Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Re: 'That' E-Mail

Sun Jan 05, 2014 9:19 pm

I know I started the thread but I'm not anti Malky and greatful for all he done for us. But it was just what I heard and 100% there is more to the story.

I also hope the biggest supporters of Malky do not take it out on OGS. It's not his fault and on Saturday the team really need our support

Re: 'That' E-Mail

Sun Jan 05, 2014 9:25 pm

Daio85 wrote:I know I started the thread but I'm not anti Malky and greatful for all he done for us. But it was just what I heard and 100% there is more to the story.

I also hope the biggest supporters of Malky do not take it out on OGS. It's not his fault and on Saturday the team really need our support


Your right. There is 100% more to this story.

Re: 'That' E-Mail

Sun Jan 05, 2014 9:46 pm

Forever Blue wrote:
CraigCCFC wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:
Deano1 wrote:all absolute bollocks. How can a manager 'take' money from a deal without a billionaire businessman, who either signs, or has his his lackeys sign cheques, knowing about it......



Spot on again :thumbup:

They need to speak to Simon Lim, Tans right hand man :thumbup: :thumbup:

How is that spot on?

I dont believe Malky took a bung, but its not hard to cover up if your working with an agent. Agent gives you cash and he adds it on to his fees in the contract.


Craig, why are some of u, including yourself trying to throw dirt on our greatest ever manager?
Rem Tan stripped our club of our identity and has lied non stop and is not a man of his word.
Rem Tan said we would keep our identity and 5 days later stripped us, a fact not gossip.

Now please give Malky some credit for his great achievements at our club :thumbup: :thumbup:


Annis, Fred Stewart achieved more then MM so how can you come to that conclusion that MM was our greatest ever manager?

Re: 'That' E-Mail

Sun Jan 05, 2014 9:55 pm

Forever Blue wrote:Craig, why are some of u, including yourself trying to throw dirt on our greatest ever manager?
:


Wow now gone from probably our best ever manager to our greatest ever manager. Annis, even you have admitted the football had been crap under Malky. Just because he got us up like several other manager's have in the distant past doesn't make him our GREATEST ever manager. Please explain why he was better than Fred Stewart who managed to achieve the below on a shoestring and also Cyril Spiers and Bill jones who also took us to the Premiership (then Division 1) with no money to spend


Division One Runner-up: 1
1923–24
Division Two Runner-up: 1
1920–21
FA Cup Winner: 1
1926–27
FA Cup Runner-up: 1
1924–25
FA Charity Shield Winner: 1
1927–28
Welsh Cup Winner: 5
1921–22, 1922–23, 1926–27, 1927–28, 1929–30
Welsh Cup Runner-up: 1
1928–29

Re: 'That' E-Mail

Sun Jan 05, 2014 10:28 pm

I actually meant one of our greatest managers we have ever had and history will show that :thumbup:
Why are u all so intent on attacking Malky. :roll: :roll:

Just remind your selves of what Malky achieved. :ayatollah:

Re: 'That' E-Mail

Sun Jan 05, 2014 10:45 pm

I think Malky Macky behind the scene was one of the best managers we ever had.

But on the pitch his tactics and substitutions bored me silly, no Annis to be a great manager, you have to get up in the morning and get most of your plans for the day 90% right and at the end of the day get all your decisions 95% right.

Malky was an up and coming manager with a lot to learn and admit when you're wrong, I heard a lot of reasons why he thought he was right, but never one reason why he was wrong, like why did he play Whittingham as a defensive midfielder, he killed him, until he lost his natural ability to put a long accurate pass, like his ability to put the ball in the top corner, remember in the Swansea game when we had a free kick from their goalkeeper being sent off, they had a stand in goal keeper, and where did whits put the free ?, right in the center of the goal where the stand in just guided the shot over the bar.

Personnaly from a football fan's point of view I'm glad he has gone, but the best of luck to him wherever he goes.

Re: 'That' E-Mail

Mon Jan 06, 2014 2:11 am

Forever Blue wrote:I actually meant one of our greatest managers we have ever had and history will show that :thumbup:
Why are u all so intent on attacking Malky. :roll: :roll:

Just remind your selves of what Malky achieved. :ayatollah:


Yes he achieved it but many of us have come to the conclusion that many other managers would just have likely achieved it on the back of the budget he was given and the piss poor championship sides he had to beat. His footballing style was awful and he turned out to be not quite the saint he portrayed himself to be.. It will be interesting to see how the rest of his career turns out but I for one am glad he has gone as I hated the football he was playing