Who is to blame if we go down? (Poll)

Annis you gonna answer the point you think we only have 6 premierships players then whos fault is that?

Or are you just going to ignore it because you know the answer is Malky?

It takes 2 seasons to get a full Premier League squad, Malky would of strengthened in Jan and I honestly believe we would f stayed up, I really do

The pundits on match of the day more or less said exactly the same. Thats all Tan had to do was control his ego and give Malky enough for one or two players to strengthen the squad and that would have been enough for survival. If he really wanted Malky out then he could have waited till the end of the season.

As a show of defiance to Tan.

Caught in the moment.

Almost as ridiculous as you claiming yesterdays first half v Palace was "one of the best in decades".

Dont resort to lying just because your post was stupid

If you are going to make up quotes you may as well go nuts as I told you

I think the only liar here is you.

Nothing made up by me at all.

Page 7 of this thread

viewtopic.php?f=2&t=137489&start=180

The following quote by you

That was one of the best 45 minutes ive seen from Swansea in decades and we have been excellent an awful lot of the time

As you were Pinnochio

thats not what you said at all though brains.

You said that I said "best halfs of football in decades" .... Which clearly is not what I said now is it

Considering we have been in the lower leagues for the majority of the last 2 decades do you not think that it may just be accurate?

Find another Swansea City first half display that marks 83% possession, 400% more shots and 100% more goals.

(You cant can you) case closed and apology accepted Polo

Last edited by Roath_Magic_ on Mon Mar 03, 2014 2:13 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Annis you gonna answer the point you think we only have 6 premierships players then whos fault is that?

Or are you just going to ignore it because you know the answer is Malky?

It takes 2 seasons to get a full Premier League squad, Malky would of strengthened in Jan and I honestly believe we would f stayed up, I really do

So what in the mean time we play six a side?

Get real. Hull spent half of what Malky did and spent it far more wisely, improving all areas of their team / squad.

2.5m on Curtis Davies or 9m on Caulker?
5m on Tom Huddlestone or 13m on Gary Medle?
Figueroa on a free or KTC and Brahyford for a combined 4m?
13m for Jelavic and Long or 11m for Cornelius and Odemwingie?

If DJ wasted what Malky did in the summer youd be calling for his head on a stick outside the Ninian.

You were always quick to point out how much Jones had to spend compared to Malky before Tan gave Malky an open cheque book last 2 years.

50m and weve ended up with a squad not that much better than the one Jones had in 2010/11.

Annis you gonna answer the point you think we only have 6 premierships players then whos fault is that?

Or are you just going to ignore it because you know the answer is Malky?

It takes 2 seasons to get a full Premier League squad, Malky would of strengthened in Jan and I honestly believe we would f stayed up, I really do

So what in the mean time we play six a side?

Get real. Hull spent half of what Malky did and spent it far more wisely, improving all areas of their team / squad.

2.5m on Curtis Davies or 9m on Caulker?
5m on Tom Huddlestone or 13m on Gary Medle?
Figueroa on a free or KTC and Brahyford for a combined 4m?
13m for Jelavic and Long or 11m for Cornelius and Odemwingie?

If DJ wasted what Malky did in the summer youd be calling for his head on a stick outside the Ninian.

You were always quick to point out how much Jones had to spend compared to Malky before Tan gave Malky an open cheque book last 2 years.

50m and weve ended up with a squad not that much better than the one Jones had in 2010/11.

Polo you were bumming the signing of Medel a few short months ago

Malky? How can people blame him when he got sacked? At least under him we was picking up points.

lets be honest
malky would of been sacked much earlier if the vocal fans had not jumped to support him against tan
imo he should of gone after the stoke game
but tan gave the fans what they were asking for (don't sack McKay)
the only thing tan got wrong was changing our colour and badge and opening his mouth to often and the fans used malky against him his results did not really warrant the support he got
those saying under malky we would have stayed up are still delusional and still using him against tan

Annis you gonna answer the point you think we only have 6 premierships players then whos fault is that?

Or are you just going to ignore it because you know the answer is Malky?

It takes 2 seasons to get a full Premier League squad, Malky would of strengthened in Jan and I honestly believe we would f stayed up, I really do

So what in the mean time we play six a side?

Get real. Hull spent half of what Malky did and spent it far more wisely, improving all areas of their team / squad.

2.5m on Curtis Davies or 9m on Caulker?
5m on Tom Huddlestone or 13m on Gary Medle?
Figueroa on a free or KTC and Brahyford for a combined 4m?
13m for Jelavic and Long or 11m for Cornelius and Odemwingie?

If DJ wasted what Malky did in the summer youd be calling for his head on a stick outside the Ninian.

You were always quick to point out how much Jones had to spend compared to Malky before Tan gave Malky an open cheque book last 2 years.

50m and weve ended up with a squad not that much better than the one Jones had in 2010/11.

Polo, I proved u wrong on Dave Jones, I just wish I could of proved u wrong on Malky.

We both totally beg to differ

Malky? How can people blame him when he got sacked? At least under him we was picking up points.

Spot on

Annis you gonna answer the point you think we only have 6 premierships players then whos fault is that?

Or are you just going to ignore it because you know the answer is Malky?

It takes 2 seasons to get a full Premier League squad, Malky would of strengthened in Jan and I honestly believe we would f stayed up, I really do

So what in the mean time we play six a side?

Get real. Hull spent half of what Malky did and spent it far more wisely, improving all areas of their team / squad.

2.5m on Curtis Davies or 9m on Caulker?
5m on Tom Huddlestone or 13m on Gary Medle?
Figueroa on a free or KTC and Brahyford for a combined 4m?
13m for Jelavic and Long or 11m for Cornelius and Odemwingie?

If DJ wasted what Malky did in the summer youd be calling for his head on a stick outside the Ninian.

You were always quick to point out how much Jones had to spend compared to Malky before Tan gave Malky an open cheque book last 2 years.

50m and weve ended up with a squad not that much better than the one Jones had in 2010/11.

When you put it like that you can see Malkys was clueless when buying players. Well done to Bruce who used the market very well, that's what a manager with prem experience can do for a club.

Annis you gonna answer the point you think we only have 6 premierships players then whos fault is that?

Or are you just going to ignore it because you know the answer is Malky?

It takes 2 seasons to get a full Premier League squad, Malky would of strengthened in Jan and I honestly believe we would f stayed up, I really do

So what in the mean time we play six a side?

Get real. Hull spent half of what Malky did and spent it far more wisely, improving all areas of their team / squad.

2.5m on Curtis Davies or 9m on Caulker?
5m on Tom Huddlestone or 13m on Gary Medle?
Figueroa on a free or KTC and Brahyford for a combined 4m?
13m for Jelavic and Long or 11m for Cornelius and Odemwingie?

If DJ wasted what Malky did in the summer youd be calling for his head on a stick outside the Ninian.

You were always quick to point out how much Jones had to spend compared to Malky before Tan gave Malky an open cheque book last 2 years.

50m and weve ended up with a squad not that much better than the one Jones had in 2010/11.

Polo you were bumming the signing of Medel a few short months ago

Not for 13m I wasnt

Annis you gonna answer the point you think we only have 6 premierships players then whos fault is that?

Or are you just going to ignore it because you know the answer is Malky?

It takes 2 seasons to get a full Premier League squad, Malky would of strengthened in Jan and I honestly believe we would f stayed up, I really do

So what in the mean time we play six a side?

Get real. Hull spent half of what Malky did and spent it far more wisely, improving all areas of their team / squad.

2.5m on Curtis Davies or 9m on Caulker?
5m on Tom Huddlestone or 13m on Gary Medle?
Figueroa on a free or KTC and Brahyford for a combined 4m?
13m for Jelavic and Long or 11m for Cornelius and Odemwingie?

If DJ wasted what Malky did in the summer youd be calling for his head on a stick outside the Ninian.

You were always quick to point out how much Jones had to spend compared to Malky before Tan gave Malky an open cheque book last 2 years.

50m and weve ended up with a squad not that much better than the one Jones had in 2010/11.

When you put it like that you can see Malkys was clueless when buying players. Well done to Bruce who used the market very well, that's what a manager with prem experience can do for a club.

What you are failing to see is Polo was loving these signings at the time, when others were telling him they can get the same or better for cheaper.

Hindsight is 20:20 as they say and Polo is the king of the hypocrite and the king of hypocrisy

Its like saying Kim for £2m when we could have got Michu for £2m. You can do that for everyone in world football. The fact is, when polo was told £12m for Medel and £8m for Cornelius was too much - he was having none of it

Annis you gonna answer the point you think we only have 6 premierships players then whos fault is that?

Or are you just going to ignore it because you know the answer is Malky?

It takes 2 seasons to get a full Premier League squad, Malky would of strengthened in Jan and I honestly believe we would f stayed up, I really do

So what in the mean time we play six a side?

Get real. Hull spent half of what Malky did and spent it far more wisely, improving all areas of their team / squad.

2.5m on Curtis Davies or 9m on Caulker?
5m on Tom Huddlestone or 13m on Gary Medle?
Figueroa on a free or KTC and Brahyford for a combined 4m?
13m for Jelavic and Long or 11m for Cornelius and Odemwingie?

If DJ wasted what Malky did in the summer youd be calling for his head on a stick outside the Ninian.

You were always quick to point out how much Jones had to spend compared to Malky before Tan gave Malky an open cheque book last 2 years.

50m and weve ended up with a squad not that much better than the one Jones had in 2010/11.

Polo, I proved u wrong on Dave Jones, I just wish I could of proved u wrong on Malky.

We both totally beg to differ

I think Steve Bruce and Hull are totally proving you wrong Annis.

Its a shame you are not honest enough to admit Malky wasted the money in the summer.

As I said, if it was DJ who spent what Malky did on such rubbish in the summer you would be starting a "Jones Out". FACT.

Annis you gonna answer the point you think we only have 6 premierships players then whos fault is that?

Or are you just going to ignore it because you know the answer is Malky?

It takes 2 seasons to get a full Premier League squad, Malky would of strengthened in Jan and I honestly believe we would f stayed up, I really do

So what in the mean time we play six a side?

Get real. Hull spent half of what Malky did and spent it far more wisely, improving all areas of their team / squad.

2.5m on Curtis Davies or 9m on Caulker?
5m on Tom Huddlestone or 13m on Gary Medle?
Figueroa on a free or KTC and Brahyford for a combined 4m?
13m for Jelavic and Long or 11m for Cornelius and Odemwingie?

If DJ wasted what Malky did in the summer youd be calling for his head on a stick outside the Ninian.

You were always quick to point out how much Jones had to spend compared to Malky before Tan gave Malky an open cheque book last 2 years.

50m and weve ended up with a squad not that much better than the one Jones had in 2010/11.

When you put it like that you can see Malkys was clueless when buying players. Well done to Bruce who used the market very well, that's what a manager with prem experience can do for a club.

What you are failing to see is Polo was loving these signings at the time, when others were telling him they can get the same or better for cheaper.

Hindsight is 20:20 as they say and Polo is the king of the hypocrite and the king of hypocrisy

Its like saying Kim for £2m when we could have got Michu for £2m. You can do that for everyone in world football. The fact is, when polo was told £12m for Medel and £8m for Cornelius was too much - he was having none of it

King of hypocrisy?

Please find where I said either were value for money.

You cannot

Apology accepted.

Annis you gonna answer the point you think we only have 6 premierships players then whos fault is that?

Or are you just going to ignore it because you know the answer is Malky?

It takes 2 seasons to get a full Premier League squad, Malky would of strengthened in Jan and I honestly believe we would f stayed up, I really do

So what in the mean time we play six a side?

Get real. Hull spent half of what Malky did and spent it far more wisely, improving all areas of their team / squad.

2.5m on Curtis Davies or 9m on Caulker?
5m on Tom Huddlestone or 13m on Gary Medle?
Figueroa on a free or KTC and Brahyford for a combined 4m?
13m for Jelavic and Long or 11m for Cornelius and Odemwingie?

If DJ wasted what Malky did in the summer youd be calling for his head on a stick outside the Ninian.

You were always quick to point out how much Jones had to spend compared to Malky before Tan gave Malky an open cheque book last 2 years.

50m and weve ended up with a squad not that much better than the one Jones had in 2010/11.

When you put it like that you can see Malkys was clueless when buying players. Well done to Bruce who used the market very well, that's what a manager with prem experience can do for a club.

What you are failing to see is Polo was loving these signings at the time, when others were telling him they can get the same or better for cheaper.

Hindsight is 20:20 as they say and Polo is the king of the hypocrite and the king of hypocrisy

Its like saying Kim for £2m when we could have got Michu for £2m. You can do that for everyone in world football. The fact is, when polo was told £12m for Medel and £8m for Cornelius was too much - he was having none of it

Not sure what polo used to say, iv always said the money was not spent wisely. Putting all your eggs into one basket with caulker, Medel and cornelius killed us, with a sprinkle of KTC, odemwingie and Brayford. 2 of those players were successes, albeit expensive successes, I think players with just as much quality could of been found for say 10 mil rather than the 20 those 2 cost. Looks at canas for example, free transfer just as good as Medel if not better.

Annis you gonna answer the point you think we only have 6 premierships players then whos fault is that?

Or are you just going to ignore it because you know the answer is Malky?

It takes 2 seasons to get a full Premier League squad, Malky would of strengthened in Jan and I honestly believe we would f stayed up, I really do

So what in the mean time we play six a side?

Get real. Hull spent half of what Malky did and spent it far more wisely, improving all areas of their team / squad.

2.5m on Curtis Davies or 9m on Caulker?
5m on Tom Huddlestone or 13m on Gary Medle?
Figueroa on a free or KTC and Brahyford for a combined 4m?
13m for Jelavic and Long or 11m for Cornelius and Odemwingie?

If DJ wasted what Malky did in the summer youd be calling for his head on a stick outside the Ninian.

You were always quick to point out how much Jones had to spend compared to Malky before Tan gave Malky an open cheque book last 2 years.

50m and weve ended up with a squad not that much better than the one Jones had in 2010/11.

When you put it like that you can see Malkys was clueless when buying players. Well done to Bruce who used the market very well, that's what a manager with prem experience can do for a club.

What you are failing to see is Polo was loving these signings at the time, when others were telling him they can get the same or better for cheaper.

Hindsight is 20:20 as they say and Polo is the king of the hypocrite and the king of hypocrisy

Its like saying Kim for £2m when we could have got Michu for £2m. You can do that for everyone in world football. The fact is, when polo was told £12m for Medel and £8m for Cornelius was too much - he was having none of it

Not sure what polo used to say, iv always said the money was not spent wisely. Putting all your eggs into one basket with caulker, Medel and cornelius killed us, with a sprinkle of KTC, odemwingie and Brayford. 2 of those players were successes, albeit expensive successes, I think players with just as much quality could of been found for say 10 mil rather than the 20 those 2 cost. Looks at canas for example, free transfer just as good as Medel if not better.

Thats what i told him, even made a thread on it. He wouldnt have it though, he was loving the signing

Links to where I said they were both value for money please, Porkies?

Links to where I said they were both value for money please, Porkies?

You said they were good signings - if their signatures stopped you strengthening elsewhere then they are not good signings are they Colombo

Being good players and good signings are vastly different.

I was telling you at the time the amount spent on those two was insane considering many can do Medels role for free or minimal fees, yet you kept banging on about caps for Chile

He is average, you over paid and hampered strengthening elsewhere, exactly what I told you at the time and exactly what you were arguing with me over. In fact, it was around about that time and around those discussions that you turned from being a bit of a laugh to a bit of a knob and not really looked back since

I will take solace that another Roathie opinion is now validated months after the fact - visionary

Last edited by Roath_Magic_ on Mon Mar 03, 2014 2:44 pm, edited 1 time in total.

We are all average when compared to the NATION OF DOMINATION

The good transfers outweigh the bad of Malky transfers.

We are all average when compared to the NATION OF DOMINATION

ACE OF BASE

The good transfers outweigh the bad of Malky transfers.

no they don't

Malky? How can people blame him when he got sacked? At least under him we was picking up points.

Spot on

annis, i dont blame malky at all but there is no way malky would of kept us up nor Ogs its not the managers that arent good enough its the players we have a squad still full of championship players and 2 strikers!!! one who is a lazy tw*t and one who i like but struggles in this league to score goals.

Our defence is championship standard

our midfield is good but not strong enough to stay up

and like i said the strikers arent good enough we cant score goals if you dont score goals you dont win games simple

Annis you gonna answer the point you think we only have 6 premierships players then whos fault is that?

Or are you just going to ignore it because you know the answer is Malky?

It takes 2 seasons to get a full Premier League squad, Malky would of strengthened in Jan and I honestly believe we would f stayed up, I really do

So what in the mean time we play six a side?

Get real. Hull spent half of what Malky did and spent it far more wisely, improving all areas of their team / squad.

2.5m on Curtis Davies or 9m on Caulker?
5m on Tom Huddlestone or 13m on Gary Medle?
Figueroa on a free or KTC and Brahyford for a combined 4m?
13m for Jelavic and Long or 11m for Cornelius and Odemwingie?

If DJ wasted what Malky did in the summer youd be calling for his head on a stick outside the Ninian.

You were always quick to point out how much Jones had to spend compared to Malky before Tan gave Malky an open cheque book last 2 years.

50m and weve ended up with a squad not that much better than the one Jones had in 2010/11.

Polo you were bumming the signing of Medel a few short months ago

Not for 13m I wasnt

Yes Medel looks a great signing and we are doing well for a team whos goal is to finish 17th.

Links to where I said they were both value for money please, Porkies?

You said they were good signings - if their signatures stopped you strengthening elsewhere then they are not good signings are they Colombo

Being good players and good signings are vastly different.

I was telling you at the time the amount spent on those two was insane considering many can do Medels role for free or minimal fees, yet you kept banging on about caps for Chile

He is average, you over paid and hampered strengthening elsewhere, exactly what I told you at the time and exactly what you were arguing with me over. In fact, it was around about that time and around those discussions that you turned from being a bit of a laugh to a bit of a knob and not really looked back since

I will take solace that another Roathie opinion is now validated months after the fact - visionary

Waffle, waffle and more waffle.

Prove where I said they were value for money.

Put up or shut up.

Is waffle the new thing for "stop talking sense i want to ask you specific selective questions to dig myself out of a hole"

You were banging on for ages how much of a great signing Medel was. If you thought his signature was over priced and thus hampered teams strengthening (which you didnt because you argued with me for saying so) then its not a great signing is it?

Yes Medel looks a great signing and we are doing well for a team whos goal is to finish 17th.

Now you are blaming malky for signing him

The good transfers outweigh the bad of Malky transfers.

no they don't

What, like when you're wanking over Noone, Mutch, Campbell, Caulker etc then forgetting he signed them all.

He gave Declan J his debut aswell.

How much did Campbell, Mutch and Noone cost again?.

The good transfers outweigh the bad of Malky transfers.

Like noone for example who malky wouldn't even start

The good transfers outweigh the bad of Malky transfers.

Like noone for example who malky wouldn't even start

Ye, when we were out of the relegation zone

This is from a debate with Polo about the overspending of Medel in SEPTEMBER...

But him doing his job well could be at the detriment of you not having wingers or strikers that can do their job... Which then impacts negatively on the team. But like i said, we are coming at this from different angles, people dont think like me and i acceot that. People see a good player and assume it must be a good signing ignoring what the team lacks because of his purchase.

Its almost as if Polo is now me 6 months ago

Like i said, visionary.

Anyway bed for me now. Go nuts

Last edited by Roath_Magic_ on Mon Mar 03, 2014 3:04 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Annis you gonna answer the point you think we only have 6 premierships players then whos fault is that?

Or are you just going to ignore it because you know the answer is Malky?

It takes 2 seasons to get a full Premier League squad, Malky would of strengthened in Jan and I honestly believe we would f stayed up, I really do

So what in the mean time we play six a side?

Get real. Hull spent half of what Malky did and spent it far more wisely, improving all areas of their team / squad.

2.5m on Curtis Davies or 9m on Caulker?
5m on Tom Huddlestone or 13m on Gary Medle?
Figueroa on a free or KTC and Brahyford for a combined 4m?
13m for Jelavic and Long or 11m for Cornelius and Odemwingie?

If DJ wasted what Malky did in the summer youd be calling for his head on a stick outside the Ninian.

You were always quick to point out how much Jones had to spend compared to Malky before Tan gave Malky an open cheque book last 2 years.

50m and weve ended up with a squad not that much better than the one Jones had in 2010/11.

Polo, I proved u wrong on Dave Jones, I just wish I could of proved u wrong on Malky.

We both totally beg to differ

I think Steve Bruce and Hull are totally proving you wrong Annis.

Its a shame you are not honest enough to admit Malky wasted the money in the summer.

As I said, if it was DJ who spent what Malky did on such rubbish in the summer you would be starting a "Jones Out". FACT.

Polo, Of course Malky wasted a lot of money, what manager never has?

Is Ole the answer?