Gary Medel proved tonight

He is a quality player have said that from day one. Yes, he started well then tailed off towards the end of the season, but he didnt have the quality around him. Whittingham and other midfield players hatdly helped him in midfield at all, it was always left for Medel to do. He is so more effective and influential playing with better players for a better team. Personally, i hope that we loan him out for the season and WHEN we get promoted again he can come back. Or if we receive a bid equal or greater than the price that we paid for him, then i would sell him. Some people on here have said that we may be willing to accept £6m for him, however the way he is playing in the World Cup then i cannot see us letting him leave for anything under £10m. I'm pretty sure that after the World Cup is over, there will be a whole host of Big European Clubs interested in buying him from us.

Bloooooobirds.

If Gary Medel signs for a team that qualifies for the Champions League group stage I will not post on here for a whole month, anyone care to bet against me?

Football fans are so fickle

Lets forget the 38 game season he just had or the very average game last week, he was good today so he must be awesome

And Martyn Ryan jnr using it to prop up his ridiculous opinion that you must be class if you play well at the world cup is bizarre, im sure Real Madrid were hammering down Diouf's door

Hes average, available for average money and only average clubs want him - average.

Can't wait to hear Roathie's opinion now.

Medel and every Chilean played superbly tonight.

Look above, the fact you think its changed or should have changed due to one good game proves exactly what ive just said

Fickle.

Still does not alter my opinion of his season with us.

Considering all the stories about him being a battler, pitbull and all that nonsence, I never seen much of it in the last 2-3 months of the season.As for the start of the season I dont think he done his job totally there either.He was bought as a defensive midfielder to break up attacks, but he did not do enough of that for me.He played well in our first 15 games then seemed to tire quickly, maybe the pace of the premiership caught him out.He was good on the ball and kept possession well, allthough he never made many killer passes,Something McPhail used to get murdered for.If we can get our money back or somewhere near it id move him on now coz his heart wont be here after the world cup.

If Gary Medel signs for a team that qualifies for the Champions League group stage I will not post on here for a whole month, anyone care to bet against me?

You sound just like roathie. Hmmmm

Of course he does, he is sensible.

Of course he does, he is sensible.

Im thinking he's just as much a whopper as you. Unless of course it is actually you. Not like you dont have form eh.

Of course he does, he is sensible.

Im thinking he's just as much a whopper as you. Unless of course it is actually you. Not like you dont have form eh.

Form for what?

And of course you think he is a whopper, he is talking sense. Just like I was supposedly a whopper for saying Cornelius was a waste of money. Silly me eh?

Whopper

He was an absolute failure at Cardiff so what the hell does it matter if he plays well for his country. Just goes to show he is patriotic and when he puts the effort in he can be a good player. Sadly for us he couldn't be fucked and the fat b*stard was fucked after 20 minutes.

One word for you "IDIOT"

Do you think he had a good season for us? Yes or no?

Regardless of whether or not he is playing well for Chile he had a terrible season for us and that's all that matters. People licked his arse because he had tough guy image (No evidence of that), a foreign name and a big transfer fee. He was shite end of.

Yeah, because we did SO well when he didn't play.

Anyone with any sense could see he was carrying us.

He was superb until he got injured and then he came back too early and struggled for 6-8 games before finally giving in when we were down.

Maybe there are a few of our fans who can't remember back before Christmas.

By the way, nothing to do with a 'hard man' image -if anything that worried me, but he did well, controlled his aggression and didn't get sent off or suspended. Just the fact he was the only player in our side who could both win the ball and retain it.

THIS. Couldn't agree more.

Of course he does, he is sensible.

Im thinking he's just as much a whopper as you. Unless of course it is actually you. Not like you dont have form eh.

Form for what?

And of course you think he is a whopper, he is talking sense. Just like I was supposedly a whopper for saying Cornelius was a waste of money. Silly me eh?

Whopper

Cornelius was the biggest waste of money in the history of CCFC. Doesnt automatically mean your right about everything else just because you called it.

In fact, looking back on the thread where every medel game was tracked - his ratings didnt fluctuate that much from beginning of season to end. He was never carrying anyone or anything (apart from too much weight). He had a good game against Fulham away and against Swansea home - he dined out on that for the rest of the season at the pleasure of the fickle fans seeing what they wanted to see.

Thats the truth of the matter.

It was a season to forget. In more ways than one.

It was a season to forget. In more ways than one.

Thats the point. Everyone wants to forget the average or crap games and count the good ones and use that as the barometer of his ability. The fact the good games were in a ridiculous minority seems by the by with some. If we did that with everyone then Peter crouch would be the best striker in world football, he isnt of course because for every good game he has about 20 average/crap ones.

As i said, people see what they want to see.

It was a season to forget. In more ways than one.

Thats the point. Everyone wants to forget the average or crap games and count the good ones and use that as the barometer of his ability. The fact the good games were in a ridiculous minority seems by the by with some. If we did that with everyone then Peter crouch would be the best striker in world football, he isnt of course because for every good game he has about 20 average/crap ones.

As i said, people see what they want to see.

Just the same as some people dont see what they dont want to see.

I see every game i can and base it over ALL of them. The stats, including OPTA stats which most Premier League managers use in team and performance analysis.... also back up my view

Football fans are so fickle

Lets forget the 38 game season he just had or the very average game last week, he was good today so he must be awesome

And Martyn Ryan jnr using it to prop up his ridiculous opinion that you must be class if you play well at the world cup is bizarre, im sure Real Madrid were hammering down Diouf's door

Hes average, available for average money and only average clubs want him - average.

Love seeing you go on the defensive when you're proved wrong

Love seeing you go on the defensive when you're proved wrong

not this idiot again.

Where was i proved wrong then? Are you suggesting because he had one good game it means he is brilliant? And dont blame "only fishing" this time

holy smokes i love this forum

I see every game i can and base it over ALL of them. The stats, including OPTA stats which most Premier League managers use in team and performance analysis.... also back up my view

You rely on stats, i get it. It makes up for your lack of football knowledge. Its understandable why your so reliant on stats. Its ok. Dont gettoo upset about it.

I see every game i can and base it over ALL of them. The stats, including OPTA stats which most Premier League managers use in team and performance analysis.... also back up my view

You rely on stats, i get it. It makes up for your lack of football knowledge. Its understandable why your so reliant on stats. Its ok. Dont gettoo upset about it.

if all else fails resort to playground nonsense, beats the old "fishing" cop out i guess

Silly Arsene Wenger and Brendan Rodgers using stats for performance analysis, clueless men. Someone needs to tell them to judge things they have never seen, apparently cardiff (really) daft says its better

Love seeing you go on the defensive when you're proved wrong

not this idiot again.

Where was i proved wrong then? Are you suggesting because he had one good game it means he is brilliant? And dont blame "only fishing" this time

holy smokes i love this forum

The Bony thing I was winding you up, he had a relatively poor game against Japan in my opinion, so I posted about it, you bit about him being class last year (which i actually agree with really) but since I knew you would keep taking my point about him being shite against Japan back to last season's form, just thought I'd let you keep biting by disagreeing with everything you said, you've done it to others enough times, thought you would have clocked.

As for Medel, well what else can I say. He's proving my exact point that when playing with better players, his quality comes through.

I see every game i can and base it over ALL of them. The stats, including OPTA stats which most Premier League managers use in team and performance analysis.... also back up my view

You rely on stats, i get it. It makes up for your lack of football knowledge. Its understandable why your so reliant on stats. Its ok. Dont gettoo upset about it.

Ask him to prove the stats he quotes too, that's always fun.

I see every game i can and base it over ALL of them. The stats, including OPTA stats which most Premier League managers use in team and performance analysis.... also back up my view

You rely on stats, i get it. It makes up for your lack of football knowledge. Its understandable why your so reliant on stats. Its ok. Dont gettoo upset about it.

if all else fails resort to playground nonsense, beats the old "fishing" cop out i guess

Silly Arsene Wenger and Brendan Rodgers using stats for performance analysis, clueless men. Someone needs to tell them to judge things they have never seen, apparently cardiff (really) daft says its better

Playground nonsense. Im deadly serious. Without stats you'd be fucked.

Stats are just one part of it. There is more to it than that. Arsense & Brendan can see a player playing football with their own eyes and know if he is performing or not. Just because you cant doesnt mean its the same for evryone else.

Love seeing you go on the defensive when you're proved wrong

not this idiot again.

Where was i proved wrong then? Are you suggesting because he had one good game it means he is brilliant? And dont blame "only fishing" this time

holy smokes i love this forum

The Bony thing I was winding you up, he had a relatively poor game against Japan in my opinion, so I posted about it, you bit about him being class last year (which i actually agree with really) but since I knew you would keep taking my point about him being shite against Japan back to last season's form, just thought I'd let you keep biting by disagreeing with everything you said, you've done it to others enough times, thought you would have clocked.

As for Medel, well what else can I say. He's proving my exact point that when playing with better players, his quality comes through.

Im afriad there is no backtracking. You barely mentioned Japan, you said "apart from scoring goals he offres nothing else". You were talking generally. You cant decide whether you want to accept you were being an idiot and incredibly wrong or just trolling, in which case you are.... a troll. Im sure you will come to a decision soon

I post what i feel, if i agree then i will agree, if i dont then i wont. Ridiculous to suggest otherwise. As for Medel - he is proving nothing other than he plays decent for Chile from time to time. If your theory was correct then he wouldnt have only average teams wanting him for such a pittance - he went to you when on the open market remember.

If Gary Medel signs for a team that qualifies for the Champions League group stage I will not post on here for a whole month, anyone care to bet against me?

You sound just like roathie. Hmmmm

He's shite for the money we paid for him, get over it.

Do you think he will be playing champions league next season?

Love seeing you go on the defensive when you're proved wrong

not this idiot again.

Where was i proved wrong then? Are you suggesting because he had one good game it means he is brilliant? And dont blame "only fishing" this time

holy smokes i love this forum

The Bony thing I was winding you up, he had a relatively poor game against Japan in my opinion, so I posted about it, you bit about him being class last year (which i actually agree with really) but since I knew you would keep taking my point about him being shite against Japan back to last season's form, just thought I'd let you keep biting by disagreeing with everything you said, you've done it to others enough times, thought you would have clocked.

As for Medel, well what else can I say. He's proving my exact point that when playing with better players, his quality comes through.

Im afriad there is no backtracking. You barely mentioned Japan, you said "apart from scoring goals he offres nothing else". You were talking generally. You cant decide whether you want to accept you were being an idiot and incredibly wrong or just trolling, in which case you are.... a troll. Im sure you will come to a decision soon

I post what i feel, if i agree then i will agree, if i dont then i wont. Ridiculous to suggest otherwise. As for Medel - he is proving nothing other than he plays decent for Chile from time to time. If your theory was correct then he wouldnt have only average teams wanting him for such a pittance - he went to you when on the open market remember.

Roathie, I've told you what happened, whatever you want to label me as, you do that, unlike others I don't take this forum so seriously that it's gonna keep me awake at night.

It doesn't bother me that you take over threads, that half of what you say is to wind people up yet when it happens to you, you cant accept it, that you post anonymously and post weird videos because you love the attention you get on here. It doesn't bother me because it's just an internet forum ffs. I just feel sorry for you.

And what can I say, we clearly disagree on Medel, even if your theory about him being poor last season is true (which I don't think it is) then how about we look at his whole career instead, where he's been an unquestionable success with better players than Cardiff have.

If Gary Medel signs for a team that qualifies for the Champions League group stage I will not post on here for a whole month, anyone care to bet against me?

You sound just like roathie. Hmmmm

He's shite for the money we paid for him, get over it.

Do you think he will be playing champions league next season?

That depends on if he signs for a team who's in the champions league or not doesnt it. D'uh.

If Gary Medel signs for a team that qualifies for the Champions League group stage I will not post on here for a whole month, anyone care to bet against me?

You sound just like roathie. Hmmmm

He's shite for the money we paid for him, get over it.

Do you think he will be playing champions league next season?

That depends on if he signs for a team who's in the champions league or not doesnt it. D'uh.

Love seeing you go on the defensive when you're proved wrong

not this idiot again.

Where was i proved wrong then? Are you suggesting because he had one good game it means he is brilliant? And dont blame "only fishing" this time

holy smokes i love this forum

The Bony thing I was winding you up, he had a relatively poor game against Japan in my opinion, so I posted about it, you bit about him being class last year (which i actually agree with really) but since I knew you would keep taking my point about him being shite against Japan back to last season's form, just thought I'd let you keep biting by disagreeing with everything you said, you've done it to others enough times, thought you would have clocked.

As for Medel, well what else can I say. He's proving my exact point that when playing with better players, his quality comes through.

Im afriad there is no backtracking. You barely mentioned Japan, you said "apart from scoring goals he offres nothing else". You were talking generally. You cant decide whether you want to accept you were being an idiot and incredibly wrong or just trolling, in which case you are.... a troll. Im sure you will come to a decision soon
]

I post what i feel, if i agree then i will agree, if i dont then i wont. Ridiculous to suggest otherwise. As for Medel - he is proving nothing other than he plays decent for Chile from time to time. If your theory was correct then he wouldnt have only average teams wanting him for such a pittance - he went to you when on the open market remember.

Roathie, I've told you what happened, whatever you want to label me as, you do that, unlike others I don't take this forum so seriously that it's gonna keep me awake at night.

yeah you said you were serious, then fishing, then serious, now trolling. Im not sure which one you have settled on. Im not telling you to take the forum seriously, i just find it odd that you think I should just assume you are being a troll or an idiot. I will take people on face value as thats how I post. [/color

It doesn't bother me that you take over threads, that half of what you say is to wind people up yet when it happens to you, you cant accept it, that you post anonymously and post weird videos because you love the attention you get on here. It doesn't bother me because it's just an internet forum ffs. I just feel sorry for you.

[color=#FF0000] what a silly post. As ive said, if i agree then i will agree, if i dont then i wont. People know im right a scarily large amount of times so when i say something they hope isnt true then they attack it - if thats me taking over threads and winding people up then so be it, at least its the truth. What makes you think you were winding me up by being an idiot on the Bony thread? If someone says 3 + 3 is 9 and I say "no its not" then who is the fool?

Id be more inclined to feel sorry for someone who feels the need to come onto an internet forum to post views that arent his just to try and get a reaction and then assume people should know thats what his intentions are. Bizarre

And what can I say, we clearly disagree on Medel, even if your theory about him being poor last season is true (which I don't think it is) then how about we look at his whole career instead, where he's been an unquestionable success with better players than Cardiff have.

you can doubt anything you like but the facts speak for themselves. As for looking at his whole career - after Sevilla he went to Cardiff, after Cardiff he will go to the likes of Besiktas. Doesnt exactly scream brilliance does it.

If Gary Medel signs for a team that qualifies for the Champions League group stage I will not post on here for a whole month, anyone care to bet against me?

You sound just like roathie. Hmmmm

He's shite for the money we paid for him, get over it.

Do you think he will be playing champions league next season?

That depends on if he signs for a team who's in the champions league or not doesnt it. D'uh.

Innit.