VINCENT TAN - ITS ALL MALKYS FAULT - VIDEO

You have one person handing out a right slating, and another person issuing a public apology. Tan would not be able to publicly criticise Malky in such a manner unless he was in a position to back his comments up should Malky consider he had a claim for libel after Tan's latest outburst. If MM is squeaky clean as suggested by many on this forum, there is no reason why he shouldn't fight back as this is not exactly doing his reputation a lot of good. Tan has messed up by changing to red, but it seems as if Malky has also messed up big time, especially now being publicly accused of almost destroying the club. If Malky remains quiet after this, I think the MM supporters may have to accept that he wasn't completely innocent when he was removed from the club.

A good assessment I would say .....

It's completely true if he did turn down Remy, the useless Scottish c**t

Bang on the money

I blame 75% on Tan and 25% on Malky, A good striker would have got us 6+ points (Like Boni has for the Jacks). But he failed to spend 8mil on a striker, Disgusting.

Well said Vincent Tan.
Malkys a championship manager at best, he squandered millions and layed the foundations for relegation.His and Moody's apology says it all.

Imagine how many players Dave Jones would have bought for £5mil and not a single one would have been a central midfielder.

It's hard to disagree with what he has to say as both MM & IM failed badly in putting together a squad capable of maintaining our PL status. Despite spending £50m.

Malky's fault for losing 4-0 to Hull and Sunderland and 3-0 to Palace and Swansea

Malky's fault for losing 4-0 to Hull and Sunderland and 3-0 to Palace and Swansea

Yes

Malky's fault for losing 4-0 to Hull and Sunderland and 3-0 to Palace and Swansea

Yes

Not really.

I really like Malky and am totally against the rebrand, but Tan does have a point. We paid 8.5 million or whatever it was (and $45,000/week) to a player that a Championship side was looking at bringing in for $500,000. The striking issues were never addressed this season. After 38 games a goal here and a goal there keeps us up, even if we concede as many as we did. Whoever the manager was going to be, it was always going to be tough without a decent goal scorer.

Of course he has a point and i agree with him but hes still a total idiot even his latest thing on converting a little debt if we get back to the prem and a supposed compromise two years on just makes me cringe when it was ALL DEBT TO EQUITY just for turning red we was promised. The mans taking the piss out of us end of

£50 million is a tad more than a little debt. £50 million pounds is 50 MILLION POUNDS. Do you know how much £50 million pounds is? It's a lot of bloody money.

Malky's fault for losing 4-0 to Hull and Sunderland and 3-0 to Palace and Swansea

Yes because he left us without a goal scoring Striker and a leaky defence........

Our £10millions striker was back where he started.....

Malky's fault for losing 4-0 to Hull and Sunderland and 3-0 to Palace and Swansea

Yes because he left us without a goal scoring Striker and a leaky defence........

Our £10millions striker was back where he started.....

What about beating Man City? Swansea? Drawing with United and Everton? Same squad

I really like Malky and am totally against the rebrand, but Tan does have a point. We paid 8.5 million or whatever it was (and $45,000/week) to a player that a Championship side was looking at bringing in for $500,000. The striking issues were never addressed this season. After 38 games a goal here and a goal there keeps us up, even if we concede as many as we did. Whoever the manager was going to be, it was always going to be tough without a decent goal scorer.

Of course he has a point and i agree with him but hes still a total idiot even his latest thing on converting a little debt if we get back to the prem and a supposed compromise two years on just makes me cringe when it was ALL DEBT TO EQUITY just for turning red we was promised. The mans taking the piss out of us end of

£50 million is a tad more than a little debt. £50 million pounds is 50 MILLION POUNDS. Do you know how much £50 million pounds is? It's a lot of bloody money.

It's also not what VT promised when he suggested the rebrand. He's a liar.

Bunch of whining xxxxx - Mackay is a good manager and he would have motivated his players and brought the best out of them. Cornelius was injured and played in total 8 games, some off bench. It was always going it be difficult but perhaps Mackay was buying for the future and we will never know if he would have settled.

Look - you never know Norwich's striker has had a shit season, Swansea's a great one both had a similar record;

One thing for 100% in all clubs when you get a crazy motherfucker chairman interfering all the f*cking time pissing off the fans trying to sue other clubs etc etc it always fucks up.

Putting this all aside - HOW THE f**k can TAN criticise Mackay for Cornelius and then employ clueless OGS.

I wonder if all will humbly apologise when Norwich under Mackay are top.

Bunch of whining xxxxx - Mackay is a good manager and he would have motivated his players and brought the best out of them. Cornelius was injured and played in total 8 games, some off bench. It was always going it be difficult but perhaps Mackay was buying for the future and we will never know if he would have settled.

Look - you never know Norwich's striker has had a shit season, Swansea's a great one both had a similar record;

One thing for 100% in all clubs when you get a crazy motherfucker chairman interfering all the f*cking time pissing off the fans trying to sue other clubs etc etc it always fucks up.

Putting this all aside - HOW THE f**k can TAN criticise Mackay for Cornelius and then employ clueless OGS.

I wonder if all will humbly apologise when Norwich under Mackay are top.

But Jones done f**k all at Sheff Wednesday so that is just Tans opinion. He was the one who signed off the cheques so where is his apology for that then ? As per usual its never Tans fault

Cardiff City like all other businesses have owners who employ managers to manage their business.
Malky Mackay was employed to manage Cardiff City.
Part of his remit would be to find and recruit suitably talented players to represent us in our maiden season in the Premiership.
We all know Vincent Tan is not a football man so lacks some knowledge in this field, this puts the onus on Malky Mackay and his assistant Ian Moody to use their inside knowledge and football contacts to bring in suitable players for the club.
If they say Fred Bloggs is a sound investment at 8.5 million and £45,000 a week then any owner worth his salt would back up the managers recommendations as he would have more football knowledge than the owner, to refuse to sign off the cheques would be undermining his manager and therefore not trusting him to do his job properly.
If you employ someone to manage then you must trust them to do the job asked of them, failure to sign off cheques would be a show of mistrust.
Vincent Tan signed off the cheques yes but the players being paid for by those cheques were the choice of the manager..Tan was backing his managers decisions, if you can't back up your manager what's the point in having one?
Manager finds a player..owner finances purchase, each one trusting each other to do their part in the deal.

When he was banging on about nobody appreciating him, I was waiting for the interviewer to say "Oi! Mr T. If you changed the colours back you'd be a f*cking hero but".

No wonder he thinks we are all mad. Nobody seems to state the obvious about his red shit being the only reason we don't appreciate him.

It does sound like Malky really fucked up now. Sad to hear. I feel a bit let down as he seemed like such a nice bloke. Didn't like his tactics but he certainly looked like he gave a shit.

On reflection, it is disgraceful that he spent so much on a striker who even he didn't think was any good as he never played him. AND he has the same agent? Well dodgy I'm afraid.

I agree with Polo. Hate Tan for the rebrand but he seems spot on here.

But Jones done f**k all at Sheff Wednesday so that is just Tans opinion. He was the one who signed off the cheques so where is his apology for that then ? As per usual its never Tans fault

Thats just it adam the way tans talking its as if malky is the board to agree on fees and wages to be paid when we all know it has to be santioned by the board, i mean how can that be tans fault it never is

Malky was the football man and moody negotiated fees/wages. They were trusted with millions and they blew it.

what would be said if Tan had veteod the Acorn deal as he thought it wasnt right......you'd all be up in arms claiming he's interfering and that the manager should decide.

Beat Tan with the rebrand stick all you like but he gave the manager full control of a war chest and trusted his judgement to spend it wisely.......Malky fucked up!

But Jones done f**k all at Sheff Wednesday so that is just Tans opinion. He was the one who signed off the cheques so where is his apology for that then ? As per usual its never Tans fault

Thats just it adam the way tans talking its as if malky is the board to agree on fees and wages to be paid when we all know it has to be santioned by the board, i mean how can that be tans fault it never is

Malky was the football man and moody negotiated fees/wages. They were trusted with millions and they blew it.

what would be said if Tan had veteod the Acorn deal as he thought it wasnt right......you'd all be up in arms claiming he's interfering and that the manager should decide.

Beat Tan with the rebrand stick all you like but he gave the manager full control of a war chest and trusted his judgement to spend it wisely.......Malky fucked up!

Neither Malky or Moody are qualified to negotiate fees or salaries, they should never have been anywhere near the money, any sensible business would have negotiators who would negotiate the best price.

The person to blame is the person at the top.

But Jones done f**k all at Sheff Wednesday so that is just Tans opinion. He was the one who signed off the cheques so where is his apology for that then ? As per usual its never Tans fault

Thats just it adam the way tans talking its as if malky is the board to agree on fees and wages to be paid when we all know it has to be santioned by the board, i mean how can that be tans fault it never is

Malky was the football man and moody negotiated fees/wages. They were trusted with millions and they blew it.

what would be said if Tan had veteod the Acorn deal as he thought it wasnt right......you'd all be up in arms claiming he's interfering and that the manager should decide.

Beat Tan with the rebrand stick all you like but he gave the manager full control of a war chest and trusted his judgement to spend it wisely.......Malky fucked up!

Neither Malky or Moody are qualified to negotiate fees or salaries, they should never have been anywhere near the money, any sensible business would have negotiators who would negotiate the best price.

The person to blame is the person at the top.

Dont be so stupid

But Jones done f**k all at Sheff Wednesday so that is just Tans opinion. He was the one who signed off the cheques so where is his apology for that then ? As per usual its never Tans fault

Thats just it adam the way tans talking its as if malky is the board to agree on fees and wages to be paid when we all know it has to be santioned by the board, i mean how can that be tans fault it never is

Malky was the football man and moody negotiated fees/wages. They were trusted with millions and they blew it.

what would be said if Tan had veteod the Acorn deal as he thought it wasnt right......you'd all be up in arms claiming he's interfering and that the manager should decide.

Beat Tan with the rebrand stick all you like but he gave the manager full control of a war chest and trusted his judgement to spend it wisely.......Malky fucked up!

And what about Lim in all this Craig?

I find it difficult to believe Malky and Moody were left totally in chare of this sort of thing.

But Jones done f**k all at Sheff Wednesday so that is just Tans opinion. He was the one who signed off the cheques so where is his apology for that then ? As per usual its never Tans fault

Thats just it adam the way tans talking its as if malky is the board to agree on fees and wages to be paid when we all know it has to be santioned by the board, i mean how can that be tans fault it never is

Malky was the football man and moody negotiated fees/wages. They were trusted with millions and they blew it.

what would be said if Tan had veteod the Acorn deal as he thought it wasnt right......you'd all be up in arms claiming he's interfering and that the manager should decide.

Beat Tan with the rebrand stick all you like but he gave the manager full control of a war chest and trusted his judgement to spend it wisely.......Malky fucked up!

And what about Lim in all this Craig?

I find it difficult to believe Malky and Moody were left totally in chare of this sort of thing.

You find anything against Malky difficult to believe

Total contradiction by Tan on 2mins 30 secs,after slating MM for spending stupid money in the PL the interviewer says"but Malky took the club into the Prem" and Tan responds by saying "only because I give him £15m to spend",so Tan agrees that Malky spent well to get us to the PL.......The guy is deluded and totally rattled throughout with his swallowing and nervousness,not the guise of a Billionaire businessmen.

i never liked watching malkys team, bored me to shit, even in the promotion season.. his signings in the premiership were shocking..especially cornfoot, and the money wasted was incredible.. as for medel..11m for a defender uffffffffff. malky in my opinion is well over rated.. dave jones is the type of manager you have to keep you up, not take you up.. a manager who can find gems with no money..but lethal when you give him a few pounds.. lets see what ole can come up with after a summer of big changes.. then i will judge him..Tan would have and still would be very popular, until he started messing with tradition, he thinks we should all worship him because of his investment,, but we dont think like that here. we wont suck up to him just because he holds the purse strings if we dont like whats hes doing, maybe he should have done his homework on welsh culture before he started pissing about with colour and badge changes..i hope he wakes up and reverses the whole thing,, but my guess is that he has already agreed contracts for next seasons kit and its too late..

But Jones done f**k all at Sheff Wednesday so that is just Tans opinion. He was the one who signed off the cheques so where is his apology for that then ? As per usual its never Tans fault

Thats just it adam the way tans talking its as if malky is the board to agree on fees and wages to be paid when we all know it has to be santioned by the board, i mean how can that be tans fault it never is

Malky was the football man and moody negotiated fees/wages. They were trusted with millions and they blew it.

what would be said if Tan had veteod the Acorn deal as he thought it wasnt right......you'd all be up in arms claiming he's interfering and that the manager should decide.

Beat Tan with the rebrand stick all you like but he gave the manager full control of a war chest and trusted his judgement to spend it wisely.......Malky fucked up!

Neither Malky or Moody are qualified to negotiate fees or salaries, they should never have been anywhere near the money, any sensible business would have negotiators who would negotiate the best price.

The person to blame is the person at the top.

Dont be so stupid

Sorry but if you think its the norm for the manager to negotiate fees and salaries then your the stupid one.

Do you think them down the road will be giving Monk a wad of cash and saying spend wisely, doubt that very much, I remember reading after they sacked Laudrup that Laudrup said he had talked to a number of players and given the details to Jenkins but didn't know why they never signed.

I doubt very much if Wenger, Mourinho, Rodgers or even Fergurson when he was at Man Utd negotiated signing fees, salaries etc, all clubs are businesses and they employ people to do the negotiations or the person in charge will do it (owner/chairman), people who run the club and know what can be afforded.

As someone mentioned Lim was Tan's man at the club, why didnt he control the money?

There are a lot of questions that need asking, putting the blame on Malky for spending too much money is cowardy by Tsn, he accepts no responsibility at all.

I really like Malky and am totally against the rebrand, but Tan does have a point. We paid 8.5 million or whatever it was (and $45,000/week) to a player that a Championship side was looking at bringing in for $500,000. The striking issues were never addressed this season. After 38 games a goal here and a goal there keeps us up, even if we concede as many as we did. Whoever the manager was going to be, it was always going to be tough without a decent goal scorer.

Of course he has a point and i agree with him but hes still a total idiot even his latest thing on converting a little debt if we get back to the prem and a supposed compromise two years on just makes me cringe when it was ALL DEBT TO EQUITY just for turning red we was promised. The mans taking the piss out of us end of

£50 million is a tad more than a little debt. £50 million pounds is 50 MILLION POUNDS. Do you know how much £50 million pounds is? It's a lot of bloody money.

It's also not what VT promised when he suggested the rebrand. He's a liar.

What did he promise exactly?

'If I had not invested, he couldn't have (won promotion). Why didn't he earn promotion with Watford? He was their manager for two years, finishing 14th and then maybe 16th.
'When Dave Jones was here, he took us to the play-offs. Malky Mackay came here as a non-performer at Watford and I gave him £15million to spend"

If he was such a non-performer at Watford, then why did you appoint him?

But Jones done f**k all at Sheff Wednesday so that is just Tans opinion. He was the one who signed off the cheques so where is his apology for that then ? As per usual its never Tans fault

Thats just it adam the way tans talking its as if malky is the board to agree on fees and wages to be paid when we all know it has to be santioned by the board, i mean how can that be tans fault it never is

Malky was the football man and moody negotiated fees/wages. They were trusted with millions and they blew it.

what would be said if Tan had veteod the Acorn deal as he thought it wasnt right......you'd all be up in arms claiming he's interfering and that the manager should decide.

Beat Tan with the rebrand stick all you like but he gave the manager full control of a war chest and trusted his judgement to spend it wisely.......Malky fucked up!

Neither Malky or Moody are qualified to negotiate fees or salaries, they should never have been anywhere near the money, any sensible business would have negotiators who would negotiate the best price.

The person to blame is the person at the top.

Dont be so stupid

Sorry but if you think its the norm for the manager to negotiate fees and salaries then your the stupid one.

Do you think them down the road will be giving Monk a wad of cash and saying spend wisely, doubt that very much, I remember reading after they sacked Laudrup that Laudrup said he had talked to a number of players and given the details to Jenkins but didn't know why they never signed.

I doubt very much if Wenger, Mourinho, Rodgers or even Fergurson when he was at Man Utd negotiated signing fees, salaries etc, all clubs are businesses and they employ people to do the negotiations or the person in charge will do it (owner/chairman), people who run the club and know what can be afforded.

As someone mentioned Lim was Tan's man at the club, why didnt he control the money?

There are a lot of questions that need asking, putting the blame on Malky for spending too much money is cowardy by Tsn, he accepts no responsibility at all.

None of your examples had a "head of recruitment" we did. Malky said himself that he and Moody negotiated Medels contract after the Man Utd game.

Thr club said they had no football man in place so trusted Malky and Moody.

The only thing Tan is guilty of in this situation is trusting a rookie with too much money and power

Lim weren't even in the UK throughout the window until August.