Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Re: Calum Scanlon

Wed Aug 12, 2026 11:56 am

Not on about the right accusation you said this is how the transfer window works but then said or this is how cardiff do it, so I pointed out swansea as an example did not do it the way you suggest now you say its about the right players?
I am sure swansea did not just sign anyone ,they got there's early and are ready to start the season with there new recruits in place,
we start the season down on players from last season despite signing 1 player.

Re: Calum Scanlon

Wed Aug 12, 2026 11:59 am

worcester_ccfc wrote:
montyblue wrote:Scanlon is just an easy pic i would suggest as he was here last season but did hardly anything,
so I would not bring him back based on what I saw and if he showed he was a good acquisition he would have alternated between bagan but he didn't he was a injury time sub .


What a surprise.

You're in the minority on this thread.



He was quick and that is about as much anyone could say about him you yourself said you could not judge on what you have seen,
he may turn out a bril player but what most fans saw he was an injury time sub .

Re: Calum Scanlon

Wed Aug 12, 2026 12:00 pm

montyblue wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:
montyblue wrote:Scanlon is just an easy pic i would suggest as he was here last season but did hardly anything,
so I would not bring him back based on what I saw and if he showed he was a good acquisition he would have alternated between bagan but he didn't he was a injury time sub .


What a surprise.

You're in the minority on this thread.



He was quick and that is about as much anyone could say about him you yourself said you could not judge on what you have seen,
he may turn out a bril player but what most fans saw he was an injury time sub .


Yeah saying I couldn't judge him isn't the same as writing him off.

Re: Calum Scanlon

Wed Aug 12, 2026 12:12 pm

worcester_ccfc wrote:
montyblue wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:
montyblue wrote:Scanlon is just an easy pic i would suggest as he was here last season but did hardly anything,
so I would not bring him back based on what I saw and if he showed he was a good acquisition he would have alternated between bagan but he didn't he was a injury time sub .


What a surprise.

You're in the minority on this thread.



He was quick and that is about as much anyone could say about him you yourself said you could not judge on what you have seen,
he may turn out a bril player but what most fans saw he was an injury time sub .


Yeah saying I couldn't judge him isn't the same as writing him off.



Writing him off based on what I saw yes,
but if that's all we have then we will have to go with him and he may turn out ok
,or are you saying scanlon as you have pointed out is picking the right players not just anyone.
And you have not answered about swansea example you say this is how the transfer window works according to you all teams do dealings late in the window ?but then said that's how we do it, so it's not how the transfer window works for all, some get players in early not just late so get off your high horse telling me this is how it's done.