Is Gestede good enough?

Whittinghams touch was barely golden same as every other player. 2blue is right helguson was certainly less effective when he came on for Rudy

We must have been watching different games

Looks like it Rudy isnt a brilliant player but he does what asked of him and causes problems.

Im not sure Malky asks him to lose the ball 99% of the time but he did tuck his goal away so ill give him 1% credit

Whittinghams touch was barely golden same as every other player. 2blue is right helguson was certainly less effective when he came on for Rudy

We must have been watching different games

Are you saying helguson was more effective?

Your becoming as deluded as the anti DJ lot

Whittinghams touch was barely golden same as every other player. 2blue is right helguson was certainly less effective when he came on for Rudy

We must have been watching different games

Are you saying helguson was more effective?

Your becoming as deluded as the anti DJ lot

How can you compare he come on for 14 minutes wen we were showing no attacking intent and wasnt given the ball or runners that rudy was, in the first half especially.

First thing Heidur done was smash Shittu and win an header whilst Shittu had bullied Rudy all game.

If you think Rudy is more effective than Helguson you are more deluded than David Ike

Whittinghams touch was barely golden same as every other player. 2blue is right helguson was certainly less effective when he came on for Rudy

We must have been watching different games

Are you saying helguson was more effective?

Your becoming as deluded as the anti DJ lot

By the way my post to cj was more in reference to whitts who calmed the game right down at the end

Whittinghams touch was barely golden same as every other player. 2blue is right helguson was certainly less effective when he came on for Rudy

We must have been watching different games

Are you saying helguson was more effective?

Your becoming as deluded as the anti DJ lot

How can you compare he come on for 14 minutes wen we were showing no attacking intent and wasnt given the ball or runners that rudy was, in the first half especially.

First thing Heidur done was smash Shittu and win an header whilst Shittu had bullied Rudy all game.

If you think Rudy is more effective than Helguson you are more deluded than David Ike

No what I think is Helguson is about 35 and can't play 3 games in a week so Rudy came in, did ok and scored the only goal of the game.

He's a donkey. The only "good" thing he can do is win headers but he can't even do that most of the time, and when he does it goes nowhere.

And score winners

Any one could've scored that goal

Why didn't anyone? Bellamy had better chances, hardly a clear cut chance.

Looking at it again on the football league show its because he wanted it more than the defender and finished well.

Because Rudy's a striker, he's meant to be there to score goals. I agree that Bellamy had better chances, but Bellamy's always in the right place at the right time to get those chances, he just needs to finish them.

I know he scored the only goal yesterday but that one goal isn't going to change my mind on him, he had an awful game, but no one really had a good game. We need someone better.

That line shows how clueless you are

Rudy is nearly 25 now. Not a kid. If he hasnt learned how to kill the ball
with that first touch by now he never will. So he lacks a good touch. Well
not such a big problem cos he's 6ft 4" and his sheer strength and size will
get him the space and time he needs... Wrong. Rudy isnt strong enough
to bully defenders. Ah well, we can always rely on his flick-ons...Wrong.
As he barely wins any headers.

The lad is NOT championship quality

Rudy is nearly 25 now. Not a kid. If he hasnt learned how to kill the ball
with that first touch by now he never will. So he lacks a good touch. Well
not such a big problem cos he's 6ft 4" and his sheer strength and size will
get him the space and time he needs... Wrong. Rudy isnt strong enough
to bully defenders. Ah well, we can always rely on his flick-ons...Wrong.
As he barely wins any headers.

The lad is NOT championship quality

Why are you so over the top and cringe in your posts?

Well now whitts first touch yesterday was worse than rudys .....rudy is a striker ...strikers are there to score goals ..rudy scored ffs ...if he had not scored ...whitts would not have been in a position to slow /control the game in the last 10 minutes lets have a quick look at some of the other untouchables ..every one thinks marshall is the best goalie in the league ..he has saved us on many occasions this season thats what hes there for but his distribution is woeful at best ....turner is there to deffend another clean sheet yesterday well done turner but his passing is terrible at best ...whitts yesterday first touch poor tackling non existant set pieces dreadful but done his job in the build up to our goal and had a very good last 10 minutes ....the point im making none of our players are perfect ..they are all trying there best work for each other and are a team ...lets stop all this is rudy good enough nonesense ffs malky thinks so or he would not pick him ....if your going to single players out its not going to do them or the team any good ....we are top of the league and we are there becouse our squad deserve to be there

Agree with the thoughts above. Good attitude but this is not his level. He managed to finish a pass that put the chance on a plate yards out but did absolutely nothing else all game bar one nice touch to lay off. I like the guy and really wish he was good enough but he's lower Championship at best. Millwall were pretty awful today and he still looked out of his depth.

this

What a bunch of sad tools complaining about someone who is costing us 9 points in 9 games.

The lot of you are quite pathetic.

What a bunch of sad tools complaining about someone who is costing us 9 points in 9 games.

The lot of you are quite pathetic.

It's pathetic that you think that just because some have a different opinion to you.

Yawn yawn

It aint just this thread.. Lets enjoy the wins and just get behind everyone!

I understand this thread but he is here at the moment so lets support him. He bagged us with the one chance we took!

It aint just this thread.. Lets enjoy the wins and just get behind everyone!

I understand this thread but he is here at the moment so lets support him. He bagged us with the one chance we took!

He did that I just want to see more from him, and I hope he can produce that. I'll back every player that wears the strip, no harm in debating things on here though!

Only messing just want to see more happy and I hope he manages to imrpove