FAO Annis

dj has proven before with wolves he can take a team up, he would of done times better than the milkman id guarantee it

Dave Jones had a far superior quality squad than Malky but failed to even get us up so can't see how you can claim that.

And a far smaller budget. Are you saying that DJ can put together a better squad than Malky with less Ian?

I agree with you that Dave Jones was better with money than Malky.

dj has proven before with wolves he can take a team up, he would of done times better than the milkman id guarantee it

Dave Jones had a far superior quality squad than Malky but failed to even get us up so can't see how you can claim that.

And a far smaller budget. Are you saying that DJ can put together a better squad than Malky with less Ian?

I agree with you that Dave Jones was better with money than Malky.

DJ was allowed to bring in Bellamy, Oli, Keogh, Drinkwater and Komaus on loan. Not cheap.

dj has proven before with wolves he can take a team up, he would of done times better than the milkman id guarantee it

Dave Jones had a far superior quality squad than Malky but failed to even get us up so can't see how you can claim that.

And a far smaller budget. Are you saying that DJ can put together a better squad than Malky with less Ian?

I agree with you that Dave Jones was better with money than Malky.

DJ was allowed to bring in Bellamy, Oli, Keogh, Drinkwater and Komaus on loan. Not cheap.

What i like to know is who brought in Ben Turner? Is he back in training, or still down in the stadium holding his hand up?

dj has proven before with wolves he can take a team up, he would of done times better than the milkman id guarantee it

Dave Jones had a far superior quality squad than Malky but failed to even get us up so can't see how you can claim that.

And a far smaller budget. Are you saying that DJ can put together a better squad than Malky with less Ian?

I agree with you that Dave Jones was better with money than Malky.

DJ was allowed to bring in Bellamy, Oli, Keogh, Drinkwater and Komaus on loan. Not cheap.

Malky had Bellamy too but on a permanent deal not most of his wages paid by Man City.

DJ bought cheap sold expensive.

Malky bought expensive sold cheap.

dj has proven before with wolves he can take a team up, he would of done times better than the milkman id guarantee it

Dave Jones had a far superior quality squad than Malky but failed to even get us up so can't see how you can claim that.

And a far smaller budget. Are you saying that DJ can put together a better squad than Malky with less Ian?

I agree with you that Dave Jones was better with money than Malky.

DJ was allowed to bring in Bellamy, Oli, Keogh, Drinkwater and Komaus on loan. Not cheap.

Malky had Bellamy too but on a permanent deal not most of his wages paid by Man City.

DJ bought cheap sold expensive.

Malky bought expensive sold cheap.

Neil so what?

The point is DJ had a better squad than Malky but could not get us over the finish line hence why he was sacked.

FAO annis

where is annis reply

dj has proven before with wolves he can take a team up, he would of done times better than the milkman id guarantee it

Dave Jones had a far superior quality squad than Malky but failed to even get us up so can't see how you can claim that.

And a far smaller budget. Are you saying that DJ can put together a better squad than Malky with less Ian?

I agree with you that Dave Jones was better with money than Malky.

DJ was allowed to bring in Bellamy, Oli, Keogh, Drinkwater and Komaus on loan. Not cheap.

Malky had Bellamy too but on a permanent deal not most of his wages paid by Man City.

DJ bought cheap sold expensive.

Malky bought expensive sold cheap.

Has Malky actually manager to sell anything

dj has proven before with wolves he can take a team up, he would of done times better than the milkman id guarantee it

Dave Jones had a far superior quality squad than Malky but failed to even get us up so can't see how you can claim that.

And a far smaller budget. Are you saying that DJ can put together a better squad than Malky with less Ian?

I agree with you that Dave Jones was better with money than Malky.

DJ was allowed to bring in Bellamy, Oli, Keogh, Drinkwater and Komaus on loan. Not cheap.

Malky had Bellamy too but on a permanent deal not most of his wages paid by Man City.

DJ bought cheap sold expensive.

Malky bought expensive sold cheap.

Has Malky actually manager to sell anything

dj has proven before with wolves he can take a team up, he would of done times better than the milkman id guarantee it

Dave Jones had a far superior quality squad than Malky but failed to even get us up so can't see how you can claim that.

And a far smaller budget. Are you saying that DJ can put together a better squad than Malky with less Ian?

I agree with you that Dave Jones was better with money than Malky.

DJ was allowed to bring in Bellamy, Oli, Keogh, Drinkwater and Komaus on loan. Not cheap.

Malky had Bellamy too but on a permanent deal not most of his wages paid by Man City.

DJ bought cheap sold expensive.

Malky bought expensive sold cheap.

Has Malky actually manager to sell anything

Yep Kenny Miller was his first huge mistake.

dj has proven before with wolves he can take a team up, he would of done times better than the milkman id guarantee it

Dave Jones had a far superior quality squad than Malky but failed to even get us up so can't see how you can claim that.

And a far smaller budget. Are you saying that DJ can put together a better squad than Malky with less Ian?

I agree with you that Dave Jones was better with money than Malky.

DJ was allowed to bring in Bellamy, Oli, Keogh, Drinkwater and Komaus on loan. Not cheap.

Malky had Bellamy too but on a permanent deal not most of his wages paid by Man City.

DJ bought cheap sold expensive.

Malky bought expensive sold cheap.

Neil so what?

The point is DJ had a better squad than Malky but could not get us over the finish line hence why he was sacked.

He had to sell his best players year on year. He didn't have the stability that Malky had. You say he had a better squad he did this with a smaller budget wheeling and dealing. If he was able to spend as much money as Malky he would have smashed the championship rather than crawl over the line like Malky did playing shite football. He also would have had better players and a better squad more prepared for the Premiership.

All my opinion of course.

Has Malky actually manager to sell anything

I always thought that a manager was supposed to BUY good players & not sell them.

Which Malky did very well indeed in the championship. I'm sure if we tried to sell some of Malky's signings, we would get some very good money indeed.

Has Malky actually manager to sell anything

I always thought that a manager was supposed to BUY good players & not sell them.

Which Malky did very well indeed in the championship. I'm sure if we tried to sell some of Malky's signings, we would get some very good money indeed.

Velikonja?

Velikonja?

Mutch? No one? Campbell? Maynard? Turner? Mason?

Easy to name players. Could also point to some absolutely fabulous DJ striker flops. We always had one every season.

Both good managers, but to compare them by what they sold, rather than quality they bought, is lunacy.

Velikonja?

Mutch? No one? Campbell? Maynard? Turner? Mason?

Easy to name players. Could also point to some absolutely fabulous DJ striker flops. We always had one every season.

Both good managers, but to compare them by what they sold, rather than quality they bought, is lunacy.

See, exactly! No one!!!

Point nicely swerved.

Both great managers who served us well. If I remember right Malky did an outstanding job on a similar (possibly reduced) budget to Jones in 2011/2012.

Point nicely swerved.

Velikonja?

Mutch? No one? Campbell? Maynard? Turner? Mason?

Easy to name players. Could also point to some absolutely fabulous DJ striker flops. We always had one every season.

Both good managers, but to compare them by what they sold, rather than quality they bought, is lunacy.

Nah its true. Due to the different circumstance its like trying to compare apples and oranges. Both good in their own way, both bad. Just couldn't resist the opportunity for a joke at the No One

dj has proven before with wolves he can take a team up, he would of done times better than the milkman id guarantee it

Dave Jones had a far superior quality squad than Malky but failed to even get us up so can't see how you can claim that.

And a far smaller budget. Are you saying that DJ can put together a better squad than Malky with less Ian?

I agree with you that Dave Jones was better with money than Malky.

DJ was allowed to bring in Bellamy, Oli, Keogh, Drinkwater and Komaus on loan. Not cheap.

Malky had Bellamy too but on a permanent deal not most of his wages paid by Man City.

DJ bought cheap sold expensive.

Malky bought expensive sold cheap.

Neil so what?

The point is DJ had a better squad than Malky but could not get us over the finish line hence why he was sacked.

thats a ridiculous argument.........he had a better squas for much less cash......that does mean he is a lot better manager.

Has Malky actually manager to sell anything

I always thought that a manager was supposed to BUY good players & not sell them.

Which Malky did very well indeed in the championship. I'm sure if we tried to sell some of Malky's signings, we would get some very good money indeed.

the 1st line sums it up..........Malky was allowed to keep...DJ was not...and infact,the one player he managed to hang on to,many slaughter him for not selling..Ledley

Velikonja?

Mutch? No one? Campbell? Maynard? Turner? Mason?

Easy to name players. Could also point to some absolutely fabulous DJ striker flops. We always had one every season.

Both good managers, but to compare them by what they sold, rather than quality they bought, is lunacy.

We shall see in the summer once we are relegated.

Mutch too injury prone to get more than we paid IMHO
Noone inconsistent
Turner no pace
Mason. Stagnated and where is he?
Maynard will never get 2.5 million for him
Campbell. Top clubs or even middle clubs won't be queueing to buy him.

dj has proven before with wolves he can take a team up, he would of done times better than the milkman id guarantee it

Dave Jones had a far superior quality squad than Malky but failed to even get us up so can't see how you can claim that.

And a far smaller budget. Are you saying that DJ can put together a better squad than Malky with less Ian?

I agree with you that Dave Jones was better with money than Malky.

DJ was allowed to bring in Bellamy, Oli, Keogh, Drinkwater and Komaus on loan. Not cheap.

Malky had Bellamy too but on a permanent deal not most of his wages paid by Man City.

DJ bought cheap sold expensive.

Malky bought expensive sold cheap.

Neil so what?

The point is DJ had a better squad than Malky but could not get us over the finish line hence why he was sacked.

thats a ridiculous argument.........he had a better squas for much less cash......that does mean he is a lot better manager.

And how much value do you think the loanees under DJ would have cost?

dj has proven before with wolves he can take a team up, he would of done times better than the milkman id guarantee it

Dave Jones had a far superior quality squad than Malky but failed to even get us up so can't see how you can claim that.

And a far smaller budget. Are you saying that DJ can put together a better squad than Malky with less Ian?

I agree with you that Dave Jones was better with money than Malky.

DJ was allowed to bring in Bellamy, Oli, Keogh, Drinkwater and Komaus on loan. Not cheap.

Malky had Bellamy too but on a permanent deal not most of his wages paid by Man City.

DJ bought cheap sold expensive.

Malky bought expensive sold cheap.

Neil so what?

The point is DJ had a better squad than Malky but could not get us over the finish line hence why he was sacked.

thats a ridiculous argument.........he had a better squas for much less cash......that does mean he is a lot better manager.

And how much value do you think the loanees under DJ would have cost?

Not much, thats why they were allowed out on loan.

Although Stephen Bywater was a £10m plus player ifever I saw one

Velikonja?

Mutch? No one? Campbell? Maynard? Turner? Mason?

Easy to name players. Could also point to some absolutely fabulous DJ striker flops. We always had one every season.

Both good managers, but to compare them by what they sold, rather than quality they bought, is lunacy.

We shall see in the summer once we are relegated.

Mutch too injury prone to get more than we paid IMHO
Noone inconsistent
Turner no pace
Mason. Stagnated and where is he?
Maynard will never get 2.5 million for him
Campbell. Top clubs or even middle clubs won't be queueing to buy him.

The only 2 players that will be sold are Medel and caulker IMO. No one else will pay decent money for any other player except maybe Marshall. Cardiff have no need to sell players on the cheap, so players like mutch will not go unless a decent offer comes in IMO. No one will want to buy any else besides them 4 anyway.

dj has proven before with wolves he can take a team up, he would of done times better than the milkman id guarantee it

Dave Jones had a far superior quality squad than Malky but failed to even get us up so can't see how you can claim that.

And a far smaller budget. Are you saying that DJ can put together a better squad than Malky with less Ian?

I agree with you that Dave Jones was better with money than Malky.

DJ was allowed to bring in Bellamy, Oli, Keogh, Drinkwater and Komaus on loan. Not cheap.

Malky had Bellamy too but on a permanent deal not most of his wages paid by Man City.

DJ bought cheap sold expensive.

Malky bought expensive sold cheap.

Neil so what?

The point is DJ had a better squad than Malky but could not get us over the finish line hence why he was sacked.

thats a ridiculous argument.........he had a better squas for much less cash......that does mean he is a lot better manager.

And how much value do you think the loanees under DJ would have cost?

i know its been pushed that these were on mega bucks.........but the wage bill was the same in malkys 1st year as Djs last....thats what the club say.........and thats without Bellamy who had gone back....so across the board,Malky had players of greater worth......Malkys 2nd year..well he spent a fortune in the transfer market......had bellamy back..and the wage bill rocketed.

Annis not having a go but you keep on about Malky taking us up but lets face it he had a huge budget, I honestly think Dave Jones would have taken us up with that budget and playing a better brand of football .

i have to agree dave jones would of but he would of still fucked up like malky did and would of got the sack

you reckon DJ would have spent 8 million on Acorn?.

But he did not buy acorn in the budget that took us up did he. Malky got us promoted on a 15 million pound budget which I am sure a few clubs in the championship would settle for. In regards to your acorn comment then it was almost inevitable that Malky would sign at least one or 2 players who did not make the grade especially as he had to almost build a new team.

Annis not having a go but you keep on about Malky taking us up but lets face it he had a huge budget, I honestly think Dave Jones would have taken us up with that budget and playing a better brand of football .

" Can We All just lay this to rest once and for All Please "
link
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=139560

Velikonja?

Mutch? No one? Campbell? Maynard? Turner? Mason?

Easy to name players. Could also point to some absolutely fabulous DJ striker flops. We always had one every season.

Both good managers, but to compare them by what they sold, rather than quality they bought, is lunacy.

We shall see in the summer once we are relegated.

Mutch too injury prone to get more than we paid IMHO
Noone inconsistent
Turner no pace
Mason. Stagnated and where is he?
Maynard will never get 2.5 million for him
Campbell. Top clubs or even middle clubs won't be queueing to buy him.

The only 2 players that will be sold are Medel and caulker IMO. No one else will pay decent money for any other player except maybe Marshall. Cardiff have no need to sell players on the cheap, so players like mutch will not go unless a decent offer comes in IMO. No one will want to buy any else besides them 4 anyway.

Medel will not be sold unless he has a class World Cup. Marshall was a DJ signing.