" GOODBYE EARNIE ? "

I think we should keep Earnie until the end of the season and then review his situation.

With Rudy out now probably for a while, Earnie will be making the job. Earnie is without doubt 1 of the best players in the championship that doesn't even make the bench.

Malky will do what's best though!

Geez......I bet you regret calling yourself Jay Bothroyd dontcha?

Noone £700,000 plus earnshaw ??????????

As sad as it would be to see Earnie leave, our need for a winger who has sheer pace and can take players on is much greater

Personally you can say what you want about McGugan but i would defientley take McGugan over Earnshaw. McGugan is younger and better!

I met Earnie about 2 weeks ago and he didnt look happy when chatting about football , his body language showed the same too . He needs game time and at the mo at Cardiff he wont get it so maybe another move could be good for him , dare I say he maybe needs to drop 1 division too to get regular starts ?

He did that last time before he moved to west brom, waved and got emotional at ninian park

and I honestly feel if he went back to nottingham forest he could have an important role to play, and could keep them up, he'l score goals and earn then crucial points.
proved he can score against a decent side again

Who'll replace him?until that question is answered hes not going anywhere.
What if miller and mason/gestade got injured? we'd be fucked.
miller/earnie didn't work because they were both unfit at the time.
masons pace with earnie lurking in the centre well we saw glimpses of that on saturday.