Fri Dec 10, 2010 6:54 am
Fri Dec 10, 2010 8:13 am
nerd wrote:Damned Yank wrote:I suspect Annis and Lord already knew all this but just didn't want to go into that much depth for the good of the club.
Nonetheless, interesting to know TNT, even if some of the details were 'off''.
Hmm. One thing I'm good at is smelling rats.
We now hear the man wasn't really Ridsdale's dad. That would be impossible. No, he merely thought it was Ridsdale's dad. Which is why he repeatedly referred to Ridsdale's father rather than doing what anyone else would do, and write something like "there with a man who may have been his dad". Indeed, quite what relevance Ridsdale's relationship to the man is/was is irrelevant to the tale anyway.
So what can we tell from this post? The premise has been shown to be false; it's a mashup of previously revealed information. The new item about Borley seems kosher... I'm just wondering if the cock and bull story around it has been designed to discredit previously revealed information.
Fri Dec 10, 2010 9:27 am
Lawnmower wrote:Tony Blue Williams wrote:Cheers TNT your post seems to colate with what Carl has been telling us recently.
I wouldnt have took you for being gullible Tony.
Fri Dec 10, 2010 9:37 am
Tony Blue Williams wrote:nerd wrote:Damned Yank wrote:I suspect Annis and Lord already knew all this but just didn't want to go into that much depth for the good of the club.
Nonetheless, interesting to know TNT, even if some of the details were 'off''.
Hmm. One thing I'm good at is smelling rats.
We now hear the man wasn't really Ridsdale's dad. That would be impossible. No, he merely thought it was Ridsdale's dad. Which is why he repeatedly referred to Ridsdale's father rather than doing what anyone else would do, and write something like "there with a man who may have been his dad". Indeed, quite what relevance Ridsdale's relationship to the man is/was is irrelevant to the tale anyway.
So what can we tell from this post? The premise has been shown to be false; it's a mashup of previously revealed information. The new item about Borley seems kosher... I'm just wondering if the cock and bull story around it has been designed to discredit previously revealed information.
Or TNT made a simple mistake? We have all made assumptions which have proved wrong and I bet everything that you have done the same at some point in your life.
Annis and Joff have both confirmed the basis of the information is true and has been known to them for some time. I accept it is reasonable to speculate whether the conversation between Ridsdale and one other ever took place with TNT conveniently sat behind, but for me it's the quality of the information about Cardiff City which counts and that has been confirmed as very good.
Fri Dec 10, 2010 9:52 am
Fri Dec 10, 2010 11:04 am