Wed Apr 28, 2021 6:11 am
Forever Blue wrote:boyo1927 wrote:Is it me.or has reserve team football as I used to know it have alot.more focus than before. Agree results like this are terrible but never known a season when so much focus is put on the reserves and youth....
The last 3 -4 seasons we have put every result out from both due to a lot of interest and also due to the CCFC Committee continuing to tell the media about how good the set up is now and that we have the best groups of footballers coming through for years .
There was also a more interest as well when Craig Bellamy was out in charge of the Accademy.
The CCFC Committee about 5 years ago put out bug stories on the Accademy so of course we have followed them more.
Personally I have always been interested in the local talent coming through![]()
![]()
Wed Apr 28, 2021 8:39 am
Wed Apr 28, 2021 8:50 am
bluesince62 wrote:ted wrote:piledriver64 wrote:ted wrote:Very concerning, still not producing enough players from the Academy, not even asking for stars, just good enough for Championship level
Up until this season you have a good point. However, have you forgotten that Bagen, Sang, Colwell and Brown have all broken into the first team this season !? Harris has also played although I’m yet to be convinced by him.
It doesn’t excuse the previous 10 years but does demonstrate that we’re, hopefully, finally getting it right.
We won’t always get 4 breakthroughs in one season but one or two is what we could expect.
As for this result, take all those I’ve mentioned out of the U23 starting eleven and surely it’s no surprise if they get hammered ? That’s just how it goes at that level.
Mate, Bagen came through Southampton academy, Sang through Bolton and Manchester united's and never joines us till he was 21 or 22 years old , Brown Wealdstones and played 48 first team appearances for them, he is 23 now. Harris no manger seems to want,
Colwell is the the magic kid, took 10 plus years to get a player through, we shall hopefully see more of him first![]()
It matters not where they come from, they have obviously improved since arriving here!! Enough to have broken into a championship side, where they were at lower league standard before?
Another dig at our academy, why people expect stacks of young stars to roll off the line,I dont know? But we have some youngsters coming through,whereas before they were deemed not good enough by previous managers? Lets just get behind those who are making their way with us.results are poor admittedly,but we are not world beaters,even at 1st team level.
Wed Apr 28, 2021 9:05 am
Wed Apr 28, 2021 9:19 am
Wed Apr 28, 2021 9:35 am
Escott1927 wrote:Colwill came up through the academy and looks like he'll be a squad player next season. Bagan was signed for the academy and will probably be our first choice LB in the next season or 2. Sang was signed for the academy and will probably be a squad player next season. Same as brown. Thats more than weve seen in a good few years. Surely that shows the academy is doing better? It was never going to be a quick fix and turnaround.
Wed Apr 28, 2021 9:44 am
ted wrote:Escott1927 wrote:Colwill came up through the academy and looks like he'll be a squad player next season. Bagan was signed for the academy and will probably be our first choice LB in the next season or 2. Sang was signed for the academy and will probably be a squad player next season. Same as brown. Thats more than weve seen in a good few years. Surely that shows the academy is doing better? It was never going to be a quick fix and turnaround.
Mate Colwill is the only actual City academy player to come through and has had one game, played alright, gave his all and we all want him to make it![]()
![]()
Bagen came through Southampton's academy, Sang through Bolton and Manchester united's and never joined us till he was 21 or 22 years old , Brown Wealdstones and played 48 first team appearances for them, he is 23 now. They are not our academy players they are other clubs.
Players joining us at 20,21 and 22 years old how can you call them our academy players ?
Tom Sang began his career with Bolton Wanderers before signing for Manchester United in 2015 after a successful trial. In January 2019, Sang joined AFC Fylde on loan for the remainder of the 2018–19 season. He was released by Manchester United in 2019, subsequently signing for Cardiff City after a trial period at the age of 20 years old. Sang is 22 years old next month.
I am looking to Colwill, Davies and Evans to make it, they are our academy players![]()
Wed Apr 28, 2021 10:04 am
ted wrote:Escott1927 wrote:Colwill came up through the academy and looks like he'll be a squad player next season. Bagan was signed for the academy and will probably be our first choice LB in the next season or 2. Sang was signed for the academy and will probably be a squad player next season. Same as brown. Thats more than weve seen in a good few years. Surely that shows the academy is doing better? It was never going to be a quick fix and turnaround.
Mate Colwill is the only actual City academy player to come through and has had one game, played alright, gave his all and we all want him to make it![]()
![]()
Bagen came through Southampton's academy, Sang through Bolton and Manchester united's and never joined us till he was 21 or 22 years old , Brown Wealdstones and played 48 first team appearances for them, he is 23 now. They are not our academy players they are other clubs.
Players joining us at 20,21 and 22 years old how can you call them our academy players ?
Tom Sang began his career with Bolton Wanderers before signing for Manchester United in 2015 after a successful trial. In January 2019, Sang joined AFC Fylde on loan for the remainder of the 2018–19 season. He was released by Manchester United in 2019, subsequently signing for Cardiff City after a trial period at the age of 20 years old. Sang is 22 years old next month.
I am looking to Colwill, Davies and Evans to make it, they are our academy players![]()
Wed Apr 28, 2021 10:28 am
ted wrote:piledriver64 wrote:ted wrote:Very concerning, still not producing enough players from the Academy, not even asking for stars, just good enough for Championship level
Up until this season you have a good point. However, have you forgotten that Bagen, Sang, Colwell and Brown have all broken into the first team this season !? Harris has also played although I’m yet to be convinced by him.
It doesn’t excuse the previous 10 years but does demonstrate that we’re, hopefully, finally getting it right.
We won’t always get 4 breakthroughs in one season but one or two is what we could expect.
As for this result, take all those I’ve mentioned out of the U23 starting eleven and surely it’s no surprise if they get hammered ? That’s just how it goes at that level.
Mate, Bagen came through Southampton academy, Sang through Bolton and Manchester united's and never joines us till he was 21 or 22 years old , Brown Wealdstones and played 48 first team appearances for them, he is 23 now. Harris no manger seems to want,
Colwell is the the magic kid, took 10 plus years to get a player through, we shall hopefully see more of him first![]()
Wed Apr 28, 2021 10:43 am
Wed Apr 28, 2021 11:35 am
Crayfish wrote:One bad defeat amongst a series of generally good results doesn't mean anything really. We lost 5-0 to Sheffield Wednesday recently and after that they have lost virtually all their games and we haven't. Don't read too much into one result.
Wed Apr 28, 2021 12:07 pm
piledriver64 wrote:ted wrote:piledriver64 wrote:ted wrote:Very concerning, still not producing enough players from the Academy, not even asking for stars, just good enough for Championship level
Up until this season you have a good point. However, have you forgotten that Bagen, Sang, Colwell and Brown have all broken into the first team this season !? Harris has also played although I’m yet to be convinced by him.
It doesn’t excuse the previous 10 years but does demonstrate that we’re, hopefully, finally getting it right.
We won’t always get 4 breakthroughs in one season but one or two is what we could expect.
As for this result, take all those I’ve mentioned out of the U23 starting eleven and surely it’s no surprise if they get hammered ? That’s just how it goes at that level.
Mate, Bagen came through Southampton academy, Sang through Bolton and Manchester united's and never joines us till he was 21 or 22 years old , Brown Wealdstones and played 48 first team appearances for them, he is 23 now. Harris no manger seems to want,
Colwell is the the magic kid, took 10 plus years to get a player through, we shall hopefully see more of him first![]()
But that’s what most clubs do.
Man City took Matondo off us and sold him for £10m.
The Prem clubs academies have kids signed from other clubs all over the world !
It’s about how the academies develop that talent and our academy looks like it’s finally got it’s act together.
Wed Apr 28, 2021 2:47 pm
piledriver64 wrote:ted wrote:piledriver64 wrote:ted wrote:Very concerning, still not producing enough players from the Academy, not even asking for stars, just good enough for Championship level
Up until this season you have a good point. However, have you forgotten that Bagen, Sang, Colwell and Brown have all broken into the first team this season !? Harris has also played although I’m yet to be convinced by him.
It doesn’t excuse the previous 10 years but does demonstrate that we’re, hopefully, finally getting it right.
We won’t always get 4 breakthroughs in one season but one or two is what we could expect.
As for this result, take all those I’ve mentioned out of the U23 starting eleven and surely it’s no surprise if they get hammered ? That’s just how it goes at that level.
Mate, Bagen came through Southampton academy, Sang through Bolton and Manchester united's and never joines us till he was 21 or 22 years old , Brown Wealdstones and played 48 first team appearances for them, he is 23 now. Harris no manger seems to want,
Colwell is the the magic kid, took 10 plus years to get a player through, we shall hopefully see more of him first![]()
But that’s what most clubs do.
Man City took Matondo off us and sold him for £10m.
The Prem clubs academies have kids signed from other clubs all over the world !
It’s about how the academies develop that talent and our academy looks like it’s finally got it’s act together.
Wed Apr 28, 2021 4:31 pm
skidemin wrote:piledriver64 wrote:ted wrote:piledriver64 wrote:ted wrote:Very concerning, still not producing enough players from the Academy, not even asking for stars, just good enough for Championship level
Up until this season you have a good point. However, have you forgotten that Bagen, Sang, Colwell and Brown have all broken into the first team this season !? Harris has also played although I’m yet to be convinced by him.
It doesn’t excuse the previous 10 years but does demonstrate that we’re, hopefully, finally getting it right.
We won’t always get 4 breakthroughs in one season but one or two is what we could expect.
As for this result, take all those I’ve mentioned out of the U23 starting eleven and surely it’s no surprise if they get hammered ? That’s just how it goes at that level.
Mate, Bagen came through Southampton academy, Sang through Bolton and Manchester united's and never joines us till he was 21 or 22 years old , Brown Wealdstones and played 48 first team appearances for them, he is 23 now. Harris no manger seems to want,
Colwell is the the magic kid, took 10 plus years to get a player through, we shall hopefully see more of him first![]()
But that’s what most clubs do.
Man City took Matondo off us and sold him for £10m.
The Prem clubs academies have kids signed from other clubs all over the world !
It’s about how the academies develop that talent and our academy looks like it’s finally got it’s act together.
i honestly do not see how under 23 football is included when talking about academies.... these boys { its not unusual to see a few experienced 30 year old boys playing } are adults whether they came through our age groups or came from other clubs...
the under 23s is more akin to a reserve team than part of an academy...
Thu Apr 29, 2021 1:33 pm
Forever Blue wrote:skidemin wrote:piledriver64 wrote:ted wrote:piledriver64 wrote:ted wrote:Very concerning, still not producing enough players from the Academy, not even asking for stars, just good enough for Championship level
Up until this season you have a good point. However, have you forgotten that Bagen, Sang, Colwell and Brown have all broken into the first team this season !? Harris has also played although I’m yet to be convinced by him.
It doesn’t excuse the previous 10 years but does demonstrate that we’re, hopefully, finally getting it right.
We won’t always get 4 breakthroughs in one season but one or two is what we could expect.
As for this result, take all those I’ve mentioned out of the U23 starting eleven and surely it’s no surprise if they get hammered ? That’s just how it goes at that level.
Mate, Bagen came through Southampton academy, Sang through Bolton and Manchester united's and never joines us till he was 21 or 22 years old , Brown Wealdstones and played 48 first team appearances for them, he is 23 now. Harris no manger seems to want,
Colwell is the the magic kid, took 10 plus years to get a player through, we shall hopefully see more of him first![]()
But that’s what most clubs do.
Man City took Matondo off us and sold him for £10m.
The Prem clubs academies have kids signed from other clubs all over the world !
It’s about how the academies develop that talent and our academy looks like it’s finally got it’s act together.
i honestly do not see how under 23 football is included when talking about academies.... these boys { its not unusual to see a few experienced 30 year old boys playing } are adults whether they came through our age groups or came from other clubs...
the under 23s is more akin to a reserve team than part of an academy...
Absolutely spot on![]()
Common sense at last .
They are 100% not Academy players and U23’s has some how been twisted in to making fans believe it.
They are trying to make out we are producing these lads Tom Sang / Ciaron Brown when they’ve joined us at ages 21 & 22, it’s madness.
Glen Williams may as well work for Tan & the Committee.
U23’s is a reserve team that our players who need to keep fit or comeback from injuries and its been over the last few years made very much competitive with promotions to higher reserve leagues etc![]()
When you join a club at 18,20,21 and 22 you’ve already been through other clubs Academies.
The Under 23's was called that instead of the reserve team or combination team to try bring on more British players, the original idea and make these games / leagues more competitive, so players not in the first team were kept fitter and challenging more and more meaningful games, nothing to do with our academy.![]()
Thu Apr 29, 2021 2:06 pm
piledriver64 wrote:Forever Blue wrote:skidemin wrote:piledriver64 wrote:ted wrote:piledriver64 wrote:ted wrote:Very concerning, still not producing enough players from the Academy, not even asking for stars, just good enough for Championship level
Up until this season you have a good point. However, have you forgotten that Bagen, Sang, Colwell and Brown have all broken into the first team this season !? Harris has also played although I’m yet to be convinced by him.
It doesn’t excuse the previous 10 years but does demonstrate that we’re, hopefully, finally getting it right.
We won’t always get 4 breakthroughs in one season but one or two is what we could expect.
As for this result, take all those I’ve mentioned out of the U23 starting eleven and surely it’s no surprise if they get hammered ? That’s just how it goes at that level.
Mate, Bagen came through Southampton academy, Sang through Bolton and Manchester united's and never joines us till he was 21 or 22 years old , Brown Wealdstones and played 48 first team appearances for them, he is 23 now. Harris no manger seems to want,
Colwell is the the magic kid, took 10 plus years to get a player through, we shall hopefully see more of him first![]()
But that’s what most clubs do.
Man City took Matondo off us and sold him for £10m.
The Prem clubs academies have kids signed from other clubs all over the world !
It’s about how the academies develop that talent and our academy looks like it’s finally got it’s act together.
i honestly do not see how under 23 football is included when talking about academies.... these boys { its not unusual to see a few experienced 30 year old boys playing } are adults whether they came through our age groups or came from other clubs...
the under 23s is more akin to a reserve team than part of an academy...
Absolutely spot on![]()
Common sense at last .
They are 100% not Academy players and U23’s has some how been twisted in to making fans believe it.
They are trying to make out we are producing these lads Tom Sang / Ciaron Brown when they’ve joined us at ages 21 & 22, it’s madness.
Glen Williams may as well work for Tan & the Committee.
U23’s is a reserve team that our players who need to keep fit or comeback from injuries and its been over the last few years made very much competitive with promotions to higher reserve leagues etc![]()
When you join a club at 18,20,21 and 22 you’ve already been through other clubs Academies.
The Under 23's was called that instead of the reserve team or combination team to try bring on more British players, the original idea and make these games / leagues more competitive, so players not in the first team were kept fitter and challenging more and more meaningful games, nothing to do with our academy.![]()
But the description of “academy products” is not something that our club has made up. You’re having a pop at our club when it’s something that every club does so why shouldn’t we ?
When Man City sold Matondo he was described as their academy product. Same as the kid that Utd nicked from our academy (forgotten his name).
Look at all the top clubs and when you actually delve deeper players from “their academies” often started out at other clubs, signing young players from other clubs is just part of that type of set-up.
The key step in development is that final transition into the first team so surely we all have to acknowledge that whatever we have done wrong in the past we seem to be getting it right now.