Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 12:42 pm

Wasn’t the managers fault. Wasn’t the players fault. It’s the board that failed to back us in summer. We run out of steam and only had kids and turnbull on bench

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 12:46 pm

We had one available centre back and we are a team that came up from league one against a team that came down from the prem having spent 14 years there and are expected to go back up and have easily one of the best squads in the division.

Yeah it sucks to lose a three goal head start but I'd have taken a point at the start of the night.

Always find it interesting how the order of the goals affects peoples judgement of how the match went. If we had been 3 nil down and fought back we'd still have the same amount of points just a lot of people would have less to moan about (though some would still find something).

And yes it 100% matters who you are playing.

West Ham will be in the mix end of season for autos. Parker's got experience in the division and they have a squad to good for the league. It'll be them Boro and Wolves and maybe Birmingham as dark(er) horses for the two auto spots.

Expecting them to not make a fight of it after that shower of a first half (from their point of view) is blue tinted spec syndrome. They were shocking first half, manager gave them a rollicking tweaked things and they came at us hard.

They'll give a few teams a spanking in the coming weeks I think as they start to feel a new manager bounce.

End of the day, their first, second and arguably third were all defensive positioning errors, which seemed to be a direct result of players not instinctively knowing where they should be on the pitch, because they were playing out of position.

The first two goals (while beautifully executed) both took advantage of the fact we only had one recognized central defender on the pitch and there was a massive gap between Bagan and Fish - and Robertson, who seemed to be instinctively trying to fill it, got lost in no-mans land.

Given the lack of centre backs and quality of competition, while like everyone else gutted couldn't hold onto three points in the cold light of day, that is a solid result in my eyes.


:bluebird:

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 12:56 pm

A weak bench is what cost us , the players were dead on there feet after 60 minutes they put a lot into that first half and second half west ham went up about 5 gears

anyone who's played at a decent level will tell you when you are playing against higher quality players fatigue sets in really quickly your legs get heavy and balls through you would have easily cut out earlier in the game start to slip past you your brain gets foggy you lose half a yard of pace and it becomes a real struggle

So I dont blame bbm the difference was they could bring on 60 millions worth of reinforcements to change the game and we couldn't

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 12:59 pm

Replies:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:01 pm

Blue since 1981 wrote:A weak bench is what cost us , the players were dead on there feet after 60 minutes they put a lot into that first half and second half west ham went up about 5 gears

anyone who's played at a decent level will tell you when you are playing against higher quality players fatigue sets in really quickly your legs get heavy and balls through you would have easily cut out earlier in the game start to slip past you your brain gets foggy you lose half a yard of pace and it becomes a real struggle

So I dont blame bbm the difference was they could bring on 60 millions worth of reinforcements to change the game and we couldn't
:shock:




So saying a weak bench does that mean it’s working having a Small Squad?

And don’t forget We have Only Won 3 League games out of 14 League Games

Plus we are 18th in the Championship

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:04 pm

Replies:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:08 pm

I agree :
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:19 pm

Blue since 1981 wrote:A weak bench is what cost us , the players were dead on there feet after 60 minutes they put a lot into that first half and second half west ham went up about 5 gears

anyone who's played at a decent level will tell you when you are playing against higher quality players fatigue sets in really quickly your legs get heavy and balls through you would have easily cut out earlier in the game start to slip past you your brain gets foggy you lose half a yard of pace and it becomes a real struggle

So I dont blame bbm the difference was they could bring on 60 millions worth of reinforcements to change the game and we couldn't


Did those replacements actually change game? What changed game was parker seeing our weaknesses and used bowen to exploit them 2nd half... ... it only needed for a city player to man mark him and the goals dont happen... bowen is best player in championship and we did nothing to stop his role 2nd half! Two passes from inside own half over the top was his strength we should never have allowed him freedom of ccs to play thos ball's not withstanding the cross that left defenders froz and trott holding imaginary ball as player walked in front of them to score ... all goals would been avoided if a player was used to mark bowen other managers would have done so why not bbm?

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:19 pm

Forever Blue wrote:
Blue since 1981 wrote:A weak bench is what cost us , the players were dead on there feet after 60 minutes they put a lot into that first half and second half west ham went up about 5 gears

anyone who's played at a decent level will tell you when you are playing against higher quality players fatigue sets in really quickly your legs get heavy and balls through you would have easily cut out earlier in the game start to slip past you your brain gets foggy you lose half a yard of pace and it becomes a real struggle

So I dont blame bbm the difference was they could bring on 60 millions worth of reinforcements to change the game and we couldn't
:shock:




So saying a weak bench does that mean it’s working having a Small Squad?

And don’t forget We have Only Won 3 League games out of 14 League Games

Plus we are 18th in the Championship

No a squad our size doesn't work it needs to be at least 5 quality players bigger and ive held my opinion since the end of the transfer window , I dont belive bbm wants a big squad but I believe he wanted one slightly bigger than what we have got and tan was unwilling to back him in the way he wanted but he won't risk his job by coming out and saying that and I dont blame him

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:35 pm

It is reassuring today to see a lot more people say it's not the manager's fault.

It's not. He managed the game well.

Some people just don't like that he doesn't call out the board - which is bonkers because if he did then he would be sacked. Either that or they just go to the default "blame the manager" when that's not always true.

The manager is doing brilliantly with this team. We have gone toe to toe with a West Ham team that has Premier League quality everywhere and a new manager, a Birmingham team who are scoring for fun and a Middlesbrough team who will probably be promoted. Long may it continue :bluebird:

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:40 pm

Of course it’s BBM fault he’s the boss and this season he is struggling so he takes the blame,they are his players, open your eyes boy.

If we do well he takes all the accolades :thumbright:

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:43 pm

Always City wrote:Of course it’s BBM fault he’s the boss and this season he is struggling so he takes the blame,they are his players, open your eyes boy.


Absolute rubbish.

But this is what people do. They just blame the manager because it's the easiest thing to do. It's lazy comments.

He got his tactics spot on, substitutions spot on. We just couldn't see the game out.

And we are not struggling at home, we are one of only five teams unbeaten at home and the others are all top teams - Middlesbrough, Southampton, Swansea and Wolves.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:57 pm

pembroke allan wrote:
Blue since 1981 wrote:A weak bench is what cost us , the players were dead on there feet after 60 minutes they put a lot into that first half and second half west ham went up about 5 gears

anyone who's played at a decent level will tell you when you are playing against higher quality players fatigue sets in really quickly your legs get heavy and balls through you would have easily cut out earlier in the game start to slip past you your brain gets foggy you lose half a yard of pace and it becomes a real struggle

So I dont blame bbm the difference was they could bring on 60 millions worth of reinforcements to change the game and we couldn't


Did those replacements actually change game? What changed game was parker seeing our weaknesses and used bowen to exploit them 2nd half... ... it only needed for a city player to man mark him and the goals dont happen... bowen is best player in championship and we did nothing to stop his role 2nd half! Two passes from inside own half over the top was his strength we should never have allowed him freedom of ccs to play thos ball's not withstanding the cross that left defenders froz and trott holding imaginary ball as player walked in front of them to score ... all goals would been avoided if a player was used to mark bowen other managers would have done so why not bbm?

Yes piro made a huge difference gave west ham a focal point to play off won the flick on for the second goal and gave fish and bagan a lot more to deal with than the first half

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 2:10 pm

The first goal I thought we were playing a too high a line when Bowen played the ball forward the back 4 were nearly up to the centre circle, and I thought Trott came rushing out too quick it was obvious their player had a simple lob into the net. If Trott had stayed back a bit the striker would have had a decision to make how he was going to score. The second goal was very similar with the ball coming over the top of the back 4 even though think it was Bagan got a touch on the ball.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 2:16 pm

Reply:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 3:28 pm

Forever Blue wrote:I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU’RE 3-0 UP YOU WIN THE GAME / TO MANAGE THE REMAINDER OF THE GAME / YOU EMPLOYE YOUR TACTICS TO CLOSE OUT THE GAME:

The coaching staff got it wrong and you don’t let a 3nil lead disappear
:thumbup: :thumbright: :thumbup: Spot on Annis :thumbup: :thumbright: :thumbup: :bluebird: :bluebird: :bluebird:

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 3:48 pm

Well over on the WH forum they seem to think that they dropped 2 points against a poor team, except for 1 guy. I would have taken a draw beforehand, was happy that we held on after that second half & now I'm upset that we didn't shove the 3 points up their arrogant arses.

Monty must be busy as he hasn't put up anything from the opposition board like he has been doing, hope you're okay mate.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:44 pm

Replies:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:45 pm

Rodneyblue wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU’RE 3-0 UP YOU WIN THE GAME / TO MANAGE THE REMAINDER OF THE GAME / YOU EMPLOYE YOUR TACTICS TO CLOSE OUT THE GAME:

The coaching staff got it wrong and you don’t let a 3nil lead disappear
:thumbup: :thumbright: :thumbup: Spot on Annis :thumbup: :thumbright: :thumbup: :bluebird: :bluebird: :bluebird:



Rodney,

We had it in the bag, we only have ourselves to blame.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:45 pm

Reply:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:46 pm

Reply :
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:48 pm

Welshman in CA wrote:Well over on the WH forum they seem to think that they dropped 2 points against a poor team, except for 1 guy. I would have taken a draw beforehand, was happy that we held on after that second half & now I'm upset that we didn't shove the 3 points up their arrogant arses.

Monty must be busy as he hasn't put up anything from the opposition board like he has been doing, hope you're okay mate.


I am in cardiff budd apologies getting sloshed and forgetting that comeback

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:50 pm

montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:Well over on the WH forum they seem to think that they dropped 2 points against a poor team, except for 1 guy. I would have taken a draw beforehand, was happy that we held on after that second half & now I'm upset that we didn't shove the 3 points up their arrogant arses.

Monty must be busy as he hasn't put up anything from the opposition board like he has been doing, hope you're okay mate.


I am in cardiff budd apologies getting sloshed and forgetting that comeback

And staying till sunday sat game and marching sunday for Rememberance for my dad uncle and auntie who gave all for there country

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:52 pm

montyblue wrote:
montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:Well over on the WH forum they seem to think that they dropped 2 points against a poor team, except for 1 guy. I would have taken a draw beforehand, was happy that we held on after that second half & now I'm upset that we didn't shove the 3 points up their arrogant arses.

Monty must be busy as he hasn't put up anything from the opposition board like he has been doing, hope you're okay mate.


I am in cardiff budd apologies getting sloshed and forgetting that comeback

And staying till sunday sat game and marching sunday for Rememberance for my dad uncle and auntie who gave all for there country


I have no Internet at the .
Motorhome park here in cardiff bloody lowsy

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:59 pm

Replies :
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 5:19 pm

Reply:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 5:22 pm

I don't think BBM is immune to criticism, but I really struggle to see how he can be blamed for the 3-3.

The only thing he could perhaps have done differently was take Salech off, move Moylan into the 9 and play Ashford as the 10, similar to how we played against Watford and Middlesbrough.

Would it have worked? We'll never know. But I can completely understand why he kept Salech on, particularly to help defend corners and set pieces against a West Ham side full of big, physical players, especially with the quality of Bowen's delivery.

A full-strength Barcelona side once threw away a three-goal lead against Liverpool, with arguably the best player in the world in their team! These things happen in football.

All the rest of his subs were forced changes and I certainly can't fault the effort of our players. We had Tanner playing at left-back and others clearly battling through injuries. West Ham came out like a train in the second half, and once they got that first goal, you could sense the momentum shifting. In the end, I thought we showed real character to hang on for the draw.

Of course it's disappointing to let a three-goal lead slip, and everyone is entitled to feel frustrated. But I think it's important to keep some perspective.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 5:22 pm

montyblue wrote:
montyblue wrote:
montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:Well over on the WH forum they seem to think that they dropped 2 points against a poor team, except for 1 guy. I would have taken a draw beforehand, was happy that we held on after that second half & now I'm upset that we didn't shove the 3 points up their arrogant arses.

Monty must be busy as he hasn't put up anything from the opposition board like he has been doing, hope you're okay mate.


I am in cardiff budd apologies getting sloshed and forgetting that comeback

And staying till sunday sat game and marching sunday for Rememberance for my dad uncle and auntie who gave all for there country


I have no Internet at the .
Motorhome park here in cardiff bloody lowsy


Have fun & don't worry about it, amazing that there are still places without internet though, I guess I'm spoilt here as everywhere has it or I can use my phone as a hot spot if really needed.

Hope we win Saturday & the march goes well & it stays dry, weather ap says cloudy but no rain for Sunday.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 5:26 pm

Bonkers game of football. It happens. Negativity towards BBM as a result is an over reaction; which seems to be the modern day approach. I cannot think who'd Id rather at the wheel at the moment.

Take the point, move on.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 5:37 pm

worcester_ccfc wrote:
Always City wrote:Of course it’s BBM fault he’s the boss and this season he is struggling so he takes the blame,they are his players, open your eyes boy.


Absolute rubbish.

But this is what people do. They just blame the manager because it's the easiest thing to do. It's lazy comments.

He got his tactics spot on, substitutions spot on. We just couldn't see the game out.

And we are not struggling at home, we are one of only five teams unbeaten at home and the others are all top teams - Middlesbrough, Southampton, Swansea and Wolves.


So if it’s not the managers fault then who decided to play a different way second half and give West Ham the freedom to attack us.
First half Bowen very quiet thanks to Scanlon doing a job on him. The sub for Scanlon should have done the same. It’s the managers job to sort that. BBM to blame for that second half performance.
Take the plaudits for first half but criticism for the second half.