Tue Dec 21, 2021 6:39 pm
Tue Dec 21, 2021 7:25 pm
Tue Dec 21, 2021 7:27 pm
Tue Dec 21, 2021 7:54 pm
rumpo kid wrote:Blame the good folk who vote cretin.. not even Obi-Wan can save us from this buffoon.
Tue Dec 21, 2021 8:18 pm
Floppsy wrote:rumpo kid wrote:Blame the good folk who vote cretin.. not even Obi-Wan can save us from this buffoon.
Who's the alternative and what different action would you want them to take?
Rightly or wrongly, Mark Drakefords name can't seem to be mentioned on here without a derogatory adjective attached to it, but rarely is an alternative offered.
Tue Dec 21, 2021 11:02 pm
Tue Dec 21, 2021 11:16 pm
rumpo kid wrote:Blame the good folk who vote cretin.. not even Obi-Wan can save us from this buffoon.
Tue Dec 21, 2021 11:21 pm
Floppsy wrote:rumpo kid wrote:Blame the good folk who vote cretin.. not even Obi-Wan can save us from this buffoon.
Who's the alternative and what different action would you want them to take?
Rightly or wrongly, Mark Drakefords name can't seem to be mentioned on here without a derogatory adjective attached to it, but rarely is an alternative offered.
Wed Dec 22, 2021 9:12 am
Wed Dec 22, 2021 9:24 am
neathbluebird wrote:As the person starting this thread ...some interesting replies and certainly contradicting opinions.
The point of my post is that i think Drakeford has overeacted to the new strain..
If you look at the death rate for this new variant then its actually less than for the flu in a bad year...every year there are 20k plus deaths from the flu & significantly more in a bad year but we live with the flu with annual vaccines for the vulnerable and society carries on as normal....similarly we are going to have to live with covid in the same way now and for many years to come.
Wed Dec 22, 2021 9:30 am
Wed Dec 22, 2021 9:57 am
Wed Dec 22, 2021 10:04 am
Wed Dec 22, 2021 10:26 am
Floppsy wrote:Politicians throughout the pandemic have either been criticised for not acting soon enough, or waiting too long before making a decision.
They can't win.
Wed Dec 22, 2021 10:49 am
Wed Dec 22, 2021 11:10 am
piledriver64 wrote:Floppsy wrote:Politicians throughout the pandemic have either been criticised for not acting soon enough, or waiting too long before making a decision.
They can't win.
Agreed. If Drakeford, by making these decisions, can remove the restrictions earlier and avoid huge pressure on the NHS then he will be proved right and despite our moans about football, clubs, etc., it would be hard to criticise. Although he will also have to deliver on the booster program too as that is the ultimate solution accepted by scientists and all UK leaders.
Similarly, if Boris is able to hold back the pressure on NHS by keeping things as they are for now then he will be proved right. In any event, I think Boris will be introducing similar restrictions to Wales after Christmas if he can get it through Parliament.
The one thing Boris can't now do is hide behind the "I listen to the science" argument.
Science is telling us to act now to avoid pain later the only mitigation against that, accepted by scientists in the main, is that scientists don't have to take into account the socio-economic factors into account when giving their advice. These are now clearly political decisions with a bit of advice from scientists behind them.
Personally I think we should learn from what happened after the Liverpool Champions League game and Cheltenham right at the start of the pandemic and act early. I may be proved wrong on that but it will be interesting to see which approach proves most successful in stalling the progress of this new variant.
Wed Dec 22, 2021 11:36 am
piledriver64 wrote:Floppsy wrote:Politicians throughout the pandemic have either been criticised for not acting soon enough, or waiting too long before making a decision.
They can't win.
Agreed. If Drakeford, by making these decisions, can remove the restrictions earlier and avoid huge pressure on the NHS then he will be proved right and despite our moans about football, clubs, etc., it would be hard to criticise. Although he will also have to deliver on the booster program too as that is the ultimate solution accepted by scientists and all UK leaders.
Similarly, if Boris is able to hold back the pressure on NHS by keeping things as they are for now then he will be proved right. In any event, I think Boris will be introducing similar restrictions to Wales after Christmas if he can get it through Parliament.
The one thing Boris can't now do is hide behind the "I listen to the science" argument.
Science is telling us to act now to avoid pain later the only mitigation against that, accepted by scientists in the main, is that scientists don't have to take into account the socio-economic factors into account when giving their advice. These are now clearly political decisions with a bit of advice from scientists behind them.
Personally I think we should learn from what happened after the Liverpool Champions League game and Cheltenham right at the start of the pandemic and act early. I may be proved wrong on that but it will be interesting to see which approach proves most successful in stalling the progress of this new variant.
Wed Dec 22, 2021 11:51 am
Floppsy wrote:piledriver64 wrote:Floppsy wrote:Politicians throughout the pandemic have either been criticised for not acting soon enough, or waiting too long before making a decision.
They can't win.
Agreed. If Drakeford, by making these decisions, can remove the restrictions earlier and avoid huge pressure on the NHS then he will be proved right and despite our moans about football, clubs, etc., it would be hard to criticise. Although he will also have to deliver on the booster program too as that is the ultimate solution accepted by scientists and all UK leaders.
Similarly, if Boris is able to hold back the pressure on NHS by keeping things as they are for now then he will be proved right. In any event, I think Boris will be introducing similar restrictions to Wales after Christmas if he can get it through Parliament.
The one thing Boris can't now do is hide behind the "I listen to the science" argument.
Science is telling us to act now to avoid pain later the only mitigation against that, accepted by scientists in the main, is that scientists don't have to take into account the socio-economic factors into account when giving their advice. These are now clearly political decisions with a bit of advice from scientists behind them.
Personally I think we should learn from what happened after the Liverpool Champions League game and Cheltenham right at the start of the pandemic and act early. I may be proved wrong on that but it will be interesting to see which approach proves most successful in stalling the progress of this new variant.
If Mark Drakeford is proved wrong by acting too early then the costs are more economic. If Boris Johnson is proved wrong for waiting then there's potentially more of a human cost at stake.
Wed Dec 22, 2021 12:03 pm
castleblue wrote:piledriver64 wrote:Floppsy wrote:Politicians throughout the pandemic have either been criticised for not acting soon enough, or waiting too long before making a decision.
They can't win.
Agreed. If Drakeford, by making these decisions, can remove the restrictions earlier and avoid huge pressure on the NHS then he will be proved right and despite our moans about football, clubs, etc., it would be hard to criticise. Although he will also have to deliver on the booster program too as that is the ultimate solution accepted by scientists and all UK leaders.
Similarly, if Boris is able to hold back the pressure on NHS by keeping things as they are for now then he will be proved right. In any event, I think Boris will be introducing similar restrictions to Wales after Christmas if he can get it through Parliament.
The one thing Boris can't now do is hide behind the "I listen to the science" argument.
Science is telling us to act now to avoid pain later the only mitigation against that, accepted by scientists in the main, is that scientists don't have to take into account the socio-economic factors into account when giving their advice. These are now clearly political decisions with a bit of advice from scientists behind them.
Personally I think we should learn from what happened after the Liverpool Champions League game and Cheltenham right at the start of the pandemic and act early. I may be proved wrong on that but it will be interesting to see which approach proves most successful in stalling the progress of this new variant.
You make a great point there "If he can get it through Parliament" and of course you are talking about the Prime Minister and the Westminster Parliament.
Mr Drakeford and his looney left cronies are at this moment just dishing out dictates with NO scrutiny from the Senedd. Following a request by the Welsh Conservatives the Senedd has been recalled today to discuss these dictates raining out of Drakeford House, but unlike the UK Prime Minister NO vote will take place.
The UK Health Security Agency, who are monitoring this Omicron effect on the UK, are finding exactly the same as South Africa i.e. increased infection rates but mainly mild symptoms and fewer people being admitted to hospital. In fact in London over the weekend over 50% of people admitted to hospital were found to be omicron positive on admittance for other conditions. In ICU beds in London 9 out of 10 beds yesterday were occupied by unvaccinated.
I accept it's early days but the latest dictates from Mr Drakeford on the working from home, £60 fines and criminal offence, with NO scrutiny from the Senedd can hardly be called Democratic.
![]()
Wed Dec 22, 2021 12:10 pm
aber blue wrote:Floppsy wrote:piledriver64 wrote:Floppsy wrote:Politicians throughout the pandemic have either been criticised for not acting soon enough, or waiting too long before making a decision.
They can't win.
Agreed. If Drakeford, by making these decisions, can remove the restrictions earlier and avoid huge pressure on the NHS then he will be proved right and despite our moans about football, clubs, etc., it would be hard to criticise. Although he will also have to deliver on the booster program too as that is the ultimate solution accepted by scientists and all UK leaders.
Similarly, if Boris is able to hold back the pressure on NHS by keeping things as they are for now then he will be proved right. In any event, I think Boris will be introducing similar restrictions to Wales after Christmas if he can get it through Parliament.
The one thing Boris can't now do is hide behind the "I listen to the science" argument.
Science is telling us to act now to avoid pain later the only mitigation against that, accepted by scientists in the main, is that scientists don't have to take into account the socio-economic factors into account when giving their advice. These are now clearly political decisions with a bit of advice from scientists behind them.
Personally I think we should learn from what happened after the Liverpool Champions League game and Cheltenham right at the start of the pandemic and act early. I may be proved wrong on that but it will be interesting to see which approach proves most successful in stalling the progress of this new variant.
If Mark Drakeford is proved wrong by acting too early then the costs are more economic. If Boris Johnson is proved wrong for waiting then there's potentially more of a human cost at stake.
As you seem to be sticking up for dripford can you tell me the logic in not allowing fans to local sport?
I can go to my local club and watch live games on TV and watch the local team from inside the club with other fans
crowded by the window but cannot go the other side of the window to watch them outside in the fresh air!!
It has nothing to do with economy just he needs to be seen to do something different to Westminster.
Wed Dec 22, 2021 12:21 pm
Wed Dec 22, 2021 12:28 pm
Floppsy wrote:aber blue wrote:Floppsy wrote:piledriver64 wrote:Floppsy wrote:Politicians throughout the pandemic have either been criticised for not acting soon enough, or waiting too long before making a decision.
They can't win.
Agreed. If Drakeford, by making these decisions, can remove the restrictions earlier and avoid huge pressure on the NHS then he will be proved right and despite our moans about football, clubs, etc., it would be hard to criticise. Although he will also have to deliver on the booster program too as that is the ultimate solution accepted by scientists and all UK leaders.
Similarly, if Boris is able to hold back the pressure on NHS by keeping things as they are for now then he will be proved right. In any event, I think Boris will be introducing similar restrictions to Wales after Christmas if he can get it through Parliament.
The one thing Boris can't now do is hide behind the "I listen to the science" argument.
Science is telling us to act now to avoid pain later the only mitigation against that, accepted by scientists in the main, is that scientists don't have to take into account the socio-economic factors into account when giving their advice. These are now clearly political decisions with a bit of advice from scientists behind them.
Personally I think we should learn from what happened after the Liverpool Champions League game and Cheltenham right at the start of the pandemic and act early. I may be proved wrong on that but it will be interesting to see which approach proves most successful in stalling the progress of this new variant.
If Mark Drakeford is proved wrong by acting too early then the costs are more economic. If Boris Johnson is proved wrong for waiting then there's potentially more of a human cost at stake.
As you seem to be sticking up for dripford can you tell me the logic in not allowing fans to local sport?
I can go to my local club and watch live games on TV and watch the local team from inside the club with other fans
crowded by the window but cannot go the other side of the window to watch them outside in the fresh air!!
It has nothing to do with economy just he needs to be seen to do something different to Westminster.
If it's table service only you won't be able to crowd by the window.(not saying it won't happen though).
I'm not trying to defend him, I'm trying to defend some of the logic behind his actions and decisions. Local sport is an odd one though I'll grant you that. He could have done better in saying that these specific restrictions will be looked at each week and be eased at the earliest opportunity. Instead he hasn't put a time limit on them.
Wed Dec 22, 2021 12:28 pm
piledriver64 wrote:castleblue wrote:piledriver64 wrote:Floppsy wrote:Politicians throughout the pandemic have either been criticised for not acting soon enough, or waiting too long before making a decision.
They can't win.
Agreed. If Drakeford, by making these decisions, can remove the restrictions earlier and avoid huge pressure on the NHS then he will be proved right and despite our moans about football, clubs, etc., it would be hard to criticise. Although he will also have to deliver on the booster program too as that is the ultimate solution accepted by scientists and all UK leaders.
Similarly, if Boris is able to hold back the pressure on NHS by keeping things as they are for now then he will be proved right. In any event, I think Boris will be introducing similar restrictions to Wales after Christmas if he can get it through Parliament.
The one thing Boris can't now do is hide behind the "I listen to the science" argument.
Science is telling us to act now to avoid pain later the only mitigation against that, accepted by scientists in the main, is that scientists don't have to take into account the socio-economic factors into account when giving their advice. These are now clearly political decisions with a bit of advice from scientists behind them.
Personally I think we should learn from what happened after the Liverpool Champions League game and Cheltenham right at the start of the pandemic and act early. I may be proved wrong on that but it will be interesting to see which approach proves most successful in stalling the progress of this new variant.
You make a great point there "If he can get it through Parliament" and of course you are talking about the Prime Minister and the Westminster Parliament.
Mr Drakeford and his looney left cronies are at this moment just dishing out dictates with NO scrutiny from the Senedd. Following a request by the Welsh Conservatives the Senedd has been recalled today to discuss these dictates raining out of Drakeford House, but unlike the UK Prime Minister NO vote will take place.
The UK Health Security Agency, who are monitoring this Omicron effect on the UK, are finding exactly the same as South Africa i.e. increased infection rates but mainly mild symptoms and fewer people being admitted to hospital. In fact in London over the weekend over 50% of people admitted to hospital were found to be omicron positive on admittance for other conditions. In ICU beds in London 9 out of 10 beds yesterday were occupied by unvaccinated.
I accept it's early days but the latest dictates from Mr Drakeford on the working from home, £60 fines and criminal offence, with NO scrutiny from the Senedd can hardly be called Democratic.
![]()
I am no "Dripford" defender but on this I'm not sure he's done much wrong. His government are a majority government and everything has been voted through, still all within the rules of the Welsh Government. The Sennedd has been recalled so your point about "NO srutiny" is incorrect.
Boris hasn't been able to hold his party together, hence him having to delay until the stats are unarguable, which many people would say is too late.
Wed Dec 22, 2021 1:08 pm
Wed Dec 22, 2021 2:02 pm
Wed Dec 22, 2021 2:27 pm
Jestrix wrote:Numbers ARE low currently in hospital, the issue is they could and probably will raise as time goes on. Already wards are running on low staffing levels due to Omnicron apparently bypassing the jabs which means patient care could be jeopardised. WAST are expecting a huge increase in cases over the next 4-6 weeks but are expecting numbers to decrease just as fast due to the lesser symptoms.
Wed Dec 22, 2021 2:54 pm
Wed Dec 22, 2021 2:59 pm
piledriver64 wrote:Floppsy wrote:Politicians throughout the pandemic have either been criticised for not acting soon enough, or waiting too long before making a decision.
They can't win.
Agreed. If Drakeford, by making these decisions, can remove the restrictions earlier and avoid huge pressure on the NHS then he will be proved right and despite our moans about football, clubs, etc., it would be hard to criticise. Although he will also have to deliver on the booster program too as that is the ultimate solution accepted by scientists and all UK leaders.
Similarly, if Boris is able to hold back the pressure on NHS by keeping things as they are for now then he will be proved right. In any event, I think Boris will be introducing similar restrictions to Wales after Christmas if he can get it through Parliament.
The one thing Boris can't now do is hide behind the "I listen to the science" argument.
Science is telling us to act now to avoid pain later the only mitigation against that, accepted by scientists in the main, is that scientists don't have to take into account the socio-economic factors into account when giving their advice. These are now clearly political decisions with a bit of advice from scientists behind them.
Personally I think we should learn from what happened after the Liverpool Champions League game and Cheltenham right at the start of the pandemic and act early. I may be proved wrong on that but it will be interesting to see which approach proves most successful in stalling the progress of this new variant.
Wed Dec 22, 2021 3:07 pm
piledriver64 wrote:castleblue wrote:piledriver64 wrote:Floppsy wrote:Politicians throughout the pandemic have either been criticised for not acting soon enough, or waiting too long before making a decision.
They can't win.
Agreed. If Drakeford, by making these decisions, can remove the restrictions earlier and avoid huge pressure on the NHS then he will be proved right and despite our moans about football, clubs, etc., it would be hard to criticise. Although he will also have to deliver on the booster program too as that is the ultimate solution accepted by scientists and all UK leaders.
Similarly, if Boris is able to hold back the pressure on NHS by keeping things as they are for now then he will be proved right. In any event, I think Boris will be introducing similar restrictions to Wales after Christmas if he can get it through Parliament.
The one thing Boris can't now do is hide behind the "I listen to the science" argument.
Science is telling us to act now to avoid pain later the only mitigation against that, accepted by scientists in the main, is that scientists don't have to take into account the socio-economic factors into account when giving their advice. These are now clearly political decisions with a bit of advice from scientists behind them.
Personally I think we should learn from what happened after the Liverpool Champions League game and Cheltenham right at the start of the pandemic and act early. I may be proved wrong on that but it will be interesting to see which approach proves most successful in stalling the progress of this new variant.
You make a great point there "If he can get it through Parliament" and of course you are talking about the Prime Minister and the Westminster Parliament.
Mr Drakeford and his looney left cronies are at this moment just dishing out dictates with NO scrutiny from the Senedd. Following a request by the Welsh Conservatives the Senedd has been recalled today to discuss these dictates raining out of Drakeford House, but unlike the UK Prime Minister NO vote will take place.
The UK Health Security Agency, who are monitoring this Omicron effect on the UK, are finding exactly the same as South Africa i.e. increased infection rates but mainly mild symptoms and fewer people being admitted to hospital. In fact in London over the weekend over 50% of people admitted to hospital were found to be omicron positive on admittance for other conditions. In ICU beds in London 9 out of 10 beds yesterday were occupied by unvaccinated.
I accept it's early days but the latest dictates from Mr Drakeford on the working from home, £60 fines and criminal offence, with NO scrutiny from the Senedd can hardly be called Democratic.
![]()
I am no "Dripford" defender but on this I'm not sure he's done much wrong. His government are a majority government and everything has been voted through, still all within the rules of the Welsh Government. The Sennedd has been recalled so your point about "NO srutiny" is incorrect.
Boris hasn't been able to hold his party together, hence him having to delay until the stats are unarguable, which many people would say is too late.
Wed Dec 22, 2021 7:18 pm