Sun Aug 08, 2010 8:53 am
Sun Aug 08, 2010 9:28 am
FblockFrank wrote:
If the book says your blue badge is not valid then it's as simple as that. The law made the law it should stand. If one is allowed to get away with it they had just as well scap it. But I,m sorry as to how it may affect you but we as residents have our rights to.
Sun Aug 08, 2010 9:40 am
Tony Blue Williams wrote:FblockFrank wrote:
If the book says your blue badge is not valid then it's as simple as that. The law made the law it should stand. If one is allowed to get away with it they had just as well scap it. But I,m sorry as to how it may affect you but we as residents have our rights to.
Sorry Frank you are way off there mate. The Disability Discrimination Act makes it unlawful for anyone to treat a disabled person less favourably than an able bodied person. There are various parts to the act but part 3 makes it a civil offence to deny provision of goods and services to the disabled on the grounds of their disablity.
It doesn't matter if the 'service' (in this case the issuing of a residential parking permit) is for monitary value or not. The discrimination can be direct (a complete ban on disabled parking) or indirect (the issuing of limited parking permits which exclude disabled drivers who do-not live in the area). IMO what we are talking about is the latter indirect discrimination.
The law is quite clear and has been tested many times, any clause in a contract or direction by an institution which by it nature results in discrimination of any kind is deemed as void.
It would be my opinion that the instructions on page 9 do exactly that and are therefore invalid.
TBH any resident who tries to deny a disabled driver parking rights for their own selfish agenda, is 'frankly' not a very nice person.
Sun Aug 08, 2010 1:15 pm
Sun Aug 08, 2010 6:07 pm
Tony Blue Williams wrote:I once questioned a traffic warden about parking my car and displaying a blue badge in a permit only public road. He responded by saying even though the handbooks tell you your blue badge is not valid, they are wary of booking cars that display blue badges because one day the disabled driver will challenge its legality in the courts.
Secretly they accept that you can't get a more blatant example of disability discrimination. This is because a traffic warden/council would be treating a disabled driver less favourably by penalising them for parking on the same road as an able bodied resident who has been issued with a permit.
I’m not saying that you won’t ]get booked because of this, but if you did I would certainly challenge the ticket on the grounds of disability discrimination and point out that the handbook rule does-not override the law of the land.
Sun Aug 08, 2010 6:21 pm
FblockFrank wrote:Tony Blue Williams wrote:FblockFrank wrote:
If the book says your blue badge is not valid then it's as simple as that. The law made the law it should stand. If one is allowed to get away with it they had just as well scap it. But I,m sorry as to how it may affect you but we as residents have our rights to.
Sorry Frank you are way off there mate. The Disability Discrimination Act makes it unlawful for anyone to treat a disabled person less favourably than an able bodied person. There are various parts to the act but part 3 makes it a civil offence to deny provision of goods and services to the disabled on the grounds of their disablity.
It doesn't matter if the 'service' (in this case the issuing of a residential parking permit) is for monitary value or not. The discrimination can be direct (a complete ban on disabled parking) or indirect (the issuing of limited parking permits which exclude disabled drivers who do-not live in the area). IMO what we are talking about is the latter indirect discrimination.
The law is quite clear and has been tested many times, any clause in a contract or direction by an institution which by it nature results in discrimination of any kind is deemed as void.
It would be my opinion that the instructions on page 9 do exactly that and are therefore invalid.
TBH any resident who tries to deny a disabled driver parking rights for their own selfish agenda, is 'frankly' not a very nice person.
Look it like this then. If they do park opposite my drive on double yellows, and they do, It means I can't get my car in or out. Also I think a lot of you have got the wrong end of the stick on this one. I have only been telling people about the new parking laws this area but if the do obstruct my drive or make it difficult for people to turn there cars around in the culdesac the residents will do all they can to get the car removed and that means you as well.
Sun Aug 08, 2010 6:27 pm
CayoBluebird wrote:Tony Blue Williams wrote:I once questioned a traffic warden about parking my car and displaying a blue badge in a permit only public road. He responded by saying even though the handbooks tell you your blue badge is not valid, they are wary of booking cars that display blue badges because one day the disabled driver will challenge its legality in the courts.
Secretly they accept that you can't get a more blatant example of disability discrimination. This is because a traffic warden/council would be treating a disabled driver less favourably by penalising them for parking on the same road as an able bodied resident who has been issued with a permit.
I’m not saying that you won’t ]get booked because of this, but if you did I would certainly challenge the ticket on the grounds of disability discrimination and point out that the handbook rule does-not override the law of the land.
But they are not being discrimated against in the exmaple you gave, and even if you want to consider it discrimination it is not on the grounds of their disability so it couldnt be challenged in court on those grounds.
Sun Aug 08, 2010 6:53 pm
Sun Aug 08, 2010 9:02 pm
Wed Aug 11, 2010 3:01 pm
Mon Nov 01, 2010 5:42 am
Mon Nov 01, 2010 6:57 am
Mon Nov 01, 2010 7:37 am
Mon Nov 01, 2010 7:46 am
FblockFrank wrote:If you get down early enough the back of tesco's in canton, when I say early about 2 hours B4 the game, there are a few car parks in and around canton, and theres Bessamer road but early is the key.
Mon Nov 01, 2010 8:22 am
sleepwalker wrote:Cardiff has got its own bye laws.
E.g. in Cardiff you have to park so many metres off a junction.
That's a bye law. In Cwmbran there is no such law.
So you might well be right about page 9 in the blue badge book.
However I'd say check with the traffic warden as well.
There might well be a bye law in Cardiff allowing blue badge holders to park
In the permit bays,
Mon Nov 01, 2010 8:31 am