Cardiff City players

Comparing the two first teams I wouldnt swap your full backs and midfield for ours. I am quite happy with mcnaughton, Taylor, cowie, Gunnarson and whitts and don't think there is much to choose between them and your lot. In defence and attack your players obviously win, I think caulker, williams(when not scoring own goals) and Vorm are better than our equivalents. And up front graham and Sinclair beat miller and Conway although I would go for mason over dyer. We've also got Ralls who I think will be a very good player. Your problem will come in the summer if some of your better players are offered 30-40k per week contracts elsewhere that your wage structure won't match. Caulker will also be back at spurs and you'll unfortunately have to play Tate again.

Interesting that you'd take Sinclair and Graham but not Dyer? Dyer has been one of our most consistent performers this season. The two different midfields play a completely different style so hard to compare. Caulker will have to be replaced no doubt as Tate is a squad member at best at this level.

I would be interested to see Darcy Blake playing alongside Williams regularly like they have for Wales. Maybe a case of complimenting each others style?

I'd certainly add Heaton or Marshall, and gunarrson and Miller.

You obviously haven't seen Mr Vorm doing his thing then?

You obviously didnt read the first message properly?

Those 2 wouldn't even get a sniff ahead of Tremmel, nevermind Lord Vorm. Doubt if they'd even get the nod ahead of our right dodgy portuguese number 3.

I'd certainly add Heaton or Marshall, and gunarrson and Miller.

You obviously haven't seen Mr Vorm doing his thing then?

You obviously didnt read the first message properly?

Those 2 wouldn't even get a sniff ahead of Tremmel, nevermind Lord Vorm. Doubt if they'd even get the nod ahead of our right dodgy portuguese number 3.

I never said they would get ahead of Vorm.

Not one reply giving a valid reason why i'm wrong, Of course there is only one reason for that and that is because i am 100% spot on!

That's because you're not wrong. I think it's safe to say that the silence/insults are a sign that you've got it 110% spot on.

You could draw another conclusion from that, if you thought about it for a nanosecond.

I disagree, for the simple fact is that your lot aren't exactly shrinking violets when it comes to putting one over on us jacks. The problem is, you've got no argument on this subject matter.

your having a laugh, go back to your shitty little forum and ask how many of your inbred friends would not want peter whittingham, not many. you were all jizzing over each other when that rumour came out you were going to sign him

I'd certainly add Heaton or Marshall, and gunarrson and Miller.

You obviously haven't seen Mr Vorm doing his thing then?

You obviously didnt read the first message properly?

Those 2 wouldn't even get a sniff ahead of Tremmel, nevermind Lord Vorm. Doubt if they'd even get the nod ahead of our right dodgy portuguese number 3.

I never said they would get ahead of Vorm.

And like I said, they still wouldn't get into our squad.

Not one reply giving a valid reason why i'm wrong, Of course there is only one reason for that and that is because i am 100% spot on!

That's because you're not wrong. I think it's safe to say that the silence/insults are a sign that you've got it 110% spot on.

You could draw another conclusion from that, if you thought about it for a nanosecond.

I disagree, for the simple fact is that your lot aren't exactly shrinking violets when it comes to putting one over on us jacks. The problem is, you've got no argument on this subject matter.

US jacks! What you and JackArmyWalesNo1 retreat lads were outnumbered

your having a laugh, go back to your shitty little forum and ask how many of your inbred friends would not want peter whittingham, not many. you were all jizzing over each other when that rumour came out you were going to sign him

I think you'll find that that was not because he'd offer anything more to the team we've already got, but because you lot would be utterly humiliated and devastated.

Not one reply giving a valid reason why i'm wrong, Of course there is only one reason for that and that is because i am 100% spot on!

That's because you're not wrong. I think it's safe to say that the silence/insults are a sign that you've got it 110% spot on.

You could draw another conclusion from that, if you thought about it for a nanosecond.

I disagree, for the simple fact is that your lot aren't exactly shrinking violets when it comes to putting one over on us jacks. The problem is, you've got no argument on this subject matter.

US jacks! What you and JackArmyWalesNo1 retreat lads were outnumbered

I think you might be missing the point old bean.

Not one reply giving a valid reason why i'm wrong, Of course there is only one reason for that and that is because i am 100% spot on!

That's because you're not wrong. I think it's safe to say that the silence/insults are a sign that you've got it 110% spot on.

You could draw another conclusion from that, if you thought about it for a nanosecond.

I disagree, for the simple fact is that your lot aren't exactly shrinking violets when it comes to putting one over on us jacks. The problem is, you've got no argument on this subject matter.

US jacks! What you and JackArmyWalesNo1 retreat lads were outnumbered

I think you might be missing the point old bean.

The point. Two little jacks, were better than you blah blah blah. Perhaps I'm getting old but seems a little childish. Whatever makes your day I suppose

your having a laugh, go back to your shitty little forum and ask how many of your inbred friends would not want peter whittingham, not many. you were all jizzing over each other when that rumour came out you were going to sign him

I think you'll find that that was not because he'd offer anything more to the team we've already got, but because you lot would be utterly humiliated and devastated.

get real mate, got a choice of 2 dwarves in britton and alun or peter whittingham, i know who most people would choose!
the best player swansea have atm is sigurdsson and hes not even yours

The point. Two little jacks, were better than you blah blah blah. Perhaps I'm getting old but seems a little childish. Whatever makes your day I suppose

Don't be so sensitive. it's a bit of banter FFS! After putting up with years of you lot lording it over us, did you really think that some of us might not take the oppertunity to come on here and rub your noses in it? Remember.. Don't dish it out if you can't take it, and anyway, your time will come again. Maybe.

your having a laugh, go back to your shitty little forum and ask how many of your inbred friends would not want peter whittingham, not many. you were all jizzing over each other when that rumour came out you were going to sign him

I think you'll find that that was not because he'd offer anything more to the team we've already got, but because you lot would be utterly humiliated and devastated.

get real mate, got a choice of 2 dwarves in britton and alun or peter whittingham, i know who most people would choose!
the best player swansea have atm is sigurdsson and hes not even yours

You lot can have very short memories when it suits you. It was only last season that Whittingham was getting slagged off left, right and centre by you lot for looking disinterested and lazy. Remember that, or am I making it up?

The point. Two little jacks, were better than you blah blah blah. Perhaps I'm getting old but seems a little childish. Whatever makes your day I suppose

Don't be so sensitive. it's a bit of banter FFS! After putting up with years of you lot lording it over us, did you really think that some of us might not take the oppertunity to come on here and rub your noses in it? Remember.. Don't dish it out if you can't take it, and anyway, your time will come again. Maybe.

Not sensitive. I just dont go on any SwanseaGower forums never have and never will. I like the banter , Im bantering back in case you didnt notice !! Seems your threads are popular anyway so dont worry about me Im just an bean. Do the and all will be forgiven

Currently there is not one Cardiff City player good enough to get into Swansea's squad let alone first 11. I know we'll get the usual blah would walk in and blah is better than blah blah. Fact is there is no Cardiff Player good enough for our squad.

Firstly JackArmyWalesNumber1 (and Tragic Flaps, you're included too), good banter, there’s nothing wrong with good banter. However, you seem to be an individual that likes answers to his questions, so I’ll gladly satisfy your request...

So none of the Cardiff City ‘squad’ could get into the Swansea squad, let alone the first XI?

If you had mentioned the first XI then I would have to agree to a certain extent, that there are players in your team that are better than ours. I’d be concerned if my team were a league above but had predominantly worse players than one a division below. Maybe I should go onto the Newport County forum (if there is such a thing, but I wouldn’t know as I don’t search for other team’s forums) and tell them how much better our team/squad is?

However, you’ve quite obviously stated that you genuinely believe that your ‘squad’ players are all better than any of our players, so I’ll humour you for a minute....

Goalkeepers
José Moreira and Gerhard Tremmel or David Marshall and Tom Heaton?

I think both of our keepers win hands down there.

Defenders:

Darnel Situ, Joe Walsh, Federico Bessone, Curtis Obeng or Mark Hudson, Kevin McNaughton, Anthony Gerrard, Ben Turner.

Wouldn’t you prefer our ‘squad’ players, over yours?

Midfield:

Jordan Smith, Gwion Edwards, Kurtis March or Peter Whittingham, Craig Conway, Aron Gunnarsson

Wouldn’t you prefer our ‘squad’ players, over yours?

Strikers:

Luke Moore, Casey Thomas or Kenny Miller, Joe Mason

In answer to your absurd question, I have named 11 players who would walk into your ‘squad’.

If you wanted to discuss best XI, then fine...but you didn’t.

Maybe you should go out for a few hours for some fresh air. There’s a lovely little place outside Swansea called Gower, which is nice

Comparing the two first teams I wouldnt swap your full backs and midfield for ours. I am quite happy with mcnaughton, Taylor, cowie, Gunnarson and whitts and don't think there is much to choose between them and your lot. In defence and attack your players obviously win, I think caulker, williams(when not scoring own goals) and Vorm are better than our equivalents. And up front graham and Sinclair beat miller and Conway although I would go for mason over dyer. We've also got Ralls who I think will be a very good player. Your problem will come in the summer if some of your better players are offered 30-40k per week contracts elsewhere that your wage structure won't match. Caulker will also be back at spurs and you'll unfortunately have to play Tate again.

Interesting that you'd take Sinclair and Graham but not Dyer? Dyer has been one of our most consistent performers this season. The two different midfields play a completely different style so hard to compare. Caulker will have to be replaced no doubt as Tate is a squad member at best at this level.

I would be interested to see Darcy Blake playing alongside Williams regularly like they have for Wales. Maybe a case of complimenting each others style?

good post fella, I think Darcy would be good for you alongside Williams and as far as Graham is concerned, I'd sooner have Dyer in my team than Graham.
Now I don't normally respond to Swansea fans posts but scotsjack's input is always a good read, at least he doesn't talk shite

Currently there is not one Cardiff City player good enough to get into Swansea's squad let alone first 11. I know we'll get the usual blah would walk in and blah is better than blah blah. Fact is there is no Cardiff Player good enough for our squad.

Firstly JackArmyWalesNumber1 (and Tragic Flaps, you're included too), good banter, there’s nothing wrong with good banter. However, you seem to be an individual that likes answers to his questions, so I’ll gladly satisfy your request...

So none of the Cardiff City ‘squad’ could get into the Swansea squad, let alone the first XI?

If you had mentioned the first XI then I would have to agree to a certain extent, that there are players in your team that are better than ours. I’d be concerned if my team were a league above but had predominantly worse players than one a division below. Maybe I should go onto the Newport County forum (if there is such a thing, but I wouldn’t know as I don’t search for other team’s forums) and tell them how much better our team/squad is?

However, you’ve quite obviously stated that you genuinely believe that your ‘squad’ players are all better than any of our players, so I’ll humour you for a minute....

Goalkeepers
José Moreira and Gerhard Tremmel or David Marshall and Tom Heaton?

I think both of our keepers win hands down there.

Defenders:

Darnel Situ, Joe Walsh, Federico Bessone, Curtis Obeng or Mark Hudson, Kevin McNaughton, Anthony Gerrard, Ben Turner.

Wouldn’t you prefer our ‘squad’ players, over yours?

Midfield:

Jordan Smith, Gwion Edwards, Kurtis March or Peter Whittingham, Craig Conway, Aron Gunnarsson

Wouldn’t you prefer our ‘squad’ players, over yours?

Strikers:

Luke Moore, Casey Thomas or Kenny Miller, Joe Mason

In answer to your absurd question, I have named 11 players who would walk into your ‘squad’.

If you wanted to discuss best XI, then fine...but you didn’t.

Maybe you should go out for a few hours for some fresh air. There’s a lovely little place outside Swansea called Gower, which is nice

I was going to reply something along the lines of.. "fair play, that's a point well made" etc, etc. But then I read the last line of your post.
I don't want to start this all over again, as I'm sure you don't. It's become extremely tedious, but I will defend my stance on the matter if push comes to shove. So lets just agree not to mention the G word shall we, and especially where in the world the G word is located?
Just for the record...
The G is part of the city and county of S.

Comparing the two first teams I wouldnt swap your full backs and midfield for ours. I am quite happy with mcnaughton, Taylor, cowie, Gunnarson and whitts and don't think there is much to choose between them and your lot. In defence and attack your players obviously win, I think caulker, williams(when not scoring own goals) and Vorm are better than our equivalents. And up front graham and Sinclair beat miller and Conway although I would go for mason over dyer. We've also got Ralls who I think will be a very good player. Your problem will come in the summer if some of your better players are offered 30-40k per week contracts elsewhere that your wage structure won't match. Caulker will also be back at spurs and you'll unfortunately have to play Tate again.

Interesting that you'd take Sinclair and Graham but not Dyer? Dyer has been one of our most consistent performers this season. The two different midfields play a completely different style so hard to compare. Caulker will have to be replaced no doubt as Tate is a squad member at best at this level.

I would be interested to see Darcy Blake playing alongside Williams regularly like they have for Wales. Maybe a case of complimenting each others style?

good post fella, I think Darcy would be good for you alongside Williams and as far as Graham is concerned, I'd sooner have Dyer in my team than Graham.
Now I don't normally respond to Swansea fans posts but scotsjack's input is always a good read, at least he doesn't talk shite

Dyer is obviously having a great season in your system but in our system I think mason playing off graham would be awesome. Think graham is just the sort of striker we need, good finisher, decent in the air and on the floor. Wonder if malky would have convinced board to splash out on him here if he had been in post earlier?

For gods sake dont mention gypseys.. Magic daps will swamp us with his links again, he's about as stimulating as a cock swab

I wasn't going to bother, but seeing as you virtually asked me to, I shall of course duly oblige...

http://wales.gov.uk/docs/statistics/201 ... 2011en.pdf
http://news.bbc.co.uk/local/southeastwa ... 127176.stm

So you know what a cock swab feels like? You might want to leave them butetown girls alone.

Your such a caaaahnt Its wasn't bute town that did it, it was the ladyboys in Thailand and your sister.. Cheers for the links I never tire of them

Not one reply giving a valid reason why i'm wrong, Of course there is only one reason for that and that is because i am 100% spot on!

That's because you're not wrong. I think it's safe to say that the silence/insults are a sign that you've got it 110% spot on.

You could draw another conclusion from that, if you thought about it for a nanosecond.

I disagree, for the simple fact is that your lot aren't exactly shrinking violets when it comes to putting one over on us jacks. The problem is, you've got no argument on this subject matter.

In your opinion.

Their keeper and their defence is better than ours, their wingers are miles better than ours, Whitts and Gunnarson are as good, if not better than the likes of Britton, Mark Gower, Kemy Augestin, and Miller is better than every single one of Swanseas strikers, bar maybe Graham, who would probably just edge it on age, but in his prime Graham couldnt lace Millers boots.

Their keeper and their defence is better than ours, their wingers are miles better than ours, Whitts and Gunnarson are as good, if not better than the likes of Britton, Mark Gower, Kemy Augestin, and Miller is better than every single one of Swanseas strikers, bar maybe Graham, who would probably just edge it on age, but in his prime Graham couldnt lace Millers boots.

Seems about right to me

Only thing I would add is that Leon Britton fits our team perfectly, whereas Whittingham or Gunnarson might not?

Their keeper and their defence is better than ours, their wingers are miles better than ours, Whitts and Gunnarson are as good, if not better than the likes of Britton, Mark Gower, Kemy Augestin, and Miller is better than every single one of Swanseas strikers, bar maybe Graham, who would probably just edge it on age, but in his prime Graham couldnt lace Millers boots.

Seems about right to me

Only thing I would add is that Leon Britton fits our team perfectly, whereas Whittingham or Gunnarson might not?

Possibly but his role is hardly unique or difficult, I am sure with someone of Whits ability he could do what Britton does ie: ticking play over with 5 yard passes sideways and backwards, no problem whatsoever.

Vorm
Kev Turner Williams Taylor
Dyer Gunnarsson Britton Whittingham Sinclair
Miller

*loan players not included

only position where your stronger than us is on the wings

Re: Cardiff City players

Postby LutonBluebird » Tue Feb 07, 2012 8:22 am
Im not gonna waste my time replying to that crap!!!!

What a load of rubbish

Bye bye!!!......................I think you will find you just did

Whittingham
Turner (better than that English prick Williams)
Gunnarsson
Miller
Cowie
Marshall
Heaton
Taylor probably would
Solomon Taiwo
These are just a few Cardiff players that would make it into your group

I can't remember a time when there was not one Swansea City player who wouldn't get into the cardiff city side, even when you were a championship side and we were league 2 there was always at least 4 players who would get in your side.

Currently there is not one Cardiff City player good enough to get into Swansea's squad let alone first 11. I know we'll get the usual blah would walk in and blah is better than blah blah. Fact is there is no Cardiff Player good enough for our squad.

What are your thoughts on this and would you like to see done to remedy this awful problem of yours?

i take it your to young to remember 2003 when you finished 3rd from bottom of league 2 and we got promoted to the championship. do you still think there was any players in that team which would have got in ours. what a thick c**t you are

Fishing for bites.

Another pointless and stupid thread by a Jack who thinks about us before Swansea.

But then I read the last line of your post.
I don't want to start this all over again, as I'm sure you don't. It's become extremely tedious, but I will defend my stance on the matter if push comes to shove. So lets just agree not to mention the G word shall we, and especially where in the world the G word is located?
Just for the record...
The G is part of the city and county of S.

You're the last person that should comment on things becoming extremly tedious.

This bloke is obviously a moron with the IQ to match

Why don't you do what all jacks do when you reach a major cup final switch off your playstation and jump into bed with your sister

Another pointless post from a jack tw@t