Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Re: CITY LOOK TO SIGN DERBY'S SHACKELL?

Sat Jun 16, 2012 9:23 am

Lawnmower wrote:
CP76 wrote:
Lawnmower wrote:Shackell is a decnt defender at this level.

I wouldn't say he'll get in the side before Hudson and Turner, but he'd be excellent cover.

Would suggest to me Gerrard is off.

1m for a cover defender.Waste.


Not at all.

Centre halfs are the most likely players to get injured or suspended.

Can you not remember us having to play McNaughton and Keinan in the play offs v Reading ? Fecking great job they did too :lol:

One lesson from last season is that over 46 games plus cups its about the strength of the SQUAD not just the first xI.

Of course we need forwards and midfielders, but we should not miss the options to strengthen in ALL areas.


You are talking two seasons ago. Weve got two decent cover centre halfs in Blake and Gerrard so why waste 1 million?

Shackell is not 1 million pound better than either Gerrard or Blake

Re: CITY LOOK TO SIGN DERBY'S SHACKELL?

Sat Jun 16, 2012 9:28 am

CP76 wrote:
Lawnmower wrote:
CP76 wrote:
Lawnmower wrote:Shackell is a decnt defender at this level.

I wouldn't say he'll get in the side before Hudson and Turner, but he'd be excellent cover.

Would suggest to me Gerrard is off.

1m for a cover defender.Waste.


Not at all.

Centre halfs are the most likely players to get injured or suspended.

Can you not remember us having to play McNaughton and Keinan in the play offs v Reading ? Fecking great job they did too :lol:

One lesson from last season is that over 46 games plus cups its about the strength of the SQUAD not just the first xI.

Of course we need forwards and midfielders, but we should not miss the options to strengthen in ALL areas.


You are talking two seasons ago. Weve got two decent cover centre halfs in Blake and Gerrard so why waste 1 million?

Shackell is not 1 million pound better than either Gerrard or Blake


Gerrard is most likely on his way - and we will probably get a fee for him,and Blake gets shown up once every few games for his lack of height, he's Ok as full back cover but should only be used as centre half when we are desperate -4th or 5th option. For example Cole and Howard both bossed him far too easily.

We have got to improve in all areas.

Re: CITY LOOK TO SIGN DERBY'S SHACKELL

Sat Jun 16, 2012 10:05 am

CP76 wrote:Donkey


Please put together a comprehensive list of target players available and who would make a difference to cardiff`s promotion - post on here - then you can critisise every bloody transfer that we try to make

Re: CITY LOOK TO SIGN DERBY'S SHACKELL

Sat Jun 16, 2012 10:09 am

TheLad wrote:How long till we lose him to someone else? Any takers?


It's only burnley and us, so possibly 3 days :lol:

Re: CITY LOOK TO SIGN DERBY'S SHACKELL

Sat Jun 16, 2012 10:13 am

NIBluebird wrote:
CP76 wrote:Donkey


Please put together a comprehensive list of target players available and who would make a difference to cardiff`s promotion - post on here - then you can critisise every bloody transfer that we try to make


Who the f**k are you? Vincent Tan?

I dont need to explain f**k all to you

Re: CITY LOOK TO SIGN DERBY'S SHACKELL

Sat Jun 16, 2012 10:29 am

Mafor wrote:Malkys gonna bore the arse of us with all these defenders


Eh? I doubt the plan is to play them all at the same time. All about building strength in depth

Re: CITY LOOK TO SIGN DERBY'S SHACKELL?

Sat Jun 16, 2012 9:18 pm

CP76 dont care who we sign he supports the Palace.