recieve at least a £25 offer for him. Put your money where your mouth is, just dont eat it my mistake

It's not a fact it's your opinion

Nope he DID outscore Rooney, Aguero, Suarez, Sturridge, Dzeko and Van persie from Xmas on . Fact

The part about being the best striker in the league was a whopper

If he scores the most then he is the best striker you whopper

Since Xmas he was the best striker in the league, fact - whopper

Last edited by RoathMagic on Sat Jun 21, 2014 4:24 pm, edited 1 time in total.

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

I never said we'd get 15 million for Marshall. That's the point in pricing him at 15 million we don't want to sell.

A striker does not go up 12.5 million in price because he had four good months

He has had a good career not just 5 months. However in the last 5 months he was the best striker in the league. Better than Aguero, Van Persie, Rooney, Dzeko, Suarez

His value would have increased 100% that much is absolutely obvious.

Im glad you agrew with Marshall

With a post like that I know your on drugs lol

Quality post as always Chubs

The post was fact. You are by all means welcome to offer a £50 donation to Ty Hafan should Swansea not recieve at least a £25 offer for him. Put your money where your mouth is, just dont eat it my mistake

It's not a fact it's your opinion

Nope he DID outscore Rooney, Aguero, Suarez, Sturridge, Dzeko and Van persie from Xmas on . Fact

The part about being the best striker in the league was a whopper

Statistically he was - I think the best striker in the PL is v. Persie though - model striker. (IMO)

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

Who gives a shit what you think you sad little man ,spending all day on a rivals message board claiming to be in oz what a f*cking mug you are

roathy how the fck can you garauntee some one will offer 25 mil? (again saying something that cannot be proved) bit of a habit that? and charity bet again? like a record thats got big crack in it and needle doesnt move! same man that knows how much profit a club will have in ten years time! and swans will be above city for next 30yrs! but unfortunately doesnt know lotto winning numbers? full of bull ++++ springs to mind!

No not the same but no where near 25million+

Then you are deluded.

We signed him for £12.5m. 100% increase on someone who was unproven in the Premier League and then became one of the hottest goal scorers around is not excessive in the slightest. Its like a £3m striker being worth £6m after taking the league by storm.

I can guarantee you that if a bid comes in it will be in that region, can you say the same regarding marshall? In fact i will say that you will never ever get a £15m bid for him and would happily donate £50 to charity if proved wrong, would you be as confident with regards to Bony at atleast £25m?

If you are honest then you wouldn't be confident in your convictions at all as we both know strikers of that ilk regularly go for such money.

Who gives a shit what you think you sad little man ,spending all day on a rivals message board claiming to be in oz what a f*cking mug you are

roathy how the fck can you garauntee some one will offer 25 mil? (again saying something that cannot be proved) bit of a habit that? and charity bet again? like a record thats got big crack in it and needle doesnt move! same man that knows how much profit a club will have in ten years time! and swans will be above city for next 30yrs! but unfortunately doesnt know lotto winning numbers? full of bull ++++ springs to mind!

1) i dont know, its just common sense though. He wont be with is long. Why? Because he is class. If he leaves someone would have had to have bid. If someone bids then they usually end up bidding what he is worth - he is worth £25m plus quite clearly. Simple really

2) where did i say i knew how much profit a club would make in 10 years? Im sure we both know i said "if swansea make a £30m profit a year for £10 years then that will be x amount of profit" its a fairly simple concept Al

3) i didnt say swansea will be above cardiff for the years. I said, in a thread asking when they think cardiff will finish above swansea next. In my opinion it was not for a decade or two.

Now im all for roathie bashing Al, in fact its quite flattering. But lets make it accurate next time son

At the end of it all Marshall is contracted to us. He is our player and we can value him at whatever we want. I believe we don't want to sell him and he is happy here. So if someone wants him then they pay what we want. If they don't he stays with us. So valuing him at 15 Mill just says he is staying unless you pay silly money. End of this story really